Trick Or Truth Part 2 | Reddits Spookiest Stories Ever

Trick Or Truth Part 2 | Reddits Spookiest Stories Ever

Author: The Friendsy Gang October 28, 2025 Duration: 36:01

The spookiest stories are back… and one of them isn’t real. Can you figure out which one’s fake before the end?

This week on Internet Friendsy, we dive into four eerie tales straight from the web:

👶 Story 1: A babysitting gig turns terrifying when someone slips into the house unnoticed.

🕯️ Story 2: “When my mom passed away, she gave me 10 signs…”—but are they signs of comfort or something darker?

🧸 Story 3: A little girl’s imaginary friend knows things she could never know in real life… and it’s only getting creepier.

📹 Story 4: Another babysitter swears she saw something moving in the baby’s room through the monitor—and it wasn’t the baby.

Tune in, guess which story is fake, and test your instincts in this Halloween-season sequel of Trick or Truth!

👻 New episodes every week.

🎧 Available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube.

📲 Follow @InternetFriendsy everywhere for bonus clips, polls, and bloopers.


Ever find yourself scrolling through a late-night Reddit rabbit hole or falling into a bizarre TikTok thread and thinking, "someone else needs to hear this"? That's the exact energy Joe and Whitney Sykes bring to their Internet Friendsy podcast. Each episode feels like pulling up a chair with two friends who have done the weirdest digital digging for you, sifting through stories, confessions, and chaotic experiences pulled from every corner of social media. They don't just read posts; they dive into them, debating, laughing, and trying to untangle the human logic behind the most viral and obscure online moments. From unbelievable Facebook rants to AI-generated oddities and true crime forums that make you question everything, the gang covers it. They even play a version of 'two truths and a lie' with internet tales, challenging you to spot the fabrication before they reveal the truth. It’s a comedy and culture show at heart, rooted in the personal journals of strangers and our collective societal obsession with sharing online. The Internet Friendsy podcast, from The Friendsy Gang, is your audio companion for those moments when the internet feels too strange to experience alone. You’ll find yourself listening and mentally comparing your own detective skills against theirs, all while getting a hearty dose of reality from our very unreal digital world.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 60

Internet Friendsy
Podcast Episodes
Secret Lives Revealed | Exposing The Reddit Crazies [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:01:17
What if the people you thought you knew were hiding something big… or several somethings?In this week’s episode of Internet Friendsy, we dive into four jaw-dropping stories that peel back the curtain on secret lives, sho…
Who’s Mom Is The AH? | Reddit Stories About Sus Moms [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 38:52
Mother’s Day is supposed to be sweet… unless you’re on Reddit, where it turns into emotional warfare. In this episode of Internet Friendsy, we’re diving into four wild stories of moms, MILs, and men who just don’t get it…
Celebre-Tea Time | Wild Reddit Celeb Stories [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 35:11
Celeb encounters can go one of two ways: totally unforgettable… or tragically cringe. This week on Internet Friendsy, we’re spilling the Celebre-Tea with a rapid-fire round of Reddit’s weirdest, wildest, and most unhinge…
Paging Dr. Disaster | Reddit Hospital Horror Stories [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 49:27
Welcome to Internet Friendsy, the podcast where Reddit stories meet judgment, chaos, and the occasional unsolicited life advice. This week’s episode is a medical-grade mess. We’re scrubbing in with stories about breakups…
Dumbest Hills to Die On | Reddits Dumbest Arguments [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 34:47
Some arguments just aren’t worth it… but these Redditors sure thought they were! In this episode of Internet Friendsy, we’re diving into the pettiest, most bizarre hills people have chosen to die on.• A son refuses to pa…
Stalk Market Crash | Real Reddit Stalker Stories [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:01:46
Ever felt like someone was watching you? In this Internet Friendsy episode, Stalk Market Crash, we dive into jaw-dropping Reddit stories about real-life stalkers—from unsettling crushes to full-blown obsessions. • Librar…
Therapy is Scare-apy ☠️ | Reddit Therapy Blunders [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 49:08
Therapy is supposed to be a safe space… but what happens when it goes horribly wrong? In this episode of Internet Friendsy, we break down the most shocking, awkward, and unethical therapy blunders from Reddit.• A woman f…