444: Telling The Truth About Poker Face

444: Telling The Truth About Poker Face

Author: Extra Hot Great: This Week In TV February 1, 2023 Duration: 1:48:10
Peacock's latest original series is a Rian Johnson-created Columbo-esque "case of the week" procedural starring a fugitive cocktail waitress/human lie detector played by Natasha Lyonne; Rolling Stone Chief TV Critic Alan Sepinwall returns to discuss it (and bring with him all his coverage from the magazine)! Around The Dial takes us through the start of a new season of Married At First Sight (yes, already), plus Shrinking, Russian Doll, Lockwood & Co., and a new season of 9-1-1: Lone Star. Jeff argues that he is NOT a crackpot for thinking so-called "bottle episodes" are wildly overpraised. Laura presents the Better Call Saul episode "Something Stupid" for induction into The Canon. Then, after naming the week's Winner and Loser, we've got a lot of questions in Game Time. Sync the Bluetooth in your classic Barracuda and listen!

GUESTS

👤 Alan Sepinwall

TOPICS

Lead Topic: 🃏 Poker Face

Around The Dial: 👰‍♀️ Married At First Sight

Around The Dial: 🧠 Shrinking

Around The Dial: 🪆 Russian Doll

Around The Dial: 👻 Lockwood & Co.

Around The Dial: 👨‍🚒 9-1-1: Lone Star

I Am Not A Crackpot: 🍾 Bottle episodes

The Canon: ⚖️ Better Call Saul S04.E07: Something Stupid

Winner & Loser: 👍 Carol Burnett

Winner & Loser: 👎 Judy Greer

Game Time: 🤷‍♀️ 19 Questions

NOTES

🗒 Full episode notes can be found on the episode 444 page on ExtraHotGreat.com

🐦 Alan Sepinwall on Twitter

🪨 Alan's Poker Face feature at RollingStone.com

🔪 Alan's Rian Johnson Q&A

🕶️ Alan's Natasha Lyonne Q&A

⭐️ Alan's Poker Face review

🛋️ Tara on pop culture therapists at VanityFair.com

🐘 Alan on Mastodon

✍️ Alan's author page at RollingStone.com

📰 Alan's free newsletter

🛣️ Elizabeth Ashley's Actress: Postcards From The Road on GoodReads.com

🎶 The Record Of The Year showdown at Mark And Sarah Talk About Songs

🍾 "It's Time For A Departure From 'Bottle Episode'" by Kathryn VanArendonk at Vulture

📷 Photo: Peacock


Ever find yourself finishing a show and immediately wanting to dissect every detail with friends who get it? That’s the feeling you’ll find each week with Extra Hot Great: This Week In TV. This isn’t just a recap service; it’s a lively, thoughtful, and often hilarious conversation that picks up right where the credits roll. The hosts dive deep into the latest episodes, standout performances, and those baffling plot twists that dominated the cultural conversation, treating television with the serious analysis and genuine passion it deserves. You’ll hear sharp reviews that go beyond simple thumbs-up or down, exploring what worked, what didn’t, and why. The discussion naturally spans the spectrum from buzzy new series to enduring film influences, reflecting a broad and discerning taste. Tuning into this podcast feels like grabbing a seat at the table with the most insightful TV enthusiasts you know, where the talk is as engaging as the shows themselves. It’s a consistent source for smart, entertaining commentary that celebrates and critiques the world of screens, big and small.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 502

Extra Hot Great: This Week In TV
Podcast Episodes
609: Studying The Testaments [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:13:40
With its series adaptation of The Handmaid's Tale a major awards success for Hulu, the logical next step is an adaptation of its sequel novel, The Testaments, revolving around the privileged young women of Gilead being p…
608: Is For All Mankind Getting Old? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:37:46
For All Mankind, aka "Space Show," may be laboring under 15 tons of old-age makeup -- but the panel, and guest David J. Roth, are here for it. Maybe in space, the makeup is weightless? Or maybe it's a handful of good per…
606: Giving The Gift Of 1980 Commercials [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:01:25
This is an un-vaulting of EEHG 388. Haaaaappy holidays! Return with us now to December 3, 1980 -- and all the utterly of-their-time commercials (and by "their time," we kind of mean the '70s) from a rerun of an After Sch…
606: Staying Up For The Late Shift [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:29:29
This is an un-vaulting of EEHG 376. For this year's special This Week In TV History episode, we're journeying back to 1996 for February sweeps -- specifically, the week of February 21-27 -- and investigating all the star…
605: Is Rooster A Cock-A-Doodle Doo Or A Cock-A-Doodle Don't? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:12:19
The third Bill Lawrence show to début or return in 2026 Q1 is Rooster, loosely "What if Carl Hiaasen had a daughter he needed to help through her divorce from a fellow prof at a New England liberal arts college by taking…
604: Investigating R.J. Decker [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 55:08
R.J. Decker is a photojournalist-turned-private investigator who originated in a novel by Carl Hiaasen. Is he more than just the network-TV version of Bad Monkey? Kim Reed returns to talk about it. Around The Dial takes…
603: A Little More Conversation About Paradise [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:29:02
Paradise is back for a whole new season of [major spoiler redacted]. After we made guest Alyson Lewis cram 11 episodes in a week, is she mad at us, or delighted to welcome her favorite new show into her life? Listen to f…
602: Did We Love Love Story? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:13:11
The latest true-life story from the Ryan Murphy factory is Love Story, all about John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette. Was our 90s nostalgia powerful enough to get us past its taste issues? Jessica Morgan returns to…
601: Did The 'Burbs Make Us Stir-Crazy? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:19:28
Peacock counter-programmed the Super Bowl with a series adaptation of the 1989 horror comedy The 'Burbs. Horror expert Matt Monagle makes his EHG début to discuss whether it made a convincing case for its existence in it…
600: Going Backstage With The Muppet Show [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:22:50
The Muppet Show returns with a one-off episode starring Sabrina Carpenter; Muppetry expert Adam Grosswirth returns to discuss it, including whether the new version nailed the original's vibe, what makes a good Muppet gue…