It's Always Exploding Somewhere: Why No Weapon Is Ever Perfect
There’s something absurdly Strangelovian about the American quest for a perfect weapon. As Jeffrey Stern warns in The Warhead, his new history of The Paveway, the first “smart” bomb, weapons are always, like their human engineers, imperfect. “It’s always exploding somewhere,” Stern dryly notes, and those explosions in the Texas Instruments developed Paveway were not only unexpected, but often tragically imperfect. So for example, the Second Gulf War was the most precise air war in history and yet within a year, more civilians died than in Hiroshima and Nagasaki combined. The conceit of “perfection”, Stern warns, might be as quintessentially American as the fatally flawed Walt Disney corporation or the Kennedy dynasty (both part of the Paveway story). Which is why this history of smart weapons makes such chilling reading in an AI age when Americans are once again being promised perfect military technology.
Keen On America is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit keenon.substack.com/subscribe
Episode 2236: Stephen Riggio on the greatest Italian novel you've never heard of
Episode 2235: Peter Osnos on LBJ & McNamara - the Vietnam Partnership Bound to Fail
Episode 2234: Terrence Sejnowski asks whether our brains and AI are converging
Episode 2233: More than a Tool: How AI is becoming an independent actor in our world
Episode 2232: Mark Galeotti on whether Putin is a prisoner or a master of history
Episode 2231: Bill Adair on the Epidemic of Political Lying, why Republicans do it more, and how it could destroy American democracy
Episode 2230: Seth Godin on why we are all hard-wired for hope
Episode 2229: Robert Skidelsky worries about the Human Condition in the Age of Artificial Intelligence
Episode 2228: Bethanne Patrick on Al Pacino, the Queen, Bob Woodward and Ketanji Brown Jackson
Episode 2227: Allie Funk on how to Build Online Trust
Episode 2226: Why the Economics of our AI Age might be unlike all previous Tech Revolutions
Episode 2225: Katherine Epstein on how American Historians are Killing History
Episode 2224: Celeste Marcus on why the humanism of Agnieszka Holland's movies remain so relevant in our Trumpian age