BONUS: Can a Woman Ever Be Pope?

BONUS: Can a Woman Ever Be Pope?

Author: Liam Heffernan November 29, 2025 Duration: 12:34

In this bonus episode, we dive deeper into the intriguing question of whether a woman could ever become pope. Plus, we discuss the current hierarchical structure of the Catholic Church and the significant barriers women face in being ordained.

We also come back to the goodness that Pope Leo XIV seems to embody, suggesting that regardless of religious titles, it's the inherent kindness that truly matters.

...

Special guest for this episode:

  • Kathleen Cummings, a professor of history and American studies at the University of Notre Dame, with a focus on the history of women, Catholicism and American religion. Her books include A Saint of Our Own: How the Quest for a Holy Hero Helped Catholics Become American.
  • John Doughney, a childhood friend of Pope Leo. They attended Catholic school together in Chicago, and he now lives in Texas, running a beautiful stained glass business with his wife.

...

Highlights from this episode:

  • The Catholic Church's hierarchical structure makes it highly unlikely for women to become priests in the near future, let alone a pope.
  • The slow pace of change within the Catholic Church means that any significant reforms will take generations to implement, if they happen at all.
  • Pope Leo XIV's past education under female theologians suggests potential for progressive change, but resistance remains strong regarding women's ordination.
  • The idea of faith as a justification for values is discussed, emphasizing that goodness is not inherently linked to religious beliefs.
  • John's reflections on growing up in a blue-collar family highlight how community and tradition shape individual values and beliefs.
  • The conversation touches on the intersection of faith, politics, and morality, urging listeners to reflect on the true essence of serving one's fellow man.

...

Additional Resources:

A Saint of Our Own: How the Quest for a Holy Hero Helped Catholics Become American by Kathleen Cummings

'We knew there was something special about him,' says childhood friend of Pope Leo

How a humble Chicago schoolboy Robert Prevost with a veteran father rose to become America's first Pope  by the Daily Mail

Pope Leo XIV: Robert Prévost arrived in Chulucanas, Peru in 1985 by the Peru News Agency

Stained Glass by John & Nancy Doughney

...

And if you like this episode, you might also love:

What Was the Constitutional Convention?

Why Does the President Only Serve Two Terms?

Is the President Above the...


Hosted by Liam Heffernan, America: The Story of the USA is a deep and ongoing conversation about the forces that have shaped the nation. This isn't just a history lesson; it's an exploration of how the past directly informs today's headlines and cultural shifts. Each episode brings together a remarkable range of voices, from Nobel laureates and acclaimed historians to veteran journalists, to dissect pivotal moments and current events with nuance and depth. You'll hear discussions that connect the dots between a centuries-old political decision and a modern social movement, or examine a breaking news story through the lens of long-standing cultural patterns. The aim is to provide a richer, more connected understanding of the American experience in all its complexity. By weaving together threads from history, politics, society, and culture, this podcast offers a comprehensive and thoughtful narrative. For those who want to look beyond the soundbites and understand the deeper currents running through the United States, this series serves as an essential and engaging resource. Tune in for a consistently insightful analysis that treats the American story as the living, evolving saga that it truly is.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

America: The Story of the USA
Podcast Episodes
BONUS: Why Didn't Nixon Destroy the Watergate Tapes? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 10:49
In this bonus episode, UCL's Professor Iwan Morgan, author of Nixon, discusses why the President refused to destroy the Oval Office tapes - the most incriminating piece of evidence that ultimately led to his resignation…
Who is the Emperor of the United States of America? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 45:31
On this day in 1869, self-proclaimed Emperor Norton of the USA issued an order, abolishing the Democratic and Republican parties.Confused? I’m not surprised. So this week we’re going to unpack one of the more bizarre and…
BONUS: Hoagies, Grammar Police, and Momphoria [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 9:43
In this bonus episode, linguistics professor Valerie Fridland discusses her favourite American accents, invents a new slang word, and chats with Liam about some of the everyday differences between American and English...…
IN THE MAKING: Can Donald Trump Run for President in 2028? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 10:29
The short answer is no (sorry MAGA), at least not without a change to the constitution. So in this episode of America: A History in the Making, I explore the main constitutional barriers to a Trump third term, and why ch…
Why Did President Richard Nixon Resign? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 44:53
This week marks the 51st anniversary of a truly unique event in American history. The one and only time a President left the White House by choice. Not due to death or the 22nd amendment, but resignation. Never before an…
IN THE MAKING: Comparing the Epstein Files to Nixon's Watergate Tapes [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 11:06
Liam here, and in this impromptu edition of America: A History in the Making, I look into the parallels between the Nixon administration's Watergate scandal and the ongoing controversy surrounding the Epstein files, disc…
Why Do Americans Speak Differently? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 46:52
This week we are talking about talking.The United States of America is a diverse country - geographically, demographically, and culturally, where every state has its own unique sense of identity. And a big part of that i…
BONUS: Why Isn't Frances Perkins a Household Name? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 9:53
Frances Perkins, the first female cabinet member in U.S. history, was a powerhouse in American politics, yet her legacy often flies under the radar.In this bonus discussion, we get into why Perkins isn't as well-remember…