GigaWhat: Clean-washing by dams?

GigaWhat: Clean-washing by dams?

Author: Mongabay.com August 13, 2022 Duration: 25:09

Hydropower has been an old and reliable source of energy in India. Until a few years ago, India considered a hydropower project renewable only when the installed capacity was less than 25 megawatt (MW). But then, in 2019, the government of India decided to consider large hydropower projects as renewable projects too. This makes hydroelectricity a vital part of India's clean energy targets - installing 500 gigawatt (GW) of non-fossil fuel-based capacity by 2030.

However, activists and researchers who have been working on issues related to the displacement of communities due to dam construction, and ecologists who study the impacts of dams on aquatic species and the region's biodiversity, think otherwise. They opine that the terms' clean' and 'green' used to describe hydropower could be misleading, as it does not consider the livelihoods lost and the cost of biodiversity lost at stake.

In this episode, we'll hear about how dams are perceived as a more stable source of energy when compared to solar and wind. We'll also hear about the true cost of relying on this form of energy. Our conversations raise a contentious question: Can hydropower be considered clean and renewable? Or is it simply a case of clean-washing?

Listen to GigaWhat and explore some of the biggest questions, challenges, and opportunities in India's transition from fossil fuel to clean energy sources. Mongabay-India is an online publication dedicated to bringing you stories on science and the environment in India.

Read the full Clean energy series on our website

Follow us on Twitter and Instagram 

Subscribe to our newsletter

Guests:

Ammu Susanna Jacob, Research Scientist, CSTEP

Shishir Rao, ecologist

Prakash Bhandari, environmental researcher and activist, Himdhara

Links:

A twin-state hydropower project could drown livelihoods and biodiversity

Fish & small hydropower projects in the Western Ghats biodiversity hotspot, India

The return of the mega hydropower projects across India

Credits:

Host: Mayank Aggarwal

Writer and producer: Kartik Chandramouli

Audio editor: Tejas Dayananda Sagar

Copy editor: Aditi Tandon

Podcast production assistant: Ayushi Kothari

GigaWhat cover art: Pooja Gupta


From the team at Mongabay.com comes Everything Environment by Mongabay India, a podcast that digs into the complex and often overlooked stories shaping India's natural world. This isn't just about headlines; it's about connecting the dots between biodiversity, climate change, and the natural resources that underpin daily life across the subcontinent. Each episode is a deep dive, whether it's examining the real-world impacts of the country's clean energy transition, uncovering lessons from ancient paleoscience, or giving a voice to lesser-known species fighting for survival. The conversations move beyond abstract problems to focus on tangible solutions and the people on the front lines. By weaving science and news into compelling narrative, this podcast places environmental discussions exactly where they belong: central to our understanding of India's present and future. You'll hear clear analysis and on-the-ground reporting that makes intricate topics accessible, fostering a deeper appreciation for the interconnectedness of ecology, policy, and community. For anyone curious about the forces shaping our environment, this series offers essential listening.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 28

Everything Environment by Mongabay India
Podcast Episodes
Wild Frequencies #3: Us and Them [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 46:20
If we listen closely, a bird's call reflects what humans have done to its landscape, and a forest soundscape tells us about habitat health. Listen to the third episode of Wild Frequencies to learn how scientists use bioa…
Wild Frequencies #2: Know Them [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 41:10
Can we figure out animal behaviour by listening to the sounds they produce? In this episode, you'll hear from scientists who listen closely to wildlife ranging from large mammals to insects. Wild Frequencies is a three-p…
Wild Frequencies #1: Find Them [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 42:28
Most wild animals are not easy to spot. They are often hidden, camouflaged, or just not around when you are. But instead of trying to 'see' them, what if we try and 'listen' to them? After all, animals communicate. For s…
Trailer: Wild Frequencies [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:02
Animals communicate. And some researchers listen to what they are saying. Hosts Shreya Dasgupta and Kartik Chandramouli travelled to different parts of India and spoke to multiple scientists to hear stories of sounds fro…
Environomy #6: A Challenge Across Generations [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 22:34
In this sixth and final episode of Environomy, we will explore how India has dealt with issues related to biodiversity and climate change since the 1991 economic reforms. Since the national government has taken a strong…
Environomy #5: The One That Got Missed [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 20:37
Though farming contributes less than 20% of India's GDP, it provides livelihood support to nearly half of the country's population. It is an extremely challenging occupation, with many from the younger generation unwilli…
Environomy #4: India Buys A Fast Car [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 15:53
There are traffic jams on India's hill stations and mountain roads across the year. It wasn't always like this. Increased incomes of the Indian middle class after the 1991 economic reforms translated to improved mobility…
Environomy #3: Playing With The Pillars [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 16:04
The legislature, the executive, and the judiciary, form the three pillars of Indian democracy. The legislature consisting of the parliamentarians, and legislators are the policy makers who draw up acts and policies. The…
Environomy #2: They Came, They Rapped, They Lobbied [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 15:47
In the early 1990s, the anti-Tehri dam and anti-Narmada dam movements were India's most well-known environmental protests. It was not as if only environmental activists were involved with these movements. The development…
Environomy #1: The Middle Class Unbottled [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 10:48
How did the 1991 economic reforms impact the course of the Indian environment in the past three decades? Listen to Environomy's first episode, where we will look at how the Indian middle class acquired a distinct economi…