127. Killer Con Woman Brenda Nicholas and Melbourne Mick Sayers

127. Killer Con Woman Brenda Nicholas and Melbourne Mick Sayers

Author: Tara Sariban and Barney Black September 16, 2019 Duration: 1:07:12

Killer Con Woman Brenda Nicholas and Melbourne Mick Sayers...

Brenda Nicholas was a con artist and thief who preyed on elderly people. She often pretended to be a tarot reader named “Lady Monica,” who gained their trust before taking them for all they were worth. In 2011, she and her ragtag gang of petty criminals stabbed 70-year-old Navy veteran and two-time Purple Heart recipient Patrick Fleming to death, just so they could steal his valuable coin collection.

Lovable rogue Michael "Melbourne Mick" Sayers was always looking for the next sure thing. This chronic punter had a life-long pathological addiction to gambling. Mick had it so bad, he would bet on anything and do whatever it took to feed his habit, including race fixing, armed robbery, drug dealing and murder. Drinking buddies with the likes of Neddy Smith and Graham Henry, after the fixing of Fine Cotton, in the end all he had to wager was the last thing of value he had... his life.


Become a Bloody Murder Patron (for as little as $1 per month, which you cancel at anytime) and have access to dozens of Patron only episodes (including our whole first season!) with new patron only content added every month!

Go to https://www.patreon.com/bloodymurder


Also Levels $5 and over go into our monthly merchandise draws and get FREE stickers and hand-made Barney Badges!

See our website! bloodymurderpodcast.com for all our social media links, contact details, a gallery, fabulous merchandise (check out our new Bloody Murder SHOES! and now STICKERS and BACKPACKS and DUFFEL BAGS!!) and much much more.


Wanna buy us a drink? Here's a donate link.


Thanks to Angela Hayden for her TCNT on Mindhunters Season 2.

True Crime Nerd Time, a segment on Bloody Murder, needs your help because it stars you! We want you, our listeners, to submit your recommendations for anything true cime related! It could be books, TV shows, movies, documentaries, exhibitions, graphic novels, art, music etc. So send us your brief story (we’ll read it out) or record your story (it can just be a recording on your phone, and we’ll play it!). We will also publish it on our website. Keep it to about 2 mins please or 200 words. Email here! bloodymurderpodcast@gmail.com. Oh and if you give us your postal address we'll send you some stickers as a reward!


Aussie As: A mullet-wearing bloke with face-tattoo's goes on a rather unique robbery spree.



Brenda Nicholas Sources: Killer Scammer: The True Story Of Brenda Nicholas, 2017, Ana Benson, Woman sentenced in vicious killing of Seattle veteran, Seattle News, Sara Jean Green, August 9, 2013,Seattle woman charged in gruesome murder of elderly Navy vet, Komo News, Conor Christofferson, November 1st 2012. Man arrested in Seattle torture, stabbing dea, Seattle 911 Police and Crime Blog, Casey McNerthney, August 17, 2012. Vietnam Veteran Francis Patrick Fleming, US Navy, Targeted & Stabbed to Death By Brenda Nicholas & Charles Jungbluth for $60,000 Coin Collection, Military Justice For All, December 8th, 2011. Torture, rare coins, psychic readings key elements in brutal slaying, Kiro7 News, November 8th, 2012. 3rd person charged in December slaying of North Seattle man, the Seattle Times, Jennifer Sullivan, November 1st, 2012. Woman sentenced in vicious killing of Seattle veteran, the Seattle Times, Sara Jean...


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


Hosted by Tara Sariban and Barney Black, Bloody Murder-A True Crime Podcast digs into the darker corners of history, focusing on crimes that haven't been covered to exhaustion elsewhere. This award-nominated show explores lesser-known cases from Australia and across the globe, offering detailed narratives that are often overlooked. What sets this podcast apart is its unique tone-a blend of deep research and unexpected comedy that arises naturally from the hosts' dynamic and their own perspective as dedicated true crime fans. The humour is careful and considered, never mocking the victims or the gravity of the events discussed. Instead, it's the odd tangent, the personal reaction, or the absurdity surrounding a case that provides a moment of levity, making the exploration of difficult topics more engaging. Listeners will find a conversation that feels like joining two friends who are equally fascinated and critical, dissecting the how and why while treating the subject with respect. Each episode aims to add a fresh voice to the genre, prioritizing stories that are compelling precisely because they aren't the ones you've already heard a dozen times. It’s this commitment to uncovering obscure tales, paired with a genuinely distinctive rapport between the hosts, that defines the experience of this particular true crime podcast.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Bloody Murder - A True Crime Podcast
Podcast Episodes
98. The Vampire of Paris and Gangster Chow Hayes [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:24:25
The Vampire of Paris and Gangster Chow Hayes...Nicolas Claux was a blood-drinking, cannibalistic hospital worker whose hobbies included desecrating graves and worshipping Satan. Nicknamed "The Vampire of Paris," this dea…
97. Murderous Mary and the Vanishing of Paddy Moriarty [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:01:47
Murderous Mary and the Vanishing of Paddy Moriarty...Described as a woman with "lovely russet hair, fine blue eyes, of normal build, with nice shapely hands" Mary Pearcey was a rather unconventional English woman who was…
96. Bloody Babs and You Me Car Park Now! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 58:50
Bloody Babs and You Me Car Park Now!...Nicknamed "Bloody Babs" by the press, vamp from the wrong side of the tracks, Barbra Graham had multiple convictions for disorderly conduct, vagrancy, suspicion of prostitution and…
95. The Killer Bride and Take my Last Beers and I'll Kill You! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:02:06
The Killer Bride and Take my Last Beers and I'll Kill You...Ashley Laney and Tracey Humphrey were married on the 4th of July, 2003. The next day, Ashley murdered Tracey’s ex-girlfriend Sandra Rosso, who was due to go to…
93. The Lies of Teri Deneka and The Chicken Millionaire [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:22:03
The Lies of Teri Deneka and The Chicken Millionaire...Divorced father of two Don Huckstep thought he’d met the woman he wanted to spend the rest of his life with on match.com. But as his wedding to Teri Deneka grew close…
92. The Sinister Minister and The Mad Scientist [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:19:22
The Sinister Minister and The Mad Scientist...Pennsylvania Pastor AB Schirmer’s wives had an unfortunate habit of dying suddenly in - rather ridiculous circumstances. Due to his stature, nobody thought to be suspicious o…
91. The Abduction of Stephanie Slater and Murder by the River Lark [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:00:00
The Abduction of Stephanie Slater and Murder by the River Lark...Michael Sams was a one legged rapist, murderer and piss-poor extortion artist. After he abducted real estate agent Stephanie Slater, the police thought she…
87. Australian Gothic - The Murder of Angelo Agostinelli [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 42:11
Australian Gothic - The Murder of Angelo Agostinelli...In May 1994, caravan park owner Angelo Agostinelli went missing from the small town of Millicent in South Australia. The gossip around town was that he'd run off wit…