Charles McCullar - A Case Re-examined — Myths vs. Facts

Charles McCullar - A Case Re-examined — Myths vs. Facts

Author: Locations Unknown September 26, 2025 Duration: 1:03:35
In 2019, Locations Unknown covered a young photographer bound for winter shots at Crater Lake National Park. The case spawned wild theories, unsubstantiated lore, and even an episode of The UnXplained with William Shatner. This week, we return with new FBI releases to separate myth from record. We revisit his route near Stump Lake, the Bybee Creek discovery, and the brutal winter terrain that shaped his fate.  Join us this week as we reinvestigate the case of Charles McCullar with fresh evidence and new theories.

Learn more about Locations Unknown: https://linktr.ee/LocationsUnknown

Check out our other shows on the Unknown Media Network:
Crime Off The Grid
Off The Trails
The Weirdos We Know  
Who Runs This Park


New Patreon Shoutouts: Rachel Jones, Rebecca Rhea, & Simon Vaux

Episode suggestion shoutout: Stevey Smith 

Get 35% of all orders at The Hiker's Cachethe official store of Locations Unknown, by becoming a member on Patreon!

Want to help the show out and get even more Locations Unknown content!  For as little as $5 a month, you can become a Patron of Locations Unknown and get access to our episodes early, special members only episode, free swag, swag contests, and discounts to our Locations Unknown Store!  Become a Patron of the Locations Unknown Podcast by visiting our Patreon page.  (https://www.patreon.com/locationsunknown)  

All our Patreon only content (Audio & Video) can now be accessed via Spotify.  (Active subscription to our Patreon channel is required.) -- Locations Unknown Subscriber Only Show | Podcast on Spotify  

Want to call into the show and leave us a message?  Now you can!  Call 208-391-6913 and leave Locations Unknown a voice message and we may air it on a future message! 

View live recordings of the show on our YouTube channel: Locations Unknown - YouTube

View Episode Sources

Presented by Unknown Media Group.

Hosts:
Mike Van de Bogert
Joe Erato

Intro/Outro “Cornfield Chase” – Cinematic Waves & Rafael Krux (licensed) → https://soundcloud.com/cinematicwav3s/cornfield-chase

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/locations-unknown--6183838/support.

Locations Unknown ventures into the silent, vast spaces where people have simply gone missing. Hosts Mike & Joe guide each episode through a specific case, piecing together timelines from the final known moments, through the often-frustrating official searches, and into the lingering questions that haunt families and park rangers alike. This isn't just a true crime podcast; it’s a close look at the intersection of human error, unpredictable nature, and the peculiar geography of places like dense national forests and isolated mountain ranges that can swallow a person whole. You’ll hear about the decisions made in the critical hours, the terrain that complicated everything, and the community of experts and amateurs who keep looking. The show naturally explores how these landscapes, while beautiful, hold secrets, making the wilderness itself a central character in every story. Tune in for a respectful, detailed examination of stories that end not with a conclusion, but with an open map and a deepened mystery. The podcast digs into the cultural fascination with these vanishings and what they reveal about our relationship with the wild, remote corners of the country.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 173

Locations Unknown
Podcast Episodes
Special Release: Fan Voicemail reactions - Part 11 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 47:44
Hey friends! We’re taking this week off while we make a few upgrades to the studio. In the meantime, enjoy our latest subscriber only episode, where we listen to and react to the newest voicemails we’ve received. We also…
Melvin Nadel - Santa Fe National Forest - New Mexico [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:10:23
September 6th, 2009: a 61-year-old fitness instructor, black belt, and seasoned bow hunter leaves his campsite near Elk Mountain in New Mexico's Santa Fe National Forest. He tells his two companions he won't go far and w…
Ron Dailey - Sierra National Forest - California [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 58:06
October 13th, 2025: a 65-year-old seasoned hunter leaves his Selma, California home for a routine day of deer hunting in the Sierra National Forest, a wilderness he's navigated for over fifty years. When he doesn't retur…
Johnny Waterman - Denali National Park & Preserve - Alaska [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 55:34
April 1st, 1981: a 28-year-old elite solo climber leaves a remote shelter deep in Alaska’s Ruth Glacier, pulling a sled and heading alone toward Denali’s imposing east side. Experienced, deliberate, and traveling light,…
Death Valley National Park Cold Cases [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:03:15
May 2019 to May 2022: three men travel alone into the vast desert backcountry of Death Valley National Park; one to cache water in a remote canyon, another to check on a vehicle at an isolated hot spring, and a third who…
Paul Victor Tomasso - Tonto National Forest - Arizona [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 45:37
February 13th, 2014: a 56-year-old experienced outdoorsman drives deep into Arizona’s Tonto National Forest for a planned multi-day solo hike. After parking along a quiet highway near the community of Young, he leaves be…
Life Beyond the Map: Interview w/ Modern Explorer, Tay Wanders [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 58:21
Today we’re sitting down with Tay, a Southern girl turned road-warrior and modern explorer who approaches adventure with confidence, intention, and a grounded perspective.A single mom and storyteller at heart, Tay create…
Laura Macke - Olympic National Park - Washington [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:02:01
October 30th, 2022: a 35-year-old counselor sets out alone into the storm-soaked rainforests of Olympic National Park. As an experienced hiker with survival training, she planned a multi-day trek into the remote backcoun…
Bryan Skilinski - Great Sand Dunes National Park - Colorado [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 52:27
February 11th, 2017, a 40-year-old man from New York, deep in a mid-life crisis, vanishes into a brutal winter storm at Great Sand Dunes National Park. Miraculously he is rescued after five freezing nights, calling it hi…
Robert Fitzgerald - George Washington National Forest - Virginia [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 53:53
November 12th, 2012, a seasoned hiker and devoted runner fails to show up for work after a solo trip to Virginia’s Confederate Breastworks Trail. His car is discovered days later, packed with food and supplies, but no si…