#423 Melody Schoenfeld - Vegan Myth Busting

#423 Melody Schoenfeld - Vegan Myth Busting

Author: Andrew Coates December 9, 2025 Duration: 49:38

Melody Schoenfeld is an author, gym owner, nutrition coach, and holds a Master's in Health Psychology. She brings deep expertise, a sharp nonsense detector, and evidence-based nuance to one of the most polarizing topics in nutrition - vegan diets.

In this episode, Melody and Andrew dive into the most persistent vegan myths, bad-faith arguments, and common misunderstandings from both sides of the vegan vs. non-vegan debate.

Melody shares insight on:
• Dispelling the myth - "There’s no such thing as a healthy vegan"
• The most common arguments claiming vegan diets aren’t healthy
• The problem with vegan dogma motives and navigating bad faith actors
• Dispelling the myth - "You can get everything you need from food alone on a vegan diet"
• What supplementation vegans actually need (and why)
• Whether vegans struggle to get enough iron and calcium
• Dispelling the myth - "All proteins are created equal"
• The truth about needing a "complete protein profile" in each meal
• The real story behind soy protein and soy fear-mongering
• Whether veganism is more expensive than omnivorous eating
• The benefits of moving more plant-based even if you don’t go fully vegan
• When vegan diets become too restrictive
• And much more

IG: @5ftoffury1


CHAPTERS


00:16 Catching Up with Melody Schoenfeld
01:50 Debunking Vegan Myths
03:20 Nutritional Considerations for Vegans
09:57 Challenges and Misconceptions of Veganism
16:46 Mental Health and Veganism
22:54 Athletic Performance on a Vegan Diet
25:57 Navigating Vegan Nutrition - Learning What Your Body Needs
26:31 Calcium and Bone Health for Vegans
27:44 Understanding Vegan Protein Sources
32:14 Debunking Soy Myths and Exploring Protein Options
35:43 The Cost and Convenience of Vegan Nutrition
37:30 Health Benefits of a Plant-Based Diet
42:58 Challenges and Misconceptions of Vegan Diets
45:12 Conclusion and Final Thoughts


SUPPORT THE SHOW


If this episode helped you, you can help me by:
• Subscribing and checking out more episodes
• Sharing it on your social media (tag me - I'll respond)
• Sending it to a friend who needs this


FOLLOW ANDREW COATES


Instagram: @andrewcoatesfitness
https://www.andrewcoatesfitness.com


PARTNERS AND RESOURCES


RP Strength App (use code COATESRP)
https://www.rpstrength.com/coates

Just Bite Me Meals (use code ANDREWCOATESFITNESS for 10% off)
https://justbitememeals.com/

MacrosFirst - FREE PREMIUM TRIAL
Download MacrosFirst and during setup you’ll be asked “How did you hear about us?”
Type in: ANDREW

KNKG Bags (15% off)
https://www.knkg.com/Andrew59676

Versa Gripps (discount link)
https://www.versagripps.com/andrewcoates

TRAINHEROIC - FREE 90-DAY TRIAL (2 steps)

  1. Go to https://www.trainheroic.com/liftfree

  2. Reply to the email you receive (or email trials@trainheroic.com) and let them know I sent you


Andrew Coates hosts Lift Free And Diet Hard, a conversation grounded in the belief that strength and wellness are built on more than just routines. This podcast moves beyond quick fixes to examine the principles and personal stories that shape a sustainable, intentional life. You’ll hear from a variety of inspiring guests who share not only their expertise but also the real-world challenges and triumphs they’ve faced. The discussions naturally weave together the science of fitness with the practicalities of daily choices, offering a nuanced look at what it means to truly care for your physical and mental health. Each episode is designed to provide actionable insights you can use to navigate your own path, fostering resilience and confidence whether you're in the gym or the kitchen. By focusing on informed decision-making over dogma, the Lift Free And Diet Hard podcast becomes a resource for anyone looking to cut through the noise of wellness culture. Andrew facilitates these explorations with a focus on empowerment, ensuring every conversation adds a layer of understanding to the complex journey of building a strong, healthy life.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Lift Free And Diet Hard with Andrew Coates
Podcast Episodes
#402 Jaclyn Phillips - The Unseen Mental Health Battle [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 55:35
Jaclyn Phillips is the Head Coach of Team Strong Girls and a vocal mental health advocate. Jaclyn joins me to share her wisdom and thoughts on:-How someone can on the surface seem like they live a charmed life but deal w…
#401 Abby Langer - Scorched Earth On Nutritional Pseudoscience [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:02:03
Abby Langer is one of the best resources for combatting the lunacy we see online and backs it up as a dietician with years of experience. Abby joins me to share her thoughts on:-the negative reaction to Serena Williams u…
#400 Holly Baxter - Muscle Building: Volume, Frequency, and Intensity [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:04:28
Holly Baxter is a prominent evidence based coach and research communicator with a Masters in Dietetics, all while being a competitive IFBB Pro.Holly joins me to deep dive into research and practical application of:-Do we…
#399 Dan Go - Getting Healthy in Your 40’s and Beyond [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 52:15
Dan Go is a fitness coach for entrepreneurs who’s build a massive media presence with actionable advice while ignoring the combativeness of the fitness industry. Dan guests to share his wisdom on:-What you need to focus…
#396 Hattie Boydle - What’s The Story You’re Telling Yourself? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:07:10
Hattie Boydle is a world champion competitor plus coach and educator. Hattie joins the podcast to share her wisdom on:-Challenging our narratives and stories about why believe and do what we do-Why women can build muscle…
#393 Michael Boyle - Should Young Athletes Specialize Early? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:07:00
Michael Boyle is the founder of Mike Boyle’s Strength and Conditioning, author, and a pioneer and icon of strength and conditioning.Mike generously guests to share his wisdom and experience about:-Should kids specialize…