Monsanto v. Durnell: Federal Preemption, Roundup, and the Future of Pesticide Liability

Monsanto v. Durnell: Federal Preemption, Roundup, and the Future of Pesticide Liability

Author: Environmental Law Institute March 25, 2026 Duration: 1:03:14

Can states hold pesticide companies accountable — or does federal law preempt? In this episode of People, Places, Planet, host Sebastian Duque Rios sits down with Patti Goldman, Senior Attorney at Earthjustice, and Cecilia Diedrich, Staff Attorney at ELI, to unpack one of the most consequential environmental law cases of the Supreme Court's current session: Monsanto v. Darnell.

 

At its core, this case asks whether federal pesticide law — the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA) — preempts state-based failure-to-warn claims, potentially shielding pesticide manufacturers like Monsanto from liability for harms caused by products like Roundup (glyphosate). With oral arguments scheduled for April 27, 2026, the stakes couldn't be higher — not just for pesticide litigation, but for the future of toxics accountability across the board.

 

We break down the science behind pesticide risks, the role of tort litigation in driving corporate accountability and regulatory reform, and why the Court's ruling could have far-reaching implications for PFAS litigation, microplastics liability, and chemical safety regulation more broadly. We also explore how recent Supreme Court decisions, including Loper Bright, are reshaping the landscape of federal agency deference and what that means for environmental and public health protections.

 

If you're interested in learning about toxics litigation more broadly, ELI’s Toxics Litigation Project recently published a landscape analysis of toxics litigation and how scientific advancement and uncertainty, state and federal law, and judicial doctrine intersect in the ongoing effort to address the risks and consequences of toxic exposures in the United States and abroad titled, "Current Trends in Toxics Litigation." Additionally, for more information on FIFRA, check out our FIFRA, Explained episode. 

  • Introduction: Pesticides & FIFRA (3:17)
  • Role of Tort Litigation in Accountability (13:44)
  • The Roundup Litigation: Failure to Warn, Glyphosate, and the Road to the Supreme Court (19:07)
  • Monsanto v. Durnell: Preemption and the Circuit Split (25:13)
  • Beyond Roundup: Implications for the Future of Toxics Litigation (40:15)
  • Concluding Thoughts: Science, Oral Arguments, and How to Protect Communities Going Forward (48:55)
★ Support this podcast ★

Produced by the Environmental Law Institute, People Places Planet is a conversation grounded in the practical realities of environmental stewardship. This podcast moves beyond abstract theory to explore how laws, policies, and innovative governance models are actively applied. Each episode features discussions with practitioners, scientists, legal experts, and community leaders who are directly engaged in crafting and implementing solutions. You’ll hear nuanced analysis on the intersection of business, regulation, and education, focusing on tangible outcomes rather than just identifying problems. The dialogue consistently centers on how complex frameworks operate in the real world, affecting specific communities, ecosystems, and industries. Listening provides a deeper understanding of the mechanisms that drive environmental progress and the challenges that arise at the intersection of human activity and planetary health. It’s an essential resource for anyone curious about the foundational rules and creative strategies shaping our relationship with the environment, offering clarity on the legal and policy threads woven through every environmental issue. Tune in for thoughtful, expert-driven perspectives that connect the dots between policy texts and their impact on the ground.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

People Places Planet
Podcast Episodes
Honoring Mud Lake This Earth Day [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 19:10
Mud Lake, written and illustrated by 2020 National Wetlands Award winner Sam Lovall, is a collection of short adventure stories set in the 1960s and 70s about children freely exploring the natural world in Haslett, Michi…
NEPA, Explained [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 24:24
When airports, buildings, highways, dams, power plants, and other federal activities are proposed, the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) requirements are invoked. Passed by Congress in 1969 and signed into law on…
Diplomacy Required: Women, Water, and Peace [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 21:14
The theme of this year’s World Water Day is “Water for Peace”. With over 2 billion people around the world lacking clean water access, tensions can arise within communities and between countries. Further complicating the…
Unleash the Green: Legal and Policy Solutions for Green Startups [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 24:43
Green startups are imagining solutions to the climate crisis and leading the transition to a sustainable economy. Yet sustainable entrepreneurship remains incredibly daunting given market challenges, long pathways to com…
How Can Business Help Solve the Freshwater Crisis? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 36:39
Billions of people around the globe lack adequate access to clean water. This freshwater crisis will be exacerbated by climate change. Liquid Asset: How Business and Government Can Partner to Solve the Freshwater Crisis…
Cumulative Impact Analysis: Massachusetts, EPA, and Beyond [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 35:19
Communities are exposed to pollution through the air, water, and land. Multiple sources of pollution and other environmental stressors can add up over time to cause adverse effects to human health and wellbeing. This is…
Swamps, Science, and Sackett: ELI's Approach to Wetland Preservation [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 19:51
What do Wetlands have to do with wellbeing? As vibrant and critical ecosystems, wetlands provide economic, cultural, and climate benefits to communities worldwide. Yet, wetlands are disappearing at an alarming rate. ELI’…
From Dubai with Dedication: Navigating COP28 Climate Commitments [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 28:36
A lot has been said about COP28. It has been described as a success, failure, and everything in between, but what actually happened? This week, host Sarah Backer is joined by Jennifer Huang, Associate Director of Interna…