Why You Choke in Tennis Matches (And How to Stop It) | Jeff Greenwald

Why You Choke in Tennis Matches (And How to Stop It) | Jeff Greenwald

Author: Mike Rogers - Founder of Senior Tennis Unpacked September 1, 2026 Duration: 19:26

👉 Go Deeper with Coaches and Pros Who Actually Know Senior Tennis https://www.skool.com/senior-tennis-unpacked-8081

What happens when you’re up 5-2, feeling good, and then suddenly tighten up?

 

In this episode of Insider’s Playbook, I’m joined by mental performance coach Jeff Greenwald to talk about one of the most frustrating parts of tennis: why we choke, why we start playing not to lose, and what causes our game to break down under pressure.

 

Jeff explains why players get trapped in self-monitoring, why trying to “fix” technique in the middle of a tight moment often makes things worse, and how to compete more freely when the score gets uncomfortable. We also talk about what to do right after a double fault, how a simple between-point routine can calm your mind, and why protecting a lead is often what causes it to disappear.

 

If you’ve ever gotten tight on serve, lost confidence when ahead, or wondered why your game changes when the match gets close, this conversation will help you understand what’s happening and how to respond better.

 

Key takeaways

  • Pressure itself is not the real problem. The bigger problem is how we react to feeling pressure, tightness, or nerves
  • After a double fault, focusing on “don’t double fault” usually creates more tension. A better response is to shift attention outward instead of inward
  • In tight moments, players often start self-monitoring and trying to fix technique, but that usually makes the problem worse
  • A simple between-point routine can help reset the mind, especially when it brings attention back to the body, breathing, and the ball
  • Going into a match with a written pressure plan helps you respond better when things get uncomfortable instead of just hoping you’ll handle it well
  • When players get ahead, they often start protecting the lead instead of continuing to compete. That shift from playing to win to playing not to lose is where trouble starts

 

About Jeff Greenwald

 

Jeff Greenwald is the author of The Best Tennis of Your Life and creator of Fearless Tennis. His work focuses on the mental side of competitive tennis, helping players manage pressure, expectations, focus, confidence, and the emotional challenges that can interfere with playing their best.

 

Contact Jeff Greenwald:

Website: https://fearlesstennis.com

Email: jeff@fearlesstennis.com

 

⏱️ Chapters:

 

00:00 Coming Up & Show Introduction

01:34 Why Pressure Makes You Play Too Safe

04:01 What to Do After a Double Fault

06:45 Why Overthinking Technique Makes It Worse

07:56 A Simple Between-Point Routine

10:02 Build Your Pressure Plan Before the Match

10:51 Creating a Written Plan for Pressure Scenarios

11:47 Can an Alter Ego Help You Compete?

13:18 Stop Playing Not to Lose

17:53 Show Wrap Up

#TennisMentalGame #TennisStrategy #SeniorTennis


For competitive tennis players over fifty, the game evolves. The desire to win remains sharp, but the path to victory requires a different map. Insider's Playbook: Smart Strategies for Competitive Senior Tennis Players Over 50 is that essential guide. Hosted by Mike Rogers, a seasoned senior tournament competitor and the founder of Senior Tennis Unpacked, this podcast digs into the nuanced realities of competing later in life. You won't find generic tips here. Instead, each conversation is a deep dive into the specific strategic adjustments, physical maintenance, and mental conditioning that give seasoned players a tangible edge. Mike brings on elite coaches who understand the senior athlete, national champions who are still dominating their age brackets, and performance experts focused on longevity. They unpack real, actionable strategies for everything from point construction and recovery to managing pressure during a tight third-set tiebreak. This is for players who analyze their matches, who know their strengths, and who are looking for that next piece of the puzzle to outsmart and outlast their opponents. Tune in to hear candid discussions that feel like a locker room talk with the most knowledgeable players and minds in senior tennis, all dedicated to helping you compete longer, smarter, and with more success.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

Insider's Playbook:  Smart Strategies for Competitive Senior Tennis Players Over 50
Podcast Episodes
Pain vs Injury: What Every Tennis Player Gets Wrong I Richard Brice [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 20:24
👉 Take my 5-Day Match Ready Challenge: https://www.skool.com/senior-tennis-unpacked-8081and be match ready as soon as you're get on the court. Richard Brice spent 17 years in chronic pain before he figured out what was d…
Anticipation Beats Speed After 50 — Here's Why I Nathan Martin [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 21:51
7 Day Free Trail - https://www.skool.com/senior-tennis-unpacked-8081/aboutSenior Tennis Unpacked Community Your reaction time is only declining 2–6 milliseconds per decade — and that decline is trainable. The real reason…
Miss Less, Win More: Consistency for Senior Players I Jonathan Stokke [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 19:16
7 Day Free Trail - https://www.skool.com/senior-tennis-unpacked-8081/aboutSenior Tennis Unpacked Community Episode DescriptionJonathan Stokke is back for his third appearance, and this time we're getting into the one thi…
Stop Playing Old, Weak Tennis - This Is All It Takes I Nathan Martin [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 20:33
7 Day Free Trail - https://www.skool.com/senior-tennis-unpacked-8081/aboutSenior Tennis Unpacked Community If you're over 50 and skipping the weight room because you think it'll wreck your joints or wear you out before m…
Fix Your Overhead: Neutralize the Most Annoying Shot I Jonathan Stokke [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 18:03
7 Day Free Trail - https://bit.ly/stu-skool Senior Tennis Unpacked Community 📄 Episode DescriptionWe all know the feeling: you're at the net, feeling like a pro, until that high, slow ball goes up and suddenly you're bac…