Erwin James (2013) | A Killer Can Be a Good Neighbour

Erwin James (2013) | A Killer Can Be a Good Neighbour

Author: Festival of Dangerous Ideas August 2, 2021 Duration: 1:00:21

When someone commits a crime, we want them punished. If wrongdoers go to prison more often and for longer, everyone seems happy.

But we live in a system where people do eventually come out of prison and rejoin the community. And this is where what has happened to them in prison really starts to matter. If prisons are a rank breeding ground for recidivism, where drug use is unchecked and non-violent offenders are initiated into the criminal world, do you want someone who has spent time there living near you? Or would you rather see them going straight back to jail?

As incarceration rates grow, if we want anyone who has been to jail to have a chance in life, maybe we need to look at a different approach – the kind of prison model that could make a killer a good neighbour.

Erwin James is a convicted murderer and Guardian journalist. James was released in August 2004 having served 20 years of a life sentence.

Chaired by journalist Hamish Macdonald.


For more than a decade, the Festival of Dangerous Ideas has curated a space where provocative thinking isn't just welcomed, it's the entire point. This podcast is a direct line to that stage, offering an archive of talks that deliberately unsettle comfortable opinions and interrogate the stubborn problems we often agree to ignore. Each episode captures a live conversation from Australia's original disruptive ideas festival, presenting arguments that can be exhilarating, uncomfortable, and vitally important. You’ll hear from a compelling roster of festival alumni-including leading experts, intellectual troublemakers, and visionary authors-who share perspectives that conventional discourse frequently sidelines. The discussions here aren't theoretical exercises; they grapple with the pressing and difficult issues shaping our society and culture right now. Tuning in means granting yourself access to a decade-long tradition of intellectual courage, where the core assumption is that some truths are only reached by first entertaining a dangerous idea. It’s a chance to listen as boundaries are pushed, not for shock value, but for clarity. The result is a consistently challenging and refreshing audio experience that complicates simple narratives and expands what feels possible to talk about.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Festival of Dangerous Ideas
Podcast Episodes
Salman Rushdie (2014) - Freedom to Write [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 31:55
We're living in increasingly brittle times. Ideas that once provoked argument, now provoke outrage – and the art of debate has now shattered. What does it mean to think freely about our world when speech itself is treate…
A message from Stephen Fry [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:48
Heading into its 13th festival, FODI exists thanks to supporters who don't flinch at difficult topics. Brave minds. Bold hearts. Dangerous conversations. We've built a reputation for dragging the world's sharpest provoca…
Roxane Gay (2024) - How to Have Dangerous Ideas [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:00:53
Drawing from her experience as an author and cultural critic who consistently challenges predictable opinions, Roxane Gay urges us to embrace the danger and discomfort of dissent. But in an age of polarised opinion warfa…
The Anatomy of Evil (2024) - Stan Grant & Simon Longstaff [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:02:24
Humanity has demonstrated, time and again, a horrific tendency to destroy its own kind – often to eliminate difference and impose uniformity of identity. At its worst, this tendency has led to the destruction of whole pe…
John N. Friedman (2024) - The Fading Dream [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 28:30
Economist John N. Friedman has made a career researching the causes of inequality and its long-term consequences for children in the US. His findings are grim. Social mobility is in sharp decline. Where you live and go t…
Todd Fernando (2024) - The Next Frontier [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 41:47
The concept of success and excellence is fraught with tension between communities within Australia. For non-Indigenous Australians, excellence is almost exclusively an economic concept, founded on stolen and inherited re…
Saree Makdisi (2024) - Tolerance is a Wasteland [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 45:09
For some, the image of Israel, as a shining example of liberal democratic ideals has been broken by the Netanyahu Government's actions in Gaza since 7 October, 2023. Yet, for others, the positive image projected by Israe…
David Baddiel (2024) - The God Desire [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:14:27
Is God a story we've just told ourselves to satisfy our own desires? Comedian and author David Baddiel knows God doesn't exist, but wishes he did. As Baddiel wrestles with his understanding of God and spirituality as a J…
Coleman Hughes & Josh Szeps (2024) - A Colourblind Society [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 59:14
Are we too focused on race? Have recent anti-racist movements like Black Lives Matter abandoned the 'colourblind' spirit of the original civil rights movement? In this live FODI edition of Uncomfortable Conversations wit…
Jen Gunter (2024) - Lifting the Curse [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 34:34
Being open about the female body has always been taboo, risky and dangerous. So, by smashing ancient menstrual taboos, and demolishing dangerous pseudoscience, the Internet's OB-GYN Jen Gunter has long been on a mission…