Joseph Smith’s Polygamy with Jeremy Hoop

Joseph Smith’s Polygamy with Jeremy Hoop

Author: Mormon Discussion Inc July 3, 2026 Duration: 3:05:16

For decades, the historical consensus has been that Joseph Smith introduced and practiced plural marriage in Nauvoo. But a small group of researchers has argued for a very different conclusion: that Joseph Smith was not the founder of Mormon polygamy and that the historical evidence has been misunderstood. In this episode of Mormonism Live, we sit down with researcher Jeremy Hoop to explore that perspective in depth. Jeremy has spent years examining William Clayton’s journals, the Nauvoo land deeds, the Augusta Cobb letters, the British Mission, and many other historical sources. He explains why he believes the standard narrative deserves to be reconsidered and walks us through the evidence that has led him to his conclusions. Whether you agree with Jeremy or not, this conversation is an opportunity to hear one of the leading voices of the Joseph Smith “non-polygamist” position explain his research in his own words.

Our goal is to better understand the arguments, the historical documents, and the reasoning behind this alternative interpretation of early Mormon history. As always, we invite you to examine the evidence, think critically, and reach your own conclusions.

Support Mormonism Live: https://donorbox.org/mormonism-live

Visit Mormon Discussions: https://mormondiscussions.org

If you enjoy thoughtful conversations on Mormon history, doctrine, and culture, please like, subscribe, and share the episode.


There's a conversation happening about the Latter-day Saint experience from a perspective you might not find in a Sunday school manual. Mormonism Live!-Radio Free Mormon, from Mormon Discussion Inc, operates like a weekly dispatch from within a complex faith tradition, examining its history, doctrines, and cultural impact with a critical yet often personal eye. Each episode feels like a deep dive into the topics that members and former members grapple with, from historical analysis to current events within the community. The hosts and their guests bring a blend of scholarly research and lived experience to the table, creating discussions that are as informative as they are provocative. Tuning into this podcast means hearing unfiltered dialogue about the realities and challenges of Mormonism, presented by those who know it intimately. It’s for anyone who wants to look beyond the surface, whether they are questioning, believing, or simply curious about one of the most distinctive American religious movements. The tone is direct and the content is unflinching, making it a unique voice in the spheres of religion and spirituality.
Author: Language: en-us Episodes: 50

Mormonism Live! – Radio Free Mormon
Podcast Episodes
Heresy Hunters On Planet Provo! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:54:11
Elder Bruce R. McConkie gave one of his most famous talks in history in 1980 named “The Seven Deadly Heresies.” RFM and Bill Reel break down this talk, exposing not only what Elder McConkie says, but why he says it; toge…
How Did Joseph Smith Know All This? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:01:20
Tonight on Mormonism Live, we examine a recurring pattern in Joseph Smith’s prophetic career: when he encountered something mysterious, incomplete, inaccessible, or simply unknown, he rarely seemed content to say, “I don…
Native American Legends in BOM! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:32:37
RFM and Bill Reel are joined by Dr. Thomas Murphy to discuss what the presence of Native American myths, individuals, and stories in the Book of Mormon means. Are these evidence the Book of Mormon is true? Or do they giv…
Mormonism’s Zelph – The White Lamanite [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:22:32
In June 1834, while marching with Zion’s Camp through Illinois, Joseph Smith and his followers came across an ancient Native American burial mound. Members of the group dug into the mound and uncovered a human skeleton—w…
Find Out What REALLY Happened At Sunstone 2026! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:31:01
RFM and Bill Reel host an august panel of Sunstone Symposium presenters and attendees, as they tell us fun and fascinating stories about what goes on behind the scenes of Sunstone! Join us! Mormon Studies were never so m…
Zion’s Camp: Turning Failure Into Faith [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 3:00:57
What if one of the most important events in early Mormon history never actually accomplished what it set out to do? In 1834, Joseph Smith organized nearly 200 armed men and led them almost 900 miles across the American f…
Mormon Endowment’s Earliest Historical Form ! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:54:47
What did the Nauvoo Temple endowment look like in its earliest form? In this episode of Mormonism Live, Bill Reel and Radio Free Mormon examine one of the earliest published firsthand accounts of the Nauvoo Temple ceremo…
Black Mormons Speak Out! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:35:57
RFM and Bill Reel are joined by a special panel of Black Mormons and ex-Mormons in this important episode. What is it like experiencing Mormonism through the lens of race? Especially when that race paints you as a second…
Obviously a 19th Century Production! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:46:02
We have shown in a prior podcast that the Book of Mormon answers all the important religious disputes of Joseph Smith’s day. In this episode we demonstrate that the Book of Mormon uses the language and expressions of oth…
The William Clayton Journals – What’s In Them? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:41:22
Tonight on Mormonism Live, Bill Reel and Radio Free Mormon take a deep dive into one of the most talked-about Mormon history stories in recent memory: the recent leaking of the William Clayton journals. For years, the fu…