True Compassion or Idiot Compassion?

True Compassion or Idiot Compassion?

Author: Susan Piver April 25, 2025 Duration: 20:27

Send us Fan Mail

In Buddhism (as in most wisdom traditions), compassion is central—but it’s often misunderstood. It’s not about being nice, it’s about being awake. True compassion is wise, fierce, and rooted in awareness.

“Idiot compassion” is a term coined by Chögyam Trungpa to describe misguided kindness that stems from the three poisons:

  • Grasping – trying to feel good or be liked.

  • Aggression – trying to control or make something (or someone) disappear.

  • Delusion – trying to avoid seeing what is really going on.

True compassion requires discernment, not people-pleasing. It might mean being sweet, but it could also mean getting angry or saying nothing. The only way to know is by paying attention.

In activism, the same principle applies: if our actions come from hate, they’ll echo hate. If they come from a broken heart longing to ease suffering, different gates will open.

There are two kinds of compassion to consider:

  • Relative compassion helps others through kindness and care.

  • Absolute compassion is dwelling in perfect recognition of interdependence. (To learn more about this, see previous episodes on the Heart Sutra.)

The spiritual path is just as much about courage as it is about kindness. It asks us to meet suffering not with spiritual bypassing, but with a heart shattered open and ready to serve.


SM (for Genevieve)

Not all compassion is created equal.

In Buddhism, compassion isn’t about being nice. It’s about being awake.

Sometimes it’s soft. Sometimes it’s fierce. But it’s never about avoiding discomfort.

Chögyam Trungpa called it “idiot compassion” when our desire to help is rooted in:

• Craving (to be liked)

• Aggression (to control or avoid conflict)

• Delusion (pretending everything’s fine)

Real compassion comes from clarity.

It doesn’t always look “spiritual.” Sometimes it sets boundaries. Sometimes it says no. And when rooted in heartbreak for the suffering of the world, it becomes powerful.

Let’s remember that true love can also be fierce. 🔥

#compassion #buddhism #idiotcompassion #fiercelove #spiritualpath #openheart #wakeup #chogyamtrungpa #realcompassion #awareness



If you enjoyed this episode:

Please rate, review, and share it with a friend who’s curious about mindfulness, spiritual commitment, or the Buddhist path.

For more on Buddhist teachings and how our humanity isn’t necessarily in our way, sign up for my free weekly newsletter or join the Open Heart Project sangha for more connection with community and with me.

If this podcast has been meaningful to you, it would be great if you would subscribe, give it a five star rating and share it with a friend. To join or learn more about The Open Heart Project please visit openheartproject.com.

Thoughts? Email us at info@susanpiver.com

Produced by Citizens of Sound

Music by: Derek O'Brien

©Open Heart Project 


In Buddhism Beyond Belief with Susan Piver, ancient wisdom meets the messy reality of modern living. Susan Piver, drawing from three decades as a student of Tibetan Buddhism and her experience guiding the nearly 20,000-member Open Heart Project meditation community, acts as a thoughtful companion rather than a distant teacher. This isn't about scholarly lectures; it's a conversation. You'll hear explorations of foundational concepts-the four noble truths, the six paramitas, and more-but always through the lens of direct, personal application. The focus is on how these teachings can resonate in the middle of a busy workday, within complex relationships, or during moments of quiet doubt. Each episode of this podcast feels like a genuine discussion about integrating contemplative practice into all aspects of life, from physical health and spiritual curiosity to navigating everyday stress. The aim is to move past doctrine and into direct experience, offering practical insights for cultivating resilience, compassion, and a sense of groundedness. Whether you're well-versed in Buddhist thought or simply curious about a more mindful approach to fitness, health, and personal growth, Susan's guidance is both accessible and deeply authentic. Tune in for a perspective that values lived understanding over belief, creating space for clarity and an open heart amid the noise.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 52

Buddhism Beyond Belief with Susan Piver
Podcast Episodes
Meditation, Rage, and Other Strong Emotions [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 12:16
Send us Fan MailWhy do we turn to meditation when things fall apart—and what are we really supposed to do with all these overwhelming emotions? In this short episode, we explore three powerful ways to relate to difficult…
Why You’re Not Meditating Consistently (and What to Do About It) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 28:11
Send us Fan MailIn this episode, Susan reflects on one of the most common meditation struggles: staying consistent. If you’ve ever wondered, “Why can’t I just do the thing I know is good for me?”—this episode is for you.…
Who Can You Trust in the Spiritual World? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 25:32
Send us Fan MailTrusting a spiritual teacher is one of the most important—and complex—decisions on the path. This talk explores three personal experiences: one with a brilliant but inscrutable and controversial teacher,…
Inexplicable Joy: Emptiness, Compassion, and the Heart Sutra, Part 2 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 25:02
Send us Fan MailIn the previous episode, we discuss a teaching that is central throughout the Buddhist world: the Prajnaparamita sutra, also known as The Heart Sutra. While being utterly confounding, at the same time it…
Inexplicable Joy: Emptiness, Compassion, and the Heart Sutra, Part 1 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 23:08
Send us Fan MailIn this episode, we discuss a teaching that is central throughout the Buddhist world: the Prajnaparamita sutra, also known as The Heart Sutra. While being utterly confounding, at the same time it is a per…
The Four Noble Truths and the Middle Way: Foundations of the Journey [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 18:56
Send us Fan MailThe Buddha’s Early Life & AwakeningSiddhartha was a protected prince, shielded from suffering by his father.He encountered old age, sickness, and death for the first time during a trip outside the palace.…
The Broken Hearted Meditator [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 14:14
Send us Fan MailPerhaps contrary to popular belief, meditation does not make us feel all zen. Rather, it actually makes us feel more deeply.Discussed in this episode:Meditation Heightens Emotions – It doesn’t numb feelin…
On Road Rage and Compassion [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 9:30
Send us Fan MailIn this (embarrassing) episode, long-time Buddhist practitioner Susan Piver describes an episode of road rage (her own) and the moment her rage turned into compassion. Spoiler: it has nothing to do with r…
How to Meditate (and Avoid the Biggest Misconceptions) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 29:55
Send us Fan MailThis episode provides a deep and practical exploration of meditation, defines meditation as something more than mindfulness, it also includes awareness. Common misconceptions are enumerated. The key takea…
On Meditation: An Uncommon View [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 24:04
Send us Fan MailMeditation is most often described as a self-help technique that will support you to improve performance, reduce stress, manage pain, and sleep better. All of this is true. Thank you, science! However, as…