Harnessing Superfans for Podcast Success #622

Harnessing Superfans for Podcast Success #622

Author: Rob Greenlee March 20, 2025 Duration: 0:00

In this episode titled “Harnessing Superfans for Podcast Success,” hosts Todd Cochrane and Rob Greenlee engage in a lively discussion covering various podcasting topics. The episode opens with Todd humorously admitting he overslept, leading to their usual banter about their long-standing podcasting journey.

Rob introduces the idea of podcast superfans, referencing an article that illustrates how heavy podcast listeners, who listen for over eight hours per week, are significantly more engaged with advertised products. They mention statistics about superfans and their purchasing behavior, highlighting the effectiveness of podcast ads on these dedicated listeners.

The conversation then shifts to the state of podcast advertising, with Rob noting recent drops in CPMs (cost per thousand impressions) shared by an acquaintance in the industry. Todd and Rob discuss the reliance on programmatic versus dynamically inserted ads, with Todd expressing skepticism regarding the effectiveness and transparency of current advertising methods.

As they explore the concept of superfans further, Todd mentions the importance of listener engagement and how podcasters can build relationships with their audiences. The hosts reflect on how personal donations from fans can often be a better indicator of superfans than mere listenership.

Rob emphasizes the need for a diversified revenue strategy for podcasters, advocating for creators to explore avenues like merchandise and direct fan contributions rather than just relying on big-name advertisers.

The episode progresses into discussing the impact of AI on podcasting, with Rob highlighting a case where a guest managed to increase downloads simply by changing the publication date of an old episode, effectively marketing it as a new release. They delve into the ethics of such practices and the potential repercussions for podcast creators who use similar tactics.

Todd offers insights into the challenges of maintaining a podcast’s audio quality and how technology sometimes complicates the process, referencing his recent technical issues with OBS. They acknowledge the importance of understanding audience engagement metrics and how the industry evolves with new tools and platforms.

Towards the end of the episode, Todd and Rob reflect on the changing media consumption landscape, including the rise of YouTube as a primary device for audiences. They reiterate the importance of building one’s brand through direct engagement channels like websites and email newsletters while also discussing how AI and technology can further assist in understanding audience behavior and improving content strategy.

The episode closes with Todd sharing thoughts on leveraging AI tools for enhancing podcast content and project management. Both hosts express optimism about the future of podcasting and the continuous need to adapt strategies in response to evolving technologies and audience expectations. They bid farewell, with Todd promising to improve technical aspects for the next broadcast.

The post Harnessing Superfans for Podcast Success #622 first appeared on New Media Show.


Hosted by veteran voice Rob Greenlee, New Media Show (Video) offers a grounded, weekly conversation about the realities of building an audience and a business in today's digital landscape. Each episode features a different guest co-host, bringing fresh perspectives from the trenches of content creation, marketing, and entrepreneurship. The discussions move beyond theory, focusing on practical strategies and the evolving tools that shape how we connect and communicate. You'll hear honest reflections on what works, what doesn't, and where the opportunities lie in the constantly shifting worlds of podcasting and online video. This isn't about hype; it's a clear-eyed look at the craft and commerce of new media, informed by Rob's long history in the space and the direct experiences of his weekly collaborators. Tune in for a straightforward exchange of ideas that feels more like a focused workshop than a broadcast, designed for anyone serious about understanding and navigating the business side of digital content.
Author: Language: en-us Episodes: 100

New Media Show (Video)
Podcast Episodes
Podcasting’s Multi-Format Future | Sharon Taylor #659 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 0:00
Podcasting is entering a new phase, and this episode goes straight into the infrastructure, business models, and platform shifts shaping what comes next. On episode 659 of The New Media Show, Host and Podcast Hall of Fam…
Local Podcasts in a Growing Video World | David Plotz #658 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 0:00
If you are trying to understand where podcasting may still have real, untapped opportunities in 2026 and beyond, this is one of those conversations that point to an important answer: Local. On Episode 658 of The New Medi…
Can Apple Make Video Podcasts Matter? | Jay Nachlis #656 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 0:00
In episode 656 of the New Media Show, Podcast Hall of Famer Rob Greenlee is joined by Jay Nachlis, Media Research VP at Coleman Insights. “It’s a timely and deeper conversation about Apple Podcasts moving more aggressive…
Podcast Growth and Discovery in 2026 | Arielle Nissenblatt #655 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 0:00
Podcast discovery feels harder in 2026, not because creators stopped trying, but because attention is now split across podcast apps, YouTube, short-form video feeds, newsletters, and search-driven recommendations. On thi…
Building a Very Human Media Business | Erin Diehl #654 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 0:00
As AI becomes more embedded into content creation, discovery, and distribution, one truth is becoming clearer: the long-term winners in media may not be the fastest or the most automated. They may be the most human. That…
Can Fiction Story Podcasts Survive Video Push | Lauren Shippen #652 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 0:00
New Media Show #652 with Rob Greenlee and Lauren Shippen On Episode 652 of the New Media Show, host Rob Greenlee shares a screen with Lauren Shippen, Creative Director at Atypical Artists, to tackle a growing tension in…
Apple’s New Video Podcast Deep Dive | James Cridland #651 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 0:00
On Weds, February 18th Live Episode #651 of the New Media Show, Rob Greenlee, Host, 2017 Podcast Hall of Famer and CEO of Trust Factor Lab at https://RobGreenlee.com, and James Cridland, Editor, https://Podnews.net and 2…
How AI-Created Podcasts Impacting Humans? | Jeanine Wright #650 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 0:00
AI-generated podcast hosts and shows are rapidly changing podcasting, video podcasting, and the creator economy across all distribution platforms, including AI LLMs. In this episode of The New Media Show Live #650 from F…
What Actually Grows a Podcast or Show Now? | Jordan Harbinger #649 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 0:00
This week in episode 649 of the New Media Show, Rob Greenlee is joined by Jordan Harbinger to unpack the question creators ask nonstop in 2026: What actually grows a podcast or show (and what doesn’t)? – Jordan’s core an…