#334: Nothing's Done It Better

#334: Nothing's Done It Better

Author: Board Game Barrage May 15, 2025 Duration: 51:32

Well, we finally did it. We played CATAN, and it was ... good! And then we started wondering, is there anything that's done quite the same thing that that game is doing? And then that got us wondering how many games there are like that, where it's genuinely hard to say that nothing has done it better since. And then that got us wondering if, instead of all this wondering, we should record a podcast episode. Before we wander, we talk about Box Two, Catan: Cities & Knights, and An Infamous Traffic.

02:47 - Box Two
09:18 - Catan: Cities & Knights
19:50 - An Infamous Traffic
31:58 - Has anyone done it better?
32:26 - Catan
35:55 - Concordia
36:17 - Rise of Tribes
37:31 - Space Base
39:26 - Archipelago
40:38 - Dominion
41:17 - Aeon's End
42:22 - Star Realms
42:32 - Shards of Infinity
44:43 - Diplomacy
44:59 - Dune
46:48 - Battle for Rokugan
47:04 - A Game of Thrones: The Board Game (Second Edition)

Get added to the BGB community map at:
https://boardgamebarrage.com/map

Send us topic ideas at:
https://boardgamebarrage.com/topics

Check out our wiki at:
https://boardgamebarrage.com/wiki

Join the discussion at:
https://boardgamebarrage.com/discord

Join our Facebook group at:
https://boardgamebarrage.com/facebook

Get a Board Game Barrage T-shirt at:
https://boardgamebarrage.com/store


Board Game Barrage is a weekly conversation with Kellen, Neilan, Mark, and Christina that feels like pulling up a chair at a lively game night. The discussion centers on the board games they’ve actually been playing, from the newest releases causing a stir to older titles that deserve another look. You’ll hear their distinct personalities and opinions clash and align as they debate strategies, dissect mechanics, and share those memorable, often hilarious moments that happen around the table. This isn’t a formal review show, but a genuine chronicle of their hobby. The heart of the podcast lies in its focus on the social experience of gaming-how to navigate different player styles, keep the atmosphere positive, and ultimately enjoy the company and the competition, regardless of who comes out on top. It’s about the shared stories that emerge from a box of cardboard and wood. Each episode is a deep dive into what makes games fun, frustrating, and fascinating, delivered with a blend of enthusiasm and friendly critique. Tune in to Board Game Barrage for an authentic, unscripted look at the modern board gaming landscape through the eyes of four dedicated friends who love to talk about what they play.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Board Game Barrage
Podcast Episodes
#318: A Mix of Things We'd Like To See with Mike DiLisio [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:08:56
The Fandango Tank returns! The ever wonderful Mike DiLisio joins us again, this time to collectively cast our minds forward to some things we'd like to manifest into the board game future. We've got a mess of ideas, a ve…
#317: Fantasy Draft: Overrated Games [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:11:24
So we've done a lot of these drafts before, but I don't think we've done one quite like this. This time we're each trying to draft a set of five games that we think you might agree are incredibly overrated. What does tha…
#316: Four Heads Are Better Than One [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 53:48
I'm in a bit of a quandary here, because Mark told me not to tell you what this episode is even about, but I want this description to be, well, descriptive but he's glaring at me really hard, and making a throat slitting…
#315: Essen SPIEL 2024 Hype List [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:01:28
We may or may not be going to Germany (who can say), but that's where all the good gaming is gonna be, so that's what we're gonna talk about. It's almost Essen SPIEL! That sure is a lot of games debuting there though, so…
#314: Bringing Out the Best in People [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 59:23
It's about people, right? Below all the mechanics, after all the rules explanations, beyond every crushing loss and glorious win, what really matters is people we're playing with. Some games make that more apparent than…
#313: That Don't Impress Me Much [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 59:24
The only thing worse than coming away from a first game with a really bad impression, is when it takes a really long time to shake. Imagine all the amazing games you're not playing because of one bad first game! Whether…
#312: Fantasy Draft: Spiel des Jahres Winners [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 56:16
It's awards season, which means that Germany's back to tell us what games are popping off over there. And that also means we're back to tell you what we think about what they think. More than that - we're looking through…
#311: Of Lovers and Travel [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 56:14
We've all been travelling about so much recently (some of us may or may not still be) that we often find ourselves asking, "what games should I pack?" Some games are better suited for playing on the go than others, and w…
#310: Bob's Decade Delights [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:17:03
Bob's back from his trip to 2014, and oh the wonders he's seen - games that not only were amazing back then, but somehow we're still talking about today! The counterpoint to our draft of games to last a decade, we're arg…
#309: Moretuary [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 50:00
More isn't always better, but that's sometimes a hard lesson to learn in the world of board games - we dig into an intriguing listener suggestion about how games (and gamers) can often fall into this trap. Also ... I gue…