Cults, Conspiracy Theories & Critical Thinking: The History America Didn't Teach You

Cults, Conspiracy Theories & Critical Thinking: The History America Didn't Teach You

Author: Gwendolyn Dolske, PhD & Rudy Salo | Philosophy & Education Podcast July 31, 2026 Duration: 41:06

What if the United States was never immune to cult thinking, but was built on it?

Journalist Jane Borden joins Gwendolyn and Rudy to unpack her book Cults Like Us: Why Doomsday Thinking Drives America, tracing a direct line from Puritan doomsday belief to modern conspiracy theories, self-help culture, and our national obsession with strongmen and influencers. We dig into how to actually define a cult (without being hyperbolic about it), the surprising overlap between cults and conspiracy theories, why doomsday predictions are so effective for cult leaders, and what role the justice system plays when belief crosses into control.

We also explore why cult stories captivate us the way true crime does and, most importantly, what actually happens in the moment someone's critical thinking finally breaks through the isolation a cult creates. A conversation about American history, critical thinking skills, and the psychology of belief that might change how you see the news, your feed, and the country itself.

Philosophy Resources, Jane Borden's book Cults Like Us, and Gifts for Book Lovers: GoodIsInTheDetails.com

Join our Patreon, book club, and get exclusive behind-the-scenes: Patreon.com/GoodIsInTheDetails

Learn more about Jane Borden's Work: https://www.janeborden.com

Get your "In My Intellectual Curiosity Era" Tote

Listen to Rudy Salo on the podcast Deliberations, season 4.


Hosted by Gwendolyn Dolske, Ph.D., and Rudy Salo, Good Is In The Details operates on the belief that the most profound insights are often hidden in plain sight, waiting to be unpacked. This philosophy and education podcast doesn't just skim the surface of big topics; it lingers there, examining the nuances of how we think, learn, and ultimately live our lives. You'll hear thoughtful, meandering conversations with scholars, authors, and practitioners from diverse fields, all centered on how ideas from ethics, culture, and critical thinking intersect with our daily realities. The hosts have a knack for breaking down complex academic concepts without losing their depth, making each episode feel like an engaging seminar you can enjoy on a walk or during your commute. Rather than offering easy answers, this podcast provides the tools and perspectives to ask better questions, finding the substance in the subtleties that we often overlook. It’s for anyone who believes that understanding the framework of an argument or the history of a thought is just as important as the conclusion. Tune in for a consistently thoughtful exploration of the books, theories, and cultural forces that quietly shape our world.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

Good Is In The Details
Podcast Episodes
To Chill or Not To Chill: When Does Perseverance Become Toxic? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 50:40
We're taught that perseverance is always a virtue, but what if the very trait we celebrate is quietly costing us our sense of meaning? Michael Scarano, a healthcare veteran turned speaker and coach, joins us to unpack wh…
Honest, True, or Authentic? (They're Not the Same Thing) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 48:33
Honesty might be the character trait we claim to value most, but what does it actually mean to be honest, and how is that different from simply telling the truth, or "being authentic"? Philosopher Christian Miller, autho…
How To Navigate The Homeless Crisis With Humanity and Reason [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 40:29
In this episode of Good Is In The Details, Gwendolyn Dolske sits down with Karen Olson — founder and CEO emeritus of Family Promise, a national nonprofit organization dedicated to helping homeless and low-income families…
The Slow Death of Local News and Its Impact on Critical Thinking [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 41:14
What happens when local journalism disappears, and how does it affect democracy, critical thinking, and informed citizens? Is local journalism disappearing, and what does that mean for democracy? In this episode of Good…