A Giant Crypto Grift: Xbox Chief on His New Blockchain Thriller and Why Web3 Still Matters
In the midst of today’s AI hysteria, have we forgotten about blockchain technology and the seductive Web3 promise of decentralization? Robbie Bach, longtime Xbox chief and lieutenant of former Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer, certainly hasn’t. In his new novel, The Blockchain Syndicate, the prescient Bach imagines not only a giant political crypto grift, but also warns about the siren song of Distributed Autonomous Organizations (DAOs). No, blockchain might not be as sexy or lucrative as LLMs these days - but Web3 still matters even if, as Bach suggests, its promise of a decentralized network remains more seductive than substantive.
1. Crypto as “Giant Grift” Bach views cryptocurrency as a highly risky, speculative investment vehicle comparable to commodities like gold or silver, but warns there’s “definitely a giant grift” happening, with vulnerable people—particularly older investors putting their savings at risk—being exploited by those taking advantage of the crypto craze.
2. AI Bubble Will Burst (But Not Catastrophically) Bach believes we’re in an AI investment bubble where valuations are unsustainable. He predicts a “sorting” of winners and losers over the next 12-18 months, with many AI investments failing to pay out, though he avoids the term “explosive pop” in favor of a more gradual reckoning.
3. Blockchain: Powerful Tool, Double-Edged Sword Despite AI hype, Bach argues blockchain remains highly relevant and current. He sees it as neither inherently good nor bad—just a tool that can be used for legitimate purposes or criminal ones. He’s particularly intrigued by its dual nature: ultimate transparency yet also ultimate obfuscation through anonymity.
4. Microsoft’s Secret Weapon: Adaptability Bach credits Microsoft’s longevity to its ability to make “tectonic shifts” across generations—from DOS to Windows, to cloud computing, to AI. He argues this skill at navigating massive transitions under Gates, Ballmer, and Nadella is more impressive than any single product innovation.
5. FBI and CIA Are Irreplaceable Bach emphasizes that regardless of political views about current leadership, institutions like the FBI and CIA are essential for national security with no viable replacement. If they’re not working well, the solution is to fix them, not abandon them—a theme central to his thriller’s premise.
Keen On America is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit keenon.substack.com/subscribe
Episode 2524: Martin Wolf on whether Trump's tariffs are as dumb as they seem
Episode 2522: Edmund Fawcett on Trump as a Third Way between Liberalism and Conservatism
Episode 2521: Michael Stein on the Real Lives of the American Working Class
Episode 2520: Larry Aldrich on what's Right with America
Episode 2519: Is Criticism of Israel, by definition, Anti-Semitic?
Episode 2518: 100 Days or 100 Years?
Episode 2517: Soli Ozel on the Light at the End of the Authoritarian Tunnel
Episode 2516: Jason Pack on the Trumpian Post-Apocalypse
Episode 2515: David A. Graham on how Project 2025 is Reshaping America
Episode 2514: How to turn America into a Waymo Democracy
Episode 2513: Adam Hochschild on how American History is Repeating itself, first as Tragedy, then as Trump
Episode 2512: Adam Becker on AI Overlords, Space Empires, and Silicon Valley's Crusade to Control the Fate of Humanity
Episode 2511: Jemima Kelly on why she hasn't quite given up on America