The Cost of Convenience: Understanding the Financial Landscape of Selling on Amazon and Chewy

The Cost of Convenience: Understanding the Financial Landscape of Selling on Amazon and Chewy

Author: Clayton Payne January 30, 2025 Duration: 1:04:47
In this episode of Pet Business Disruptors, Clayton engages in a deep conversation with Mike, the Director of Business Development and Operations at Brands Best Friend, an e-commerce agency specializing in the pet industry. They explore the complexities of navigating the ever-evolving e-commerce landscape, particularly on platforms like Amazon, Chewy, and Walmart. Mike shares insights on the challenges pet brands face in establishing a direct-to-consumer presence, the importance of developing a comprehensive e-commerce strategy, and the impact of rising customer acquisition costs. The discussion also highlights the significance of understanding consumer behaviour, the role of trust in online purchasing, and the necessity of adapting to changes brought about by AI and shifting market dynamics. With a focus on integrity and partnership, Mike emphasizes how Brands Best Friend helps brands thrive in a competitive environment while maintaining a commitment to the well-being of pets. KEY TAKEAWAYS E-commerce Strategy is Essential: Brands need a comprehensive e-commerce strategy that encompasses various platforms like Amazon, Chewy, and Walmart, rather than focusing solely on one.  Trust and Convenience Drive Sales: Consumers often prefer established platforms like Amazon due to their trustworthiness and convenience, making it challenging for direct-to-consumer (DTC) brands to gain traction.  Cost of Customer Acquisition is Rising: The cost of acquiring customers through digital marketing is increasing, with some brands spending significant amounts per customer. Adaptability to Market Changes is Key: The e-commerce landscape is constantly evolving, influenced by factors like AI and changing consumer behaviours.  BEST MOMENTS "There's a big difference between being on Amazon and having an Amazon strategy." - Mike  "You have to understand the pet industry and its history before applying any type of e-commerce knowledge." - Mike  "If you're not where your customers are, you're going to get left behind." - Clayton "It’s rare for us to enter into retainer model contracts with our brands." - Mike  HOST BIO Clayton Payne is an industry veteran of three decades of working in the pet industry. Brought up working in his parents' pet store, Clayton has seen the industry evolve over five different decades and has been on the cutting edge of the industry since the nineties. Building pet businesses from scratch, establishing multi-national distribution chains and having worked in every aspect of the industry, Clayton has a rare insight into the Pet Industry that is rivalled by few.  Clayton has been the spearhead of many of the industry's changes and has introduced numerous new concepts to market with a trail of success behind him. He has worked in numerous countries within the pet industry, speaks four different languages and has established both import and export relationships on all continents (excluding Antarctica). As well as being COO of one of the UKs fastest growing insect technology companies, Clayton is a Pet industry consultant who has consulted for many household brands and delivers sales training to pet trade professionals. https://www.linkedin.com/in/clayton-payne-a6772244/ https://www.tiktok.com/@petbusinessdisruptors https://www.youtube.com/@PetBusinessDisruptors  

Clayton Payne hosts Pet Business Disruptors, a podcast that digs into the real, working mechanics of the world of pets. This isn't just theoretical business talk; it's a direct line to the strategies and personal stories of people who have actually built their careers in this vibrant field. Each conversation is designed to pull back the curtain, offering an honest look at what it takes to navigate the pet industry, from launching a small grooming service or a new pet product to securing a key role within a major corporation. The discussions are grounded in practical experience, explaining not only how things should be done but how Clayton's guests have done them themselves. The scope is intentionally broad, making the podcast equally valuable for someone just considering their first job with animals or a seasoned executive leading a large team. By focusing on actionable insights and lived experiences, this series serves as a unique resource for anyone passionate about turning their love for pets into a sustainable profession. You'll hear specific advice on operational challenges, marketing to pet owners, and understanding the nuances that make this industry so unique. Tune in for a candid exploration of the business behind our furry, feathered, and scaled companions.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Pet Business Disruptors
Podcast Episodes
Jessica Fisher on Fresh Food, HPP and Becoming Your Pet's Health CEO [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:08:05
What if the person you trust most with your pet's health knows the least about what's on their plate? Jessica Fisher, host of The Pet Parenting Reset, joins Clayton to challenge the comfortable assumptions baked into the…
From Conventional Vet to Holistic Rebel with Dr Andrew Jones [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:17:46
When the traditional system tries to box you in, sometimes the only option is to forge your own path. This conversation dives deep into what happens behind the closed doors of modern veterinary clinics, exploring the int…
From Traditional Cook Island Roots to Modern Joint Mobility Support [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:12:17
When a traditional remedy defies standard pharmaceutical paradigms, it turns heads—and when it works wonders on pets, it changes lives forever. We sit down to explore the incredible journey of a transdermal extract deriv…
Why "Human Grade" is the Most Meaningless Claim in Pet Food [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:04:52
Ever wondered why every bag of cat litter now says "senior" or why "human grade" meat is often just industrial hamburger? Jordan Tyler joins the show to strip away the glossy marketing and get real about the science of p…
From Insurance Agent to Freeze-Drying Innovator with Ashton Hood [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:00:41
It isn’t every day you meet an insurance agent who decides to trade the office for a goat farm, only to end up building his own freeze-drying machinery from the ground up. Ashton Hood of Shepherd Boy Farms joins the show…
QuailOS: How One Entrepreneur is Automating the Poultry Industry [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:02:33
In this episode, Clayton sits down with Christian Greninger, the founder of Undique.us and QuailOS.com. Christian shares his fascinating transition from working as an IT engineer in Ireland to building a nationwide netwo…
Disrupting the Small Pet Market with HayPigs! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:14:45
In this episode, Clayton sits down with Rik Cridland, the founder of HayPigs!. Rik shares his journey from studying industrial design and creating film merchandise to revolutionizing the small pet market. After rescuing…
From Medicine to Marketplaces: The Jo Proud Story [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 43:03
Today, Clayton is joined by Jo Proud, the visionary founder of PetAttics. Jo shares her remarkable journey from a career in medicine to becoming an award-winning entrepreneur. She discusses the inspiration behind her fir…