155: Baby Don't Hurt Me | What To Do When a Donor Gift Harms More Than Helps

155: Baby Don't Hurt Me | What To Do When a Donor Gift Harms More Than Helps

Author: Jess Birken, MNM, JD January 8, 2026 Duration: 16:59

You're getting donations for a nonprofit – and that's great! But sometimes generosity comes with strings you never expected.

In this episode, Meghan and I dig into the wild world of donor gifts and why nonprofits need clear guardrails to protect themselves from gifts that actually hurt the nonprofit.

Real Listener Question: "We have a donation button on our website where people can give online and set up recurring donations for monthly contributions. A few weeks ago, someone set up a daily 50 cent donation. Our accountant looked into it and is saying that it's not fraud or anything like that, but it just seems really silly. Our payment processor takes $0.30 out per transaction plus a merchant fee, so we're getting next to nothing on these donations. What do I do?"

This tiny daily gift opens the door to a much bigger conversation about gift acceptance policies and the hidden costs of donations. Meghan and I talk through the drawbacks, the admin time, the donor relationship dynamics, and the surprising ways well-intentioned gifts can actually drain your resources. We also break down how to set minimums, how to talk to donors with compassion, and how to avoid getting stuck with gifts that cost more than they give back.

What You'll Learn:

  • Why every nonprofit needs a gift acceptance policy
  • How to know when a gift creates more harm than helps
  • The hidden administrative costs behind every single donation
  • Ways to set smart donation minimums
  • How to redirect donors without damaging the relationship
  • Why saying no is actually part of stewardship
  • How to prepare for unusual gifts before they show up

Bottom line: Not every gift is a positive thing for a nonprofit. Sometimes you need to say no and guiding donors toward giving that truly supports your mission.

Resources from this Episode

Connect with Us

Listen & Engage

Stay Connected


Ever find yourself wishing for a direct line to seasoned nonprofit leaders, a chance to unpack the real challenges that don’t make it into the glossy annual reports? Charity Therapy is that conversation. With host Jess Birken, who brings her background as a lawyer and a Master of Nonprofit Management to the table, each session feels like pulling up a chair with a trusted advisor. The discussions move beyond theory, tackling the granular details of operations that leaders actually face-whether it’s navigating a tricky IRS compliance question, rebuilding a fundraising strategy from the ground up, or managing the complex interpersonal dynamics that define any mission-driven team. This podcast digs into the operational heart of the sector, offering pragmatic insights you can apply directly to your own work. It’s a resource built on the understanding that running a nonprofit is a continuous practice of problem-solving, and Jess guides these explorations with clarity and a deep respect for the work. Tune in for honest dialogue that treats the daily grind of management as the serious and nuanced craft that it is.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Charity Therapy
Podcast Episodes
Let's Keep This Private [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 20:37
The nonprofit world throws out that "501(c)(3)" moniker left and right – but what does that really mean? The IRS doesn't always communicate in ways the average person can (or should!) understand. So let's break it down –…
Follow the Money [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 21:22
Just because your organization is striving to do good, thatdoesn'tmean you're exempt from having todeal with trolls and scammers. There's no scam exemption application you can file! So, what can YOU doto make sure the no…
It's Like an Onion [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 22:51
Executive committees – what should they really do anyway? Spoiler alert – not as much as you think! Some nonprofit boards have a nasty habit of relying on an executive committee to be the board within the board, and that…
TLDR: Y'all Need Protection! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 23:07
You can't (and shouldn't!) envision every bad thing that might happen at a nonprofit. Nobody's got time for that! But you do need to be prepared and protected – and that means insurance! We're pulling this episode out of…
Periods of Baldness [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 19:32
There's this phrase "no man is an island." Well, guess what – no nonprofit is an island, either. In this episode, we're talking about the different ways people try to hack the board of directors and hoard all the control…
Making Ch-ch-ch-changes! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 13:08
No one gets into nonprofit work because they LOVE all the paperwork, but that doesn't mean you're exempt from doing it (sorry!). There are some core documents that every nonprofit needs to keep up with – especially when…
Size Matters [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 20:29
Nonprofits need to have a board - but how is that board supposed to make decisions? Today, we're getting into your board questions, all about redonk quorums, bureaucratic nightmares, and absentee board members. You don't…
Two Thumbs Down [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 20:13
Tis the season for… Giving Tuesday! The Tuesday after Thanksgiving, every nonprofit you've ever thought about will be contacting you about giving to their Giving Tuesday campaign. But should they? We're bringing our epis…
Onto the Next Chapter! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 19:22
We've got a vocab lesson for you today – what's the difference between a nonprofit chapter and a nonprofit affiliate? I don't blame you if you don't know - most people use those words interchangeably! How can you tell th…
Ghouls and Goblins Unite! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 22:24
Hang tight – we're going alllll the way back to our very first episode for this special Halloween celebration! Jordan Couch, lawyer from Tacoma and friend of the pod, came on to answer some ~spooky~ nonprofit questions a…