We Need a Care Revolution: Victor Montori

We Need a Care Revolution: Victor Montori

Author: Alex Smith, Eric Widera July 31, 2025 Duration: 47:41

In his book, "Why We Revolt," Victor Montori decries the industrialization of healthcare.  We've become a healthcare factory, beholden to health systems motivated by profit. In particular, he laments the loss of the "care" aspect of healthcare.

Clinicians are under the clock to churn through patients.  Patients are tasked with doing work outside of the clinic. Patients are tasked with hours and hours of work to self manage, obtain and manage medications, track weights and fingersticks, not to mention scheduling visits and waiting around for the visit to start.

Now we have an app for that. For what, you ask? Well, for everything! Digital burden is real. Think about what we ask patients to do: charge your device, remember your password, 2 factor authentication, each interface is different, wait…where do you enter your fingersticks again?

Victor is an endocrinologist who often provides care for older patients with multiple chronic conditions, polypharmacy, and complex social situations.  He's "one of us."

Some might argue that these circumstances call for incremental change.  Not Victor.  He argues that we need a revolution. In particular, he argues that the revolution must come from patients to be successful.

On this podcast we discuss:

  • Why do we need a revolution? What made him get to this point of arguing for a revolt?

  • Why should the revolution be patient led, rather than clinician led? What role do clinicians have to play?

  • What is minimally disruptive medicine (a term Victor coined with Carl May and Francis Mair in 2009)?

  • How does shared decision making fit into the revolution?

  • What's the matter with guidelines? What's the role of standardization?

  • We suspect that most geriatrics and palliative care providers feel like they've escaped many of the issues Victor describes, trading less glamorous and remunerative work for more satisfying time spent caring for patients; focusing on what matters, goals of care, and attention to emotion and social well-being.  Are we deluding ourselves?


If you'd like to join the revolution, please check out Victor's website, patientrevolution.org

And I believe this is the first Peter Gabriel song request! I think Peter Gabriel's album So was the first cassette tape I purchased.  About time, 350+ podcasts in.  My son Kai turns this very non-guitar friendly song into an acoustic jam for the audio-only podcast version; you get my weaker attempt on YouTube :) 

Finally, a quick plug for the Sommer Lecture series in Portland OR.  Victor and I had a terrific time bonding at this year's lecture series. While not strictly geriatrics and palliative care focused, the lectures seem targeted at a broad audience, with something for everyone.  And yes, I made them sing parody songs :)

-Alex Smith

 


Hosted by UCSF physicians Alex Smith and Eric Widera, GeriPal-A Geriatrics and Palliative Medicine Podcast creates a vital space for conversation at the intersection of aging and serious illness care. This isn't a dry lecture series; it's a dynamic dialogue where Eric and Alex bring on leading experts to unpack the complexities of geriatric and palliative medicine. They delve into the latest research that should change practice, tackle the ethical dilemmas that provoke debate, and explore the nuanced clinical challenges that professionals face daily. The tone is engaging and often surprisingly lighthearted, with moments of humor and even the occasional song, making profound topics more accessible. Whether you're a clinician, nurse, social worker, or any professional dedicated to this field, this podcast offers a blend of evidence-based insights and practical wisdom you can use. It’s a resource that acknowledges the weight of the work while fostering connection and continued learning. For those seeking formal education credits, AMA PRA Category 1 CME and MOC credit are also available through the show. Tune in to join a community committed to improving care for older adults and those with serious illness.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

GeriPal - A Geriatrics and Palliative Medicine Podcast
Podcast Episodes
Embedding Care in the ED: Liz Goldberg and Lauren Southerland [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 47:15
The idea of embedding various forms of non-emergency care in the emergency department makes a WORLD of sense. If an older adult comes into the ED with a fall, the minimum the ED has to do is address the fall injury and s…
AI and Healthcare: Bob Wachter [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 52:28
Today we interviewed Bob Wachter about his book, "A Giant Leap: How AI Is Transforming Healthcare and What That Means for Our Future." You may recall we interviewed Bob in April 2024 about AI, and at that time he was on…
Uncertainty In Medicine: Jonathan Ilgen and Gurpreet Dhaliwal [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 51:12
The only certainty in medicine is uncertainty. It touches every aspect of clinical practice, from diagnosis to treatment to prognosis. Despite this, many clinicians view uncertainty as something to tolerate at best or el…
Inflammaging: Brian Andonian, Sara LaHue, Joe Hippensteel [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 50:51
Six years ago we had John Newman on GeriPal to talk about Geroscience (Song choice Who Wants to Live Forever by Queen, perfect selection). John explained the basics of geroscience, what is it, what are the key theories i…