FEELS LIKE TWO CASES OF THE 1% KIND: DAVID GRUBBS AND BILL AND PEGGY STEPHENSON

FEELS LIKE TWO CASES OF THE 1% KIND: DAVID GRUBBS AND BILL AND PEGGY STEPHENSON

Author: Melissa Morgan, Bleav June 18, 2025 Duration: 50:54
Very few murders have absolutely no persons of interest or perceived suspects. Sometimes these baffling cases can confound even the most seasoned and perceptive investigators. The murder of David Grubs and the double homicide of Bill and Peggy Stephenson both from 2011, have kept the original detectives and the FBI stumped. These two nightmares need to end for their family and friends who grieve them every day. There is no closure but I hope we can help them see justice.

Melissa Morgan brings her professional broadcasting skills and an insatiable curiosity to Just The Tip-Sters: True Crime Podcast. This isn't a dry recitation of facts; it's a guided exploration into the cases that linger in the margins, both solved and chillingly open. Each episode feels like joining a conversation with a friend who happens to be deeply knowledgeable about detective work and forensic science, making complex details accessible and strangely compelling. You'll find yourself pulled into investigations, examining the evidence alongside her, and appreciating the odd tangents into the spiritual or the simply weird that some cases inspire. The tone here is unique-it respects the gravity of the subject while allowing space for the gallows humor that often accompanies a deep dive into the absurdities of human behavior. It’s that blend of professionalism, contagious curiosity, and unexpected wit that defines the journey. This podcast lives in the details others might overlook, always listening for that one piece of the puzzle, that potential tip from anywhere, that could shift an entire perspective. Prepare for a ride that is as thoughtful as it is engaging, where mysteries are picked apart with both a critical eye and a genuine sense of wonder about the stories we tell about crime and the people involved.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Just The Tip-Sters: True Crime Podcast
Podcast Episodes
FEELS LIKE YOU CAN'T BLAME THE MOON: THE SMITH FAMILY MASSACRE [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 50:18
Money makes people do awful things sometimes. Very rarely do you hear about a son torturing his mother to ger the combination to her safe by starting with cutting his elderly mothers little finger before bludgeoning her…
FEELS LIKE PEARL BRYAN TRUSTED THE WRONG MAN [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 54:19
A terrible story that starts in small town Indiana, shows up in Cincinnati Ohio finally ending in a field in Northern Kentucky with a well loved 20 Year old Pearl Bryan being found decapitated. Thank you to the remarkabl…
FEELS LIKE BILLY CHERMIRMIR WAS THE BIGGEST COWARD [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 53:13
How do you come from Africa, become a health care worker in the US and then resort to killing over 20 elderly women for their jewelry? People Magazine dubbed Billy Chermirmir's tactics from The 'Serial Killers Playbook."…
FEELS LIKE K9 MOZART IS AN EARTH ANGEL [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 50:08
When a few people tell me about a remarkable canine program that is only being utilized in four law enforcement agencies across the country and one of them is in my home town of Northern Kentucky, I was skeptical. But co…
FEELS LIKE JAMES "JIMMY" TIDWELL RAN INTO THE WORST GUY: ISRAEL KEYES [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 54:01
When hard working, loyal, salt of the Earth guy like Jimmy Tidwell goes missing in February of 2012 after finishing his regular shift at work, no one can imagine what could've happened. After friends and family members w…
FEELS LIKE JUDY SMITH WAS A LONG WAY FROM HOME [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 57:50
April of 1997 finds accomplished, loving wife and mother Judy Smith accompanying her attorney husband Jeffrey Smith from their home in Boston to Philadelphia for a health care industry legal conference. April 10th was go…
FEELS LIKE INDIANA WANTS HIM-FOR 22 YEARS: THE MURDER OF ROBIN BAXTER [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 46:52
A small town in South Eastern Indiana, New Albany has gone through some very interesting changes. An area where more wealthy residents lived in large brick homes over looking the Ohio River when it was settled, it was al…
FEELS LIKE TAMMY LYNN LEPPERT HAD A BRIGHT FUTURE [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:01:21
With newspaper headlines like "Brevard's Answer to Shirley Temple," and "Cocoa Beach Girl Star of Tomorrow," you would think Florida native Tammy Lynn Leppert had the world on a string. Performing since she was two years…