#472 Dr Eric Helms - Do You Need To Train To Failure, Do You Need More Than 1 Set, Do You Need More Than 6 Reps To Build Muscle?

#472 Dr Eric Helms - Do You Need To Train To Failure, Do You Need More Than 1 Set, Do You Need More Than 6 Reps To Build Muscle?

Author: Andrew Coates May 25, 2026 Duration: 1:26:28

Dr. Eric Helms returns to add important nuance to the extreme and absolute claims we see on social media about building muscle.


Have you ever heard the following claims:


“Only the last 5 reps count, everything else is junk volume”

“You need to train to failure to build muscle”

“There’s no benefit to more than 1 hard set for hypertrophy”

“You never need to train more than 4–6 reps for hypertrophy”

“People can’t accurately assess their proximity to failure at higher rep ranges”


Eric tackles these and more hypertrophy claims and concepts with research and provides:


Where they may hold technical truth

Where they’re misleading

Where they’re lacking critical context or nuance

Where they don’t work for every population


Plus Eric explains why you might not be in calorie maintenance even though the scale stays constant while you gain muscle and lose fat, and how much of a calorie surplus do we really need to efficiently build muscle.


Eric brings practical reality to the divisive social media hypertrophy playground.


This is essential listening for anyone trying to build muscle, coaches people who want to build muscle, or feels confused about conflicting claims online.


Instagram: @helms3dmj


CHAPTERS


00:30 Failure Training Basics

03:44 Hypertrophy Evidence

05:52 Strength Versus Failure

07:01 Real World Failure Limits

10:13 Defining True Failure

11:30 Adapting To Hard Work

14:55 Volume Intensity Debate

16:51 Silos And Survivorship

25:50 Bodybuilding Volume Reality

32:05 Diminishing Returns Explained

38:44 Practical Constraints and Planning

40:40 Linear Vs Diminishing Curves

42:58 Volume vs Failure Tradeoffs

46:42 Do Last Reps Count

48:06 Beginners vs Advanced Needs

52:36 High Volume High RIR Methods

56:56 RIR Accuracy At High Reps

01:03:01 Why Heavy Reps All Count

01:07:20 Practical Rep Range Choices

01:08:58 Calorie Surplus For Growth

01:11:10 Surplus Data: Beginners vs Trained

01:21:38 How Big Should A Surplus Be

01:24:09 Wrap Up and Resources


SUPPORT THE SHOW


If this episode helped you make sense of hypertrophy science, training volume, or muscle building myths, you can support the show by:


Subscribing and checking out more episodes

Sharing it on social media (tag me and I’ll respond)

Sending it to a coach, lifter, or someone overwhelmed by conflicting training advice


FOLLOW ANDREW COATES


Instagram: @andrewcoatesfitness

https://www.andrewcoatesfitness.com


PARTNERS AND RESOURCES


RP Strength App (use code COATESRP)

https://www.rpstrength.com/coates


Just Bite Me Meals (use code ANDREWCOATESFITNESS for 10% off)

https://justbitememeals.com


MacrosFirst – FREE Premium Trial

Download MacrosFirst and during setup select ANDREW


KNKG Bags (15% off)

https://www.knkg.com/Andrew59676


Versa Gripps

https://www.versagripps.com/andrewcoates


TRAINHEROIC – FREE 90-Day Trial

https://www.trainheroic.com/liftfree


Reply to the email you receive (or email trials@trainheroic.com) and let them know Andrew sent you


Andrew Coates hosts Lift Free And Diet Hard, a conversation grounded in the belief that strength and wellness are built on more than just routines. This podcast moves beyond quick fixes to examine the principles and personal stories that shape a sustainable, intentional life. You’ll hear from a variety of inspiring guests who share not only their expertise but also the real-world challenges and triumphs they’ve faced. The discussions naturally weave together the science of fitness with the practicalities of daily choices, offering a nuanced look at what it means to truly care for your physical and mental health. Each episode is designed to provide actionable insights you can use to navigate your own path, fostering resilience and confidence whether you're in the gym or the kitchen. By focusing on informed decision-making over dogma, the Lift Free And Diet Hard podcast becomes a resource for anyone looking to cut through the noise of wellness culture. Andrew facilitates these explorations with a focus on empowerment, ensuring every conversation adds a layer of understanding to the complex journey of building a strong, healthy life.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

Lift Free And Diet Hard with Andrew Coates
Podcast Episodes
#505 Elizabeth Ward & Hillary Wright - Menopause Nutrition [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 53:36
Elizabeth Ward and Hillary Wright are registered dietitians, authors of *The Menopause Diet Plan*, and together are known as The Menopause Dietitians.They join me to cut through the noise around menopause nutrition and e…
#504 Harley Pasternak - Diets and GLP-1 Use in Popular Culture [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:02:15
What happens when evidence-based nutrition collides with celebrity culture, fad diets, GLP-1 medications, and increasingly extreme body-image trends?Harley Pasternak is an internationally renowned trainer, author, educat…
#503 Kevin Carr - How to Train for Independent Aging [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:07:45
Kevin Carr is co-owner of several businesses and brands, including Mike Boyle Strength and Conditioning and Certified Functional Strength Coach, and author of the new book Prescribing Movement as Medicine.Kevin returns t…
#501 Stan Efferding - Nutrition for Muscle Growth [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 56:53
Stan Efferding is an icon of bodybuilding, powerlifting, and elite evidence-based coaching.Stan returns with his unique ability to interpret cutting-edge research and combine it with decades of real-world experience coac…
#500 Dr. Layne Norton - You Will Not Outwork Me [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:07:07
I’m honoured to celebrate episode #500 with Dr. Layne Norton as my guest.Layne is an icon of the fitness industry: a prolific educator, author, champion, world-record-holding powerlifter, and a major influence throughout…
#499 Dr. Sean Pastuch - Live More, Hurt Less [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:08:30
Dr. Sean Pastuch returns to share lessons from his career and his new book, Live More, Hurt Less.Sean joins me to discuss:• How he defines “Live More, Hurt Less”• What that philosophy looks like in real life• Why helping…