Pianist and broadcaster Keelan Carew nominates Russian composer Nicolai Medtner

Pianist and broadcaster Keelan Carew nominates Russian composer Nicolai Medtner

Author: BBC Radio 4 February 16, 2026 Duration: 27:43

Matthew Paris is joined by the pianist and broadcaster Keelan Carew, who nominates the Great Life of the early 20th century composer Nicolai Medtner.

It’s often the case that in a world of strong contenders, there are 'Great Lives' hidden by the scale and success of their contemporaries. That’s certainly a case that can be made in the case of Nicolai Medtner. Born towards the end of the 19th century in Moscow he followed in the immediate footsteps of Sergei Rachmaninov who would state later in life that 'in my opinion, [Medtner] was the greatest composer of our time.' Many have begged to differ since, but Medtner's was undoubtedly an extraordinary life and he has a particular hold over pianists stretching back over the last hundred years. After the Russian revolution Rachmaninov himself would help and support Medtner as he tried to establish himself in the west. However, where Rachmaninov acceded to the requests made of him, Medtner was fiercely conservative in his tastes at a time when modernism held sway in Europe.

To help tell his story Matthew and Keelan are joined by pianist and composer, Francis Pott, another Medtner enthusiast who has explored a life that took Nicolai from pre-revolutionary Russia to a house in north London where he eventually settled in the 1930s. His reputation and output might have languished were it not for the support of the Maharajah of Mysore, who founded the Medtner society and funded the recording of many of Medtner's works including his piano concertos and songs, the former played by the now elderly composer.

As well as the music, illustrated from the keyboard by Keelan himself, Nicolai's personal life involved marrying the wife of his brother. The three lived together for many years. We also hear from the last person who knew Medtner and recalls taking the composer on countryside trips in the 1950s where he loved nothing better than to sit by the river Thames eating ice-cream.

Producer: Tom Alban


Some voices become so familiar they feel like companions, and the conversations on Great Lives from BBC Radio 4 have that quality. It’s less a formal history lesson and more a series of intimate, revealing portraits, shaped by the personal choices of a different guest each time. These guests-ranging from acclaimed artists and scientists to politicians and writers-bring forward the figure who has profoundly shaped their own path, whether that’s a towering historical icon or a quieter, overlooked genius. What you’ll hear is a genuine discussion, often surprising and always deeply human, as host and guest piece together a life from the facts, the myths, and the enduring legacy. The magic of this podcast lies in that dual perspective: you learn about an extraordinary subject, but you also get a glimpse into what moves the person choosing them. It’s a documentary series that lives in the specific details of individual experience, connecting the personal to the historical. Tune in for thoughtful, well-researched conversations that explore how a single life can ripple through culture, society, and the individuals who come after, reminding us that biography is never just about the past.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

Great Lives
Podcast Episodes
Ellen E Jones nominates Florynce Kennedy [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 27:59
One dubbed "the biggest, loudest and indisputably the rudest mouth on the battleground", Florynce Kennedy was a force to be reckoned with. She was a lawyer, a vocal figure in the American civil rights and feminist moveme…
AN Wilson selects Johann Wolfgang von Goethe [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 27:47
"I've chosen him because I think he was possibly the most interesting human being who has ever lived". AN WilsonBorn in the middle of the 18th century in Frankfurt, Goethe went on to become the preeminent figure in Germa…
Jessica Fostekew on Boudica [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 27:44
"The Queen Boadicea, standing loftily charioted, Brandishing in her hand a dart and rolling glances lioness-like, Yell'd and shriek'd between her daughters in her fierce volubility": so wrote Alfred, Lord Tennyson in the…
Reginald D Hunter selects Eugene V Debs [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 27:41
Eugene Victor Debs, born 1855 in Indiana USA, was a railway worker, a trade unionist and a five time candidate for the presidency. He was imprisoned during the First World War for sedition. He'd urged resistance to the d…
Pen Hadow nominates Sir Peter Scott [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 27:48
"Make the boy interested in natural history," wrote Captain Scott from his tent in the Antarctic. He was talking about his son, three-year-old Peter Scott, whom he never saw again and who went on to found the Wildfowl an…
Lauren Cuthbertson on Margot Fonteyn [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 28:06
Margot Fonteyn was an icon: a ballerina who helped build and indeed embodied the traditional image of a dancer, just as the artform was finding its feet on the British cultural scene. From humble beginnings she became an…
Dr Hannah Critchlow picks Professor Colin Blakemore [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 27:59
Professor Colin Blakemore was a famous communicator of science, the youngest ever Reith lecturer on the BBC. He was also targeted by members of the animal rights movement, which sent bombs and letters lined with razor bl…
Doug Allan on Captain Jacques Cousteau [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 28:07
Captain Jacques-Yves Cousteau was an oceanographer, filmmaker and explorer who made the seas a subject of fascination for millions.During his time in the French Navy, Cousteau co-invented the Aqua-Lung: the first self-co…
Ekow Eshun on the first openly gay footballer, Justin Fashanu [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 27:47
In 1981 Brian Clough paid £1 million pounds to bring Justin Fashanu to Nottingham Forest. It was the climax of a meteoric career, but within months the goals had dried up, he'd been going to gay nightclubs, and Fashanu h…