With all the buzz surrounding the Gwen Hasselquist case and the upcoming
Crime Junkie episode (releasing October 27, 2025), we thought it was the perfect time to re-release our original four-part series on Gwen’s story, first published in 2021. For Gwen’s family, friends, and everyone who cared deeply for her, we’re truly grateful her case is finally receiving the attention it deserves.
That said, we need to get something off our chests.
We first discovered Gwen’s case in September 2021, when one of our co-hosts happened to meet a lawyer in Chicago who was quietly investigating it on his own time. What he shared shocked us, there was
no coverage anywhere. No news articles, no Reddit threads, no social media discussions. Gwen’s story had been completely forgotten.
We decided to change that.
Over the following years, we poured countless hours into investigating this case, speaking with dozens of people close to Gwen (many of whom still haven’t given permission for their accounts to be made public), filing FOIA requests, and combing through hundreds of pages of messages and correspondence. The result was over six hours of in-depth reporting, released across four episodes between November 2021 and August 2022. To this day, people continue to reach out to us about Gwen’s story.
Unfortunately, Crime Junkie has now released an episode claiming they “discovered” and “investigated” the case. That is simply not true. Their work appears to have been directly lifted from our years of research and a Reddit (post), without any acknowledgment or attempt to contact us. Sadly, this behavior is not new for
Crime Junkie, which has previously faced plagiarism accusations from several other creators, including
On the Case with Paula Zahn,
The Trail Went Cold,
Trace Evidence,
Once Upon a Crime, and
Dealing Justice.
What’s most disappointing is that we genuinely believe the hosts of
Crime Junkie share our ultimate goal, to give Gwen’s story the attention it deserves. We’re not backed by a mega corporation with an army of researchers; we’re an independent show run by two guys with full-time jobs and families who simply love telling meaningful stories.
At the end of the day, if their episode helps spread awareness about Gwen, that’s a win for her and her loved ones, and that’s what matters most.
We hope you’ll take this opportunity to listen (or re-listen) to our updated and remastered four-part series on the disappearance of Gwen Hasselquist, releasing this weekend. And don’t worry,
Part 2 of Lost in the Shadow of the Rockies is still scheduled for release on October 31.
Thank you for continuing to support independent podcasts like ours. We truly appreciate every one of you.
Original episode summary:In episode 68, we continue our investigation of the suspicious death of Gwen Hasselquist, interviewing Dora, Gwen's stepsister. Dora had recently reconnected with Gwen and was at her house a few hours after she was reported missing and stayed around for the initial days after her death. Join us this week as we learn new details about Gwen's life before she died and what happened in the weeks after her death.
Notes on this episode: - We've been informed, after recording this episode, that the automated toll booth cameras only record the license plate, not the person driving. We were also informed that there might not have been video cameras that would have captured someone walking or running off the bridge.
Gwen Hasselquist Part 1 - The Original Investigation (Orig. Released 11/8/2021)
Gwen Hasselquist Part 2 - The Police Report (Orig....
