Ep 561 The $40M Earnout That Never Got Paid, and the One That Did - Rob Walling and Garren Hilow

Ep 561 The $40M Earnout That Never Got Paid, and the One That Did - Rob Walling and Garren Hilow

Author: John Warrillow August 28, 2026 Duration: 1:01:00

Garren Hilow bootstrapped Abveris, an antibody discovery business doing $12 million in revenue, and sold it in 2021 for $150 million up front with another $40 million available in an earnout. His team came within one percent of the revenue target. The acquirer said they had missed it, refused to share the accounting behind that conclusion, and dared him to sue. 

Rob Walling sold Drip with 40 percent of his purchase price tied to an earnout and collected all but a fraction of it. 

In this episode of Built to Sell Radio, John Warrillow puts the two founders side by side to work out what actually separated the two outcomes, and you discover how to negotiate an earnout you have a chance of collecting. 

You'll learn: 

  • Why a revenue-based earnout hands the acquirer the calculator, including the right to change how your revenue is recognized partway through the year 

  • Walling's ranking of earnout milestones from worst to best, and the one type he tells founders to refuse outright 

  • Why taking more cash at close makes an acquirer less likely to fight you over the back end 

  • What a private equity buyer admitted over dinner about how often his firm plans to replace the founder 

  • The reporting clause Hilow left out of his agreement, and what its absence cost him 

  • How old Slack messages and a verbal instruction to work from home became grounds for a termination with cause 

  • Why an acquirer who intends to fold your company into theirs should not be offering an earnout at all 


For any entrepreneur, the idea of selling the company they've built is both a daunting prospect and a potential pinnacle of success. Built to Sell Radio, hosted by John Warrillow, steps into that complex space with a clear, practical focus. This isn't about abstract theory; it's a weekly conversation grounded in real experience. Every episode features a different founder who has recently navigated the sale of their business. The discussion goes straight to the heart of the matter: understanding the personal and strategic reasons behind the decision to sell. Listeners get an honest breakdown of what worked, from preparation and valuation to negotiation, and perhaps more importantly, the unforeseen pitfalls and mistakes made along the way. It’s that candid post-mortem, the lessons learned in the trenches of a transaction, that provides unparalleled value. By compiling these firsthand accounts, the podcast builds a comprehensive library of exit strategies and cautionary tales. Tuning in feels like gaining access to a private mastermind, where seasoned entrepreneurs share the unvarnished truth about cashing in their life's work. If you're contemplating your own eventual exit, this series offers the nuanced, peer-to-peer insights you need to think like a buyer, protect your interests, and ultimately, build a business that is truly desirable. Built to Sell Radio serves as an essential guide, transforming the opaque process of selling a business into a clearer, more manageable journey.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

Built to Sell Radio
Podcast Episodes
Ep 542 The 15X Multiple That Let Him Walk Away in 12 Months [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:08:04
At some point every founder needs to ask a simple question: is it better to own a big slice of a small pie, or a smaller slice of a bigger pie? In this week's episode, we hear from someone who chose a smaller slice of a…
Ep 539 Deal Collapsed at LOI, Sold for 6x EBITDA Anyway [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 45:42
Jay Richards spent five months deep in an acquisition process. He had a letter of intent. He had mentally checked out. He was planning what came next. Then issues surfaced in diligence and the deal collapsed. This week o…
Ep 537 Why this $5M Business Sold for $25M [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:06:38
When Sharon Gillenwater built Boardroom Insiders, she was doing something nobody else wanted to do: manually researching the personal work styles, business initiatives, and habits of Fortune 500 executives so that enterp…
Ep 534 Why a "short list" of acquirers may be a trap [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 58:17
Andrew McConnell built a SaaS company that helped vacation rental managers price homes like airlines using dynamic pricing based on demand. He eventually successfully exited, but not before learning the hard way that bui…