***LIVE*** TENA MASHELL PREAST -The Stranger at the Door

***LIVE*** TENA MASHELL PREAST -The Stranger at the Door

Author: Locating the Lost February 21, 2026 Duration: 1:00:24

On August 4, 1991, 19-year-old Tena Mashell Preast stepped out of her Lawton, Oklahoma home to speak with a mysterious visitor. She didn't take her purse, her keys, or even her shoes. In just 20 minutes, the vibrant young woman with a "heart of gold" vanished without a trace, leaving a family to spend the next 34 years fighting for the truth.In this deeply emotional episode of Locating the Lost, we sit down with Laurie McCauley, Tena’s cousin and the sister-figure who raised her. Laurie shares the raw, unfiltered reality of a family left behind by a system that often overlooked Tena. We explore the investigative hurdles, the missed opportunities, and the theories that continue to haunt those who loved her.We’re diving into the theories and the chilling details:The Cellar Secret: Why was a dirt-packed cellar on the property suddenly filled in shortly after Tena disappeared?The Restraining Order: Within a year before she vanished, Tena had taken legal steps to protect herself from an ex-boyfriend.The "Man at the Door": Was the mysterious visitor a stranger, or someone Tena knew well enough to step outside without her belongings?The Lawton Serial Killer: Does Tena’s case link to the notorious Cache Road killings, or was her proximity to victim Barbara Berry just a tragic coincidence?Tattoos of Identity: We discuss the importance of her unique tattoos—the word "Cameel" and a yellow smiley face with a red bullet hole saying "Have a nice day"—as potential keys to finding her today.📢 WE NEED YOUR VOICES:Silence is the only thing keeping this case cold. If you lived in Lawton in the early '90s or have information about the property on NW 17th Street, your tip could be the missing piece of the puzzle.How you can help:Submit a Tip: Contact the Lawton Police Department at 580-581-3270 (Reference Case #1991-7194).Share Her Story: Visit Oklahoma Cold Cases to share Tena’s profile and keep her name alive.Listen now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or YouTube.Our LinkTree to follow on all social media: https://linktr.ee/locatingthelost?utm...#LocatingTheLost #TenaPreast #JusticeForTena #MissingInOklahoma #LawtonColdCase #TrueCrimePodcast #OklahomaColdCases #ColdCase #MissingPerson #SilenceIsBetrayal #Missing #Truecrime


There are names that linger in the air of a town long after the news vans have left, and stories that exist only in the fragmented memories of those left waiting. Locating the Lost sits with those stories. This isn't a procedural rundown of cold cases, but a deliberate effort to recenter the human beings at the heart of every disappearance. Each episode focuses on a single person who has vanished, weaving together the details of their life, the circumstances of their last known moments, and the enduring impact of their absence on family and community. You'll hear the subtle tensions in a detective's voice, the raw hope in a sibling's recollection, and the heavy silence that follows an unanswered question. The goal here isn't sensationalism, but preservation-giving auditory space to narratives that risk fading from public consciousness. By tuning into this podcast, you become a witness to these searches, understanding that every case file represents a world upended. It's a sobering, necessary listen for anyone who believes that forgetting is a second disappearance.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Locating the Lost
Podcast Episodes
S3E6 Where is Nancy Lynn Green? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 38:52
On this episode we speak to April Green Thompson the daughter of Nancy Lynn Green who disappeared September 30th, 2002 from Wheeling, WV. She vanished on Sept. 30, 2002, after being dropped off on the campus of the Ohio…
S3E5 What Really Happened to Robert Morrison? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:04:33
On this episode we speak to Jessica Morrison who reached out to us about the suspicious death of her brother Robert Morrison. Jessica believes his unattended death may have been murder, she writes: Hi there. My name is J…
S3E4 Missing Pitchers-What Happened to Dorothy and Danielle Pitcher? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 57:30
Courtesy of missingpitchers.org: On May 23rd, 1993, Dorothy Pitcher (47) and Danielle Pitcher (14) were kidnapped while walking along highway 181 at the s-curve, in Sunizona, Arizona. The mother and daughter left home at…
S2 E14 Who Killed Mary Tanner? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 57:43
On this episode we speak to the sister of Mary Tanner, Dr. Beth Goodwin and her continued fight for justice for the death of sister. On the evening of July 7, 1978, 18-year-old Mary Ellen Tanner attended parties in a woo…
S3 E3 Have They Found Patricia Lee Otto? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 51:38
Patricia was last seen in Lewiston, Idaho late in the evening on September 2, 1976. She got into an argument with her husband, Ralph Otto, and left the house angrily. She never returned. Ralph didn't report her missing;…
S3 E2 The Suspicious Death of Linda Maxwell [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 45:19
A teenage girl goes out with friends in Calais. Days later, her body washes ashore. Life in the small town turned upside down in 1984. Kim Steadman was one of the last people to see Linda Maxwell alive 37 years ago, she…
S3 E1 Who Stole the Life of Johnney Leavitt? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 56:52
August 19, 2016 - Johnney Leavitt, 20, was walking down Route 172 (L'etang Road) towards Back Bay Road in L'Etete just before 4:00 am when he was struck by a vehicle. Mr. Leavitt died at the scene. It is believed that he…
S2 E13 What Really Happened to Liz Perkins? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 59:35
On the evening of July 31st, 2018 Liz Munster, who also goes by the name Perkins had been picked up at a friend's house in Augusta Maine by a male individual at about 8:30pm. She never came home, her family believe she o…
S2E12 Justice for Kaylene Oehling [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 56:46
Kaylene Oehling was last seen at a friend's home in Etna, Pennsylvania late in the evening on January 9, 2020. She left home to meet her boyfriend, Michael D. Manno, and was supposed to return, but never came back. At 1:…

«1...678910