Real Historians vs Pop Historians, A Roundtable Discussion -- JFT Ep 18

Real Historians vs Pop Historians, A Roundtable Discussion -- JFT Ep 18

Author: Michael September 8, 2025 Duration: 2:04:28

This is a roundtable discussion between REAL HISTORIANS David Parnell and John D Hosler and POP HISTORIANS myself and Andrew of Shadows over Constantinople.

You may have seen some online tension between pop historians/enthusiasts and "real" historians. I have experienced a bit of that myself (see previous episode).

Why is there this tension? Don't we have common ground? How can we all work together better? We discuss "What is an historian?" and "Is history an art or science?" What does an historian's training look like? How do we spend our time? Why are many non-professional historians anonymous? and more!

You can follow David Parnell on substack here

You can pick up his excellent book here

You can follow John D Hosler on X here

You can pick up his excellent book on the Siege of Acre here

You can follow Andrew on X here

And lastly, you can follow everything related to my Memory Medieval project at the substack

Look for new episodes on the 3rd and 17th of each month. I have a few great episodes lined up for the near future you won't want to miss. The next episode is on medieval literature and its effect on the medieval mind. Then an episode on war horses. And a couple more big episodes in the works!



Get full access to Memory Medieval at memorymedieval.substack.com/subscribe

Michael hosts Memory Medieval Podcast, a series of thoughtful conversations that dig into how people lived, thought, and organized their worlds a thousand years ago. Rather than just listing dates and battles, this podcast explores the textures of daily life, the evolution of cultural ideas, and the complex structures of society that defined the medieval period. Each episode features a different historian or expert, leading to organic discussions that can jump from analyzing a single manuscript to debating broad social transformations across centuries. You’ll hear about the stories we tell ourselves about the past and how our modern memory of the Middle Ages is constantly being reshaped. The tone is more like a deep dive with curious friends than a formal lecture, making the distant past feel surprisingly immediate and relevant. For anyone with an interest in the roots of our contemporary world, this podcast offers a nuanced and engaging doorway into a fascinating era. Find more from Michael and his guests through the Substack linked to the show.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 35

Memory Medieval Podcast
Podcast Episodes
The best medieval history essays on THE WHOLE INTERNET [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 11:40
For all subscribers of the Memory Medieval Podcast..Made this video to tell you about an exciting project I have been cooking up.If you like medieval history, you are going to want to take a look. Check out the publicati…
The Life, Death, and Lore of Old English w/Wylfcen -- Ep30 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 47:12
Wylfcen joins me to give us an education on the life, death, and lore of the Old Enligsh language. Funnily enough, I did not know that Tolkien was a professor of Old English! I’m always doing so much on the Normans.. it’…
Richard the Lionheart part 4 w/ James Naus -- Ep29 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:28:21
Dr. James Naus joins me to discuss the complicated relationship between the Angevins (Richard the Lionheart) and the Capetians (Philip Augustus, one of Richard’s great rivals). Was Philip just insecure? Was he a bad crus…
Richard the Lionheart part 3 w/ The Bazaar of War -- Ep28 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:20:07
Ben of The Bazaar of War joins me to take a deep dive into the life and military career of Saladin. I really wanted to understand why he is regarded as such a great commander while his results in the third crusade, despi…
Richard the Lionheart part 2 w/ J Stephen Roberts -- Ep27 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 56:04
J Stephen Roberts of Real Crusades History joins me to discuss Richard the Lionheart and what some of the hostile sources have to say about him. As J Stephen is one of the top history creators online, we also discuss his…
Richard the Lionheart Part 1 w/ John Gillingham -- MMP Ep26 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:20:04
This is the first in a six part series on Richard the Lionheart and what a way to kick it off than with the world’s top scholar! John Gillingham has written the seminal biography on Richard and is widely regarded as the…
Make Your Holiday Feast more Medieval! w/ Andrew Mitchell -- MMP Ep25 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:34:11
Andrew Mitchell is a history professor at Grove City College, a small liberal arts college in western PA where he teaches a recurring and popular history class on “Food and Feasting”. Grove City is one of only a handful…