WHEN FICTION MEETS FACT (AND FICTION MEETS FICTION):  THE STORY OF STEVE BRODIE, MAUD AND PERCY

WHEN FICTION MEETS FACT (AND FICTION MEETS FICTION): THE STORY OF STEVE BRODIE, MAUD AND PERCY

Author: Forgotten News Podcast April 7, 2018 Duration: 1:18:08
In July 1886, Steve Brodie, a resident of the Bowery neighborhood of New York City, made a bet to jump off the Brooklyn Bridge, into the river below, in exchange for the money to open a saloon. This was a 135 foot jump. He became legendary for the leap. But, did it actually happen?  Listen and decide what you think!  Also, on this episode, we present a short story from 1902 - Maude and Percy Visit the Bowery - which gives a humorous (?) glimpse into what happens when a naïve upper middle class young couple decide to experience the excitement and terrors of the Bowery. Although the story is fiction, it contains many mentions of real places and people of the time period, including Steve Brodie (!) and McGurk’s saloon, which was depicted in detail on a recent episode of our podcast.  And, for the enjoyment of our listeners, the story of Maud and Percy is presented here, as an audio play.    HISTORICAL REFERENCES   Steve Brodie: New York Times, July 24, 1886. New York Times, February 7, 1901. New York Post, November 5, 2007. The Day, Associated Press (AP), July 24, 1986. Sante, Luc, Low Life (1990), pp. 122-25. Haw, Richard, The Brooklyn Bridge: A Cultural History (2006), pp. 145-150.  McCullough, David, The Great Bridge: The Epic Story of the Building of the Brooklyn Bridge (2012), p. 448. Freeman, Morton, A New Dictionary of Eponyms (1997), pp. 33. Steve Brodie: Find-a-Grave. Bridget Brodie (wife): Find-a-Grave.   Maud and Percy: Jarrold, Earnest (a.k.a. “Mickey Finn”), Maud and Percy Visit the Bowery, Cleveland Plain Dealer, January 11, 1903 (reprint from New York Sun). Earnest Jerrold – Wikipedia biography. Earnest Jerrold – “Mickey Finn” is Dead (obituary), New York Times, March 21, 1912.    GUEST VOICES. Steve Brodie: Steve Brodie - Andy Wang, the host of the Inspired Money podcast.  Accomplice of Steve Brodie – Sam Kulper of the Breakers podcast. Bowery Bus Tour Guide (Unidentified) - Pete Lutz from the Pulp Pourri podcast, the Jake Dimes podcast, the Range Detective podcast; and the Save the Last Word for Me podcast. Maud & Percy: Maud – Sara Stapleton of the Karen & Ellen Letters podcast. Percy – Kevin Gallagher, the host of the Everything is Awesome podcast. NYC Police officer (Unidentified) – Barney Black of Bloody Murder podcast. Intoxicated Man (Unidentified) – Austin Beach of Audioblivious Productions. Waiter (Unidentified) – Drew Profit of Audioblivious Productions. Man on Street & Witness at McGurk’s (Unidentified) - Scott Phillips of Audioblivious Productions. Sadie - Taylor Sadowski, listener and fan. Sadie’s Friend (Unidentified) - Karen Wickiam, the host of Stat! Shocking Traumas and Treatments podcast. Sailor (Unidentified) - Jeremy Hennessy of Audioblivious Productions. Pick-Pocket Girl / Lady of the Evening (Unidentified) - Danielle Ries of Audioblivious Productions. Narrator (story) - Sam Kulper of the Breakers podcast. Miscellaneous: Narrator, the story of Steve Brodie & Outro Aphorism (voice) – Kit Caren, co-host of the Forgotten News Podcast. Host Intro – Nina Innsted, the host of the Already Gone podcast.     MUSIC   Kevin MacLeod of Incompetech.com – Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses / by 3.0 At Rest I Knew A Guy Confortable Mystery   Freesound: Piano_Ending_Tune organ grinder chinese umbrella rag demo   Andy Wang: My Pearl is a Bowery Girl (chorus) The Bowery (chorus)   ABRF: Short Ragtime Piano Thingy I Made   StarSheep4: Swingin' The Alphabet - Childrens' Song Arrangement                (drum intro segment only).   SOUND EFFECTS   Freesound: Male_crying_and_weeping WestVillageNYC crowd Horror_shrieks_woman crowd-mob-riot-noise (voices only) Splash Medieval_Fanfare_tweaked Clapping Cheering Applause   OUTRO APHORISM:  Source: Chesterton, G.K., Heretics (1905),                                      in chapter “Omar and the Sacred Vine”, p. 108.   T-SHIRTS

