Cringe: Why Sincerity Still Matters at the TTRPG Gaming Table

Cringe: Why Sincerity Still Matters at the TTRPG Gaming Table

Author: Josh Varty and Kristoffer Hansen October 24, 2025 Duration: 37:03

Let’s talk about being cringe! 

  • Pretend play is an essential part of growing up and learning social roles and shit.
  • This goes back to Piaget and Vygotsky - pretending is how we experiment and try on identities and learn empathy and problem-solving. 
  • Adults often repress that because it’s fucking cringe as hell.
  • Sitting down to play a role-playing game reactivates that early developmental muscle, but it’s occasionally awkward and weird.
  • Kids: The floor is lava! 
  • Adults: If I do enough pretend violence I might be able to afford pretend real estate! 

Irony is the Armor of Sincerity


  • Memes, quotes, and in-jokes make the table feel safe — a shared cultural shorthand.
  • Emotional detachment also feels safe. Not caring about fake people is cooler than caring about fake people, and we usually want to be cool.
  • But irony can also block emotional engagement. If everyone’s half-laughing through their character arcs, no one has to risk being sincere.


The Cringe Frontier


  • Why do we generally cringe at sincerity? 
  • Is cringe just a way of enforcing emotional conformity? 
  • Can being cringy be brave, or is it always the absolute worst? 
  • We both come from improv backgrounds where being cringe is kind of a necessity. Has that better prepared us for cringe at our tables? 


Circle of Safety


  • I was reading a post recently from someone who was wondering if maybe we’d gone a bit too far on making game tables a safe space. I’m pretty sure I disagree with that person, but I will agree that the tools we have aren’t ideal and probably never will be.
  • What are your personal safety mechanisms? 
  • How do you invite people to be sincere without forcing them to “act” at the table? 
  • What is the DM’s role in creating an emotional stable space for Big Feelings? 
  • Huizinga’s Magic Circle suggests that normal rules, even rules about social conformity, are suspended during play. Does that work if the real space (outside of the liminal shared imagined space of play) is not safe? 
  • How can we support emotional safety in service to enabling bravery?



In No Plot, Only Lore, hosts Josh Varty and Kristoffer Hansen settle in for a conversation that feels like pulling up a chair at a familiar table. Their focus is the intricate, often messy, and deeply rewarding world of collaborative storytelling games, examining them not as rulebooks to be won but as frameworks for shared imagination. Each episode digs into the craft behind these experiences-how a setting’s history shapes a character’s decision, why a particular game mechanic fosters better stories, or what it means to build a narrative together without a predetermined endpoint. You’ll hear two seasoned practitioners reflect on the subtle art of being a player and a guide, discussing the tools and philosophies that transform a simple game night into a memorable saga. This podcast is for anyone who has ever gotten lost in a character’s backstory or spent more time discussing a campaign’s lore than actually rolling dice. It’s a thoughtful, meandering, and personal look at the stories we tell when we play, offering insights that resonate long after the session ends. Join Josh and Kristoffer for a deep, comfortable dive into the heart of why we gather to imagine together.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 93

No Plot, Only Lore
Podcast Episodes
Too Much Lore: Sumo Part 1 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 51:07
Join Josh and Kris on No Plot, Only Lore as they dive into the surprising world of professional Sumo—a sport Josh argues is the "purest representation" of physical will. This episode explores how Sumo transcends being a…
AI Re-revisited: Gray Ooze and the Enshittification of the Tabletop [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 36:45
In this episode of No Plot, Only Lore, Josh and Kris dive deep into the "gray ooze" currently flooding the internet: Generative AI. What started as a potential tool for busy DMs has quickly spiraled into a self-fulfillin…
AI Revisited: The Turd in the Digital Pool [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 43:55
The Honeymoon Phase is Over.This week, Josh and Kris revisit their stance on Generative AI. While early adoption promised a reduction in cognitive load for DMs, the reality has shifted toward a "net negative" across near…
The Walled Garden - The Open Gaming License, History and Future [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 48:19
We're back! We're doing audio and video now like a couple-a lunatics! We're doing a deep dive on the open gaming license and its impact on the entire tabletop RPG world, and we're blaming it on Kevin Siembieda! Not reall…
December Sads [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 29:52
Look, December low-key sucks when it comes to a lot of things, and gaming is no different. But it doesn't have to suck completely! Come hang out with us and we'll talk about it.
Best TTRPG Holiday Gift Guide 2023 | Lancer, Daggerheart & Dice! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 52:32
Josh and Chris for their second annual Holiday Gift Guide dedicated to the coolest tabletop role-playing games (TTRPGs) and accessories for 2023.Hear their takes on the year's biggest releases and hottest picks, includin…
Attention Economy and TTRPGs: Are We Krill in the Critical Role Pond? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 35:01
Hosts Josh and Kris tackle the Attention Economy and its uncomfortable role in the TTRPG space. From recognizing their place as "krill" in the same ecosystem as giants like Critical Role to debating whether the attention…