He Spent 2 Years Undercover With the Sons of Silence (Part 1) | ATF Agent Blake Boteler

He Spent 2 Years Undercover With the Sons of Silence (Part 1) | ATF Agent Blake Boteler

Author: Citizens Behind the Badge May 5, 2026 Duration: 39:15

What does it actually cost to go undercover for two years with one of America's most violent outlaw motorcycle gangs?

Blake Boteler knows. He's the retired ATF special agent who spent two years as "Bo" — a prospect, then a patch-wearing member of the Sons of Silence — in Colorado Springs, Colorado. His 1963 Harley Davidson and undercover jacket are now in the National Law Enforcement Museum. Craig Floyd, who ran the National Law Enforcement Officer's Memorial Fund, named Blake his Officer of the Month in July 2002.

In Part 1, Blake breaks down what deep cover really looks like — and it's not nine to five.

Before a word is spoken about the Sons of Silence, Blake describes the moment that set everything in motion: a gas-station robbery in Oklahoma City, a class ring taken at gunpoint, a dumpster search with his father, and a suspect tracked down through a girlfriend's white dog. That letter from the DA ended up in his ATF interview. ATF offered him a job before anyone else did.

From there: how you cold-call your way into a motorcycle gang when you have no informants. How you pass a girl test that isn't about what you think it's about.

How you manage the three dilemmas — violence, drugs, and women — when you can't blow your cover and you won't compromise your ethics. And how you live when you're actually living three lives: Bo the outlaw, Blake the ATF agent, and Blake the husband and father of three children who once watched his kids play tee-ball from a parking lot — and had to let a police officer question him for it without saying a word.

Bill Erfurth — retired Miami-Dade detective who infiltrated the Genovese and Bonanno crime families in South Florida — joins the conversation to compare notes.

Same world, entirely different approach.

It ends on the Fourth of July. Blake is in jail. He watches fireworks through his cell window.

In Part 2: 230 weapons seized. A $50,000 contract on his life. And an arrest plan built around a hearse, a fake funeral, and a cemetery plot in Colorado Springs.

Citizens Behind the Badge supports law enforcement officers and their families. Learn more and donate at CitizensBehindTheBadge.org.


Heroes Behind the Badge is a podcast that brings you the untold stories of America's law enforcement community, from the front lines to the final call. Guided by Craig Floyd, who spent 34 years working alongside police officers across the nation, and joined by veteran facilitator Dennis Collins and law enforcement expert Bill Erfurth, the show cuts through misconceptions and focuses on the real people behind the badge. In each episode, listeners can expect candid conversations, hard-earned insights, and powerful moments that highlight service, sacrifice, and the realities of the job. If you want to listen episodes that go beyond headlines and hear stories shaped by experience and respect, Heroes Behind the Badge by {author} offers a clear, grounded perspective on the law enforcement community.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 53

Heroes Behind the Badge
Podcast Episodes
CPR on "Superman": The Partner Rick Rossman Couldn't Save — Part 2 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 31:01
Part 1 ended on the Thanksgiving 1983 murders of Rick Rossman's Metro-Dade partners Richie Boles and David Strzalkowski — shot with their own service weapons by ex-con Charlie Street — and Rick's admission that in more t…
He Called It Suicide. By 2:14 AM, Two Partners Were Dead | Part 1 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 28:17
Thanksgiving weekend, 1983. Only five officers were assigned to cover an entire Miami-Dade, Florida district that night. Before his first call, Rick Rossman told his sergeant it felt like suicide going out that short-sta…
She Was Taken to the Wrong Hospital While Her Husband Died | Part 1 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 26:16
On August 24, 1984, U.S. Capitol Police Sergeant Chris Eney was shot and killed in a training exercise — accidentally, by a fellow officer and friend. When his wife Vivian got the call, she was told someone was coming to…
Officer Deaths, Safety, and the Hard Questions [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 33:23
What does it actually mean to say officer deaths dropped below 100?In Part 2 of this two-part conversation on Heroes Behind the Badge, we sit down again with Bill Alexander, CEO of the National Law Enforcement Officers M…
The Story Behind the National Law Enforcement Memorial [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 27:19
Before the names are etched in stone, there are lives. Families. Communities forever changed.In Part 1 of this two-part conversation on Heroes Behind the Badge, we sit down with Bill Alexander, CEO of the National Law En…