There’s a certain kind of story that crackles with urgency when it breaks, dominating conversations and front pages, only to vanish completely a few years later. FORGOTTEN NEWS PODCAST goes looking for those stories. Each episode is a deep dive into a different moment that once captivated the public, an event or figure that seemed indelible but somehow slipped through the cracks of our collective memory. You’ll hear about scandals that toppled empires of reputation, inventions that promised to change everything, and personal dramas that played out on a very public stage-all now quietly gathering dust in old newspaper archives and forgotten diaries. The aim isn’t just to recount these tales, but to understand why they resonated so powerfully in their moment and explore what their disappearance says about how we remember. It’s a process of careful excavation, piecing together narratives from primary sources, historical accounts, and the cultural echoes that remain. Tuning into this podcast feels like opening a long-lost trunk in the attic; every story is presented with the immediacy it once held, allowing you to experience the surprise, outrage, or wonder just as an audience did decades or even centuries ago. These are the headlines that time edited out, brought back to life.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

FORGOTTEN NEWS PODCAST
Podcast Episodes
A DOUBLE NIGHTMARE IN ATHENS COUNTY - 1881 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 56:05
In the autumn of 1881, the community of Athens, Ohio, was the scene of the lynching of Christopher Davis, a young black man, and a violent attack on Lucinda Luckey, a widow. On this episode, you will hear their interconn…
STRANGE THINGS FOUND IN THE WOODS [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:18:08
Some random stories of unusual things that people have found in the woods, here and there, over the past 150+ years. The stories are fun and interesting, so check it out. Listeners: We apologize for the fact that the vol…
A HIATUS, A HERO, AND AN OUTLAW [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 31:19
In 1947, in New York, an innocent man was convicted and sent to prison, for a murder he didn't commit. A newspaper reporter was awarded the Pulitzer Prize for proving him innocent, and winning his release. Also: Police B…
TROUBLED TIMES IN CHINATOWN [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:02:55
The dark and violent side of the history of Chinatown, in New York City, during the 19th and early 20th centuries. Also: Police Blotter & Court News (Florida), November 24, 1899. HISTORICAL REFERENCES Troubled Times In C…
ABRAHAM LINCOLN, TRUE CRIME WRITER [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 57:51
In 1846, future U.S. president Abraham Lincoln wrote a short story about a very strange and mysterious murder case, that had taken place in Illinois, a few years earlier. The story was published in a local newspaper. On…
THE WITCH WHO WASN'T:  JANE WENHAM - 1712 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 37:48
The trial of Jane Wenham in 1712, is mostly infamous as "the last witchcraft trial in England". But, that's not the only reason why this case should be infamous. Also: Police Blotter & Court News - June 1, 1863. HISTORIC…
THE STORY BEHIND APRIL FOOL'S DAY [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 4:09
The title says it all. Our guest: Emily Prokop of The Story Behind Podcast. Operation Switcheroo! Enjoy.
CLARA'S CRAZY IDEA - 1893 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:18:13
The story of the woman who gave birth to the Public Defender system, for the U.S., in 1893. HISTORICAL REFERENCES: Books: Babcock, Barbara, Woman Lawyer: The Trials of Clara Foltz (2011). Drachman, Virginia, Sisters In L…
SLAVERY IN DISGUISE - 1892 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 41:08
The tragic story of how, during the years between the late 1870s and early 1940s, the states of the American South used the criminal courts to effectively re-establish slavery for hundreds of thousands of black people, a…
A TEEN LOVE STORY - 1890 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 39:49
The adventures (mis-adventures?) of two young teen couples, from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, who ran away from home, to Cleveland, Ohio, in September 1890, to elope. HISTORICAL REFERENCES:Cleveland Plain Dealer, September…