92. Are PE Firms Ruining Machining? A New & Better Model for Buying Shops with Mark Hillenburg

92. Are PE Firms Ruining Machining? A New & Better Model for Buying Shops with Mark Hillenburg

Author: Paul Van Metre November 19, 2025 Duration: 1:08:02

Over the last decade, I've watched private equity surge into the machining world — and I've seen firsthand how often the short-term flip-in-five-years strategy ends up hurting shops, people, customers, and entire supply chains. While the capital can help, the incentives often drive decisions that weaken the very businesses PE firms acquire. But every now and then, someone comes along with a model that stops you in your tracks because it actually makes sense for our industry.

That someone is Mark Hillenburg, co-founder of Collective Manufacturing Group, a company built on a radically different vision: buy great machine shops and hold them forever. No flipping. No short-term targets. No cultural upheaval. Just long-term stewardship, disciplined investment, and a deep respect for the people who built these businesses in the first place.

In this conversation, Mark and I dig into his incredible journey — starting a tiny shop with his father in a 700-square-foot garage, learning machining the hard way, living through major turnarounds, scaling multi-site aerospace manufacturing, and ultimately becoming disillusioned with traditional PE models. His experiences shaped a philosophy that aligns closely with the heart of American manufacturing: protect the legacy, empower the people, and build a business that lasts.

We also talk about how his team is already reviving shuttered shops, empowering internal leaders, gaining trust from OEMs, and receiving deal flow from customers who don't want their critical suppliers bought by traditional PE firms. If you care about the long-term health of the machining ecosystem, you'll want to hear this one. Mark's approach gives me real hope for where this industry can go.

You will want to hear this episode if you are interested in...

  • (0:00) Mark Hillenburg's background in manufacturing
  • (7:07) Exiting the family shop and transitioning into sales/business development roles
  • (9:10) Rebuilding MSP Aviation during a downturn and rising to President/CEO 
  • (13:25) Reconnecting with Matt Ritchie to pursue a new vision: Collective Manufacturing Group
  • (22:38) Finding and acquiring the three shops they purchased
  • (26:59) Why owners chose Collective over traditional PE buyers
  • (32:09) Identifying "hidden gem" employees and future leaders
  • (35:22) Culture-building and becoming an employer of choice
  • (38:34) Collective's four-pillar stakeholder philosophy
  • (39:00) Deal flow
  • (48:13) What matters to Collective when it comes to PE and acquisitions 
  • (51:50) How shops create strategic value—not just parts
  • (53:17) Why going deep with customers beats being transactional
  • (56:44) Collective's financial backing and long-term capital structure
  • (58:31)) Buying three shops in nine months: challenges and lessons
  • (59:33) Is the industry moving away from traditional PE models?

Connect with Mark Hillenburg

Connect With Machine Shop Mastery

Subscribe to Machine Shop Mastery on

AppleSpotify


Audio Production and Show Notes by - PODCAST FAST TRACK


Paul Van Metre hosts Machine Shop Mastery, a conversation grounded in the real-world challenges and triumphs of running a precision manufacturing business. This isn't about abstract theory; it's a deep dive into the shop floor, focusing on the practical strategies that turn a technical skill into a sustainable and growing enterprise. Each episode pulls back the curtain on the operational, financial, and personal leadership aspects that define a successful shop, moving beyond the blueprints to talk about building a resilient business. You'll hear candid discussions about navigating client relationships, managing cash flow, investing in the right equipment, and developing a team that can execute complex work. The podcast aims to underscore the critical role these businesses play as community anchors and economic engines, often overlooked in broader industry talks. For current shop owners, the insights offer a path to refine their operations and boost profitability. For aspiring entrepreneurs with a passion for machining, these conversations provide a clear-eyed look at what it truly takes to launch and scale. Tune in for straightforward advice and stories that connect the craft of machining with the art of building a lasting legacy.
Author: Language: en-us Episodes: 100

Machine Shop Mastery
Podcast Episodes
113. Inside a Defense Shop's Lights-Out Automation Build [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:06:05
What do you do when your entire business model collapses almost overnight? For Sven Klatt and the team at Vineburg Machining, the answer wasn't to retreat—it was to reinvent. After losing their three largest customers to…
104. Beyond Tool & Die: How Overton Industries Evolved and Thrives [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:12:27
What does it take to grow a third-generation family machine shop into a diversified, nearly 100-person operation pushing $20 million in revenue? In this episode of Machine Shop Mastery, I sit down with Zac Overton of Ove…