S2. EP13. The Girlfriend Mix-Up

S2. EP13. The Girlfriend Mix-Up

Author: AndrewTellsStories June 25, 2025 Duration: 4:02

What do you get when you confuse your girlfriend’s sister for your girlfriend? Awkward couch moments, a family group chat full of memes, and a mysterious warning from her dad. In this hilariously cringe-worthy tale, one guy shares how a simple mix-up turned into a family-wide fiasco—and why he’s now triple-checking who’s in the room before making a move.


Ever find yourself scrolling through Reddit, completely lost in a thread so strange it feels like its own little universe? That’s the feeling AndrewTellsStories aims to capture with Crazy Reddit Stories. This podcast isn’t about the day’s headlines or popular opinions; it’s a curated dive into the platform’s shadowy corners and vibrant communities where people share their most extraordinary experiences. You’ll hear tales that blur the line between reality and fiction, from chilling confessions posted in the dead of night to elaborate, real-life scenarios that seem too wild to be true. Each episode is a journey through these digital campfire stories, narrated with a sense of curiosity and just the right amount of skepticism. Whether it’s a mystery that was solved by internet sleuths or a personal anecdote that defies all logic, the podcast serves as an audio archive of the internet’s collective, and often unbelievable, imagination. It’s for anyone who loves a good story and wonders about the real people behind those usernames. So, if your own feed needs a break from the ordinary, let AndrewTellsStories guide you through the labyrinth. Just press play, and remember: on the internet, truth is often stranger than fiction.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 20

Crazy Reddit Stories
Podcast Episodes
S2. EP14. I Accidentally Gave My Best Friend A Colonoscopy. [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 5:13
When my best friend Jake refused to see a doctor for his “bathroom issues,” I reluctantly stepped up to help him try an enema. Big mistake. What started as a horribly awkward favor spiraled into an ER trip, a colonoscopy…
S2. EP12. My Girlfriend Is Pregnant... But I'm Infertile... [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 4:20
In this gut-wrenching story, a man’s life is turned upside down when his girlfriend, Emma, claims to be pregnant—despite his infertility. As he presses her for answers, the truth is revealed: not only is she not pregnant…
S2. EP11. The Accidental Wrestling Champion [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 8:06
A casual wrestling fan accidentally signs up for a class, gets thrown into an amateur wrestling match, and somehow wins by pure luck. From unintentional body slams to a fluke victory over a pro wrestler, this hilarious s…
S2. EP10. I Found Out My REAL MOTHER was a STRIPPER! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 5:13
In this jaw-dropping episode of the CRS Podcast, we hear a cringe-worthy tale of an 18th birthday gone horribly wrong. What was meant to be a night of laughs and "adulting" with friends at a sketchy strip club takes a sh…
S2. EP9. The Family Drama that Came with a New Number [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 4:30
In this special episode of the CRS Podcast, we celebrate the birthday of our lead producer, Andrew, with a hilarious and unexpected story. When John changes his phone number, he inherits one previously owned by a woman n…
S2. EP8. My Wife Claimed I Cheated But I Had Video Tapes [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 5:53
In this episode of The CRS Podcast, we dive into a gripping story of betrayal and resilience. After eight years of marriage, a submitter uncovered his wife’s affair, sparking a contentious divorce and custody battle. Wit…
S2. EP7. The Viagra Smoothie Incident [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 5:52
In this side-splitting episode, we recount the infamous tale of how an innocent pre-workout smoothie turned into a reputation-destroying fiasco. When an unmarked blue powder accidentally dosed our storyteller’s best frie…
S2. EP6. I Accidently FaceTimed My Boss In The Bathroom [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 6:53
What’s the worst place to accidentally call your boss? For one unlucky employee, the answer is... the bathroom. In this episode, we unravel the hilariously awkward tale of a FaceTime gone wrong—complete with panicked han…
S2. EP5. My Parents Try To Ruin My Gay Relationship. [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 5:58
In this episode of Crazy Reddit Stories, we explore a deeply personal and emotional tale of love, resilience, and self-discovery. Our guest shares their journey of finding happiness with their amazing boyfriend, Ryder, a…
S2. EP4. Teen Pregnancy [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 6:14
"In this episode of Crazy Reddit Stories, we explore the heartfelt and emotional story of a teenage guy whose life takes a sudden turn when his girlfriend reveals she’s pregnant. What starts as a moment of carelessness s…