2031 - BONUS: Temptation Island (s2e1) "Temptation's Knocking" with Keisha

2031 - BONUS: Temptation Island (s2e1) "Temptation's Knocking" with Keisha

Author: Pink Shade April 13, 2026 Duration: 55:23
Mary Payne and Keisha discuss the glorious return of our King, Mark L. Walberg, and Netflix's Temptation Island. All 9 episodes are now on Pink Shade Prime ($10/month level). On this episode, we meet "Jack with the hair" (and no job) and Shyanne, who is very young and super co-dependent. We also meet Summit (not to be confused with Sumit) and "Kaylee with the eyes". He's outgoing and she's introverted; they've been together for 1 year. Then there are Mikey and Sydney. She's a gorgeous aesthetician and he's a goofy former F-boy. Finally we meet Cole and Scarlett. She's a gorgeous business lady and he's a little bit of a liar.

Watch this episode on YouTube: https://youtu.be/6e08BMswCiA 

Support our sponsor:

Warby Parker: Warby Parker was founded with a mission: to inspire and impact the world with vision, purpose, and style. Our listeners get 15% off plus free shipping when they buy two or more pairs of prescription glasses at WarbyParker.com/PINKSHADE — using our link helps support the show. #WarbyParker

Want more Pink Shade?

Ever find yourself yelling at the TV during a particularly outrageous episode of a reality show? You’re not alone. Pink Shade: Reality TV with MP is that conversation, hosted by Mary Payne Gilbert, who dives deep into the shows that dominate our watercooler talk. This isn't just a summary of what happened; it's a sharp, funny, and often cathartic breakdown of the drama, the decisions, and the sheer audacity we witness on screen. Mary Payne brings her unique perspective to each recap, joined by a rotating cast of co-hosts who add their own flavor to the discussion. New episodes drop three times a week, keeping pace with the relentless flow of content from franchises like WeTV's Love After Lockup universe and TLC's sprawling 90 Day Fiancé saga. Tuning into this podcast feels like grabbing a drink with friends who are just as invested in the absurdity and occasional heart of modern reality television. You'll get analysis, plenty of laughs, and the satisfying sense that someone is articulating exactly what you were thinking from your couch. For anyone who loves to dissect the intricate, messy lives played out on these shows, Pink Shade offers the perfect weekly companion.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Pink Shade: Reality TV with MP
Podcast Episodes
2035 - Ladies of London (s4 eps 7-8) with Keisha [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:24:00
Mary Payne is back from vacation and ready to dive into Monarch Monday with a double recap! On Ladies of London (s4e7) "Horsing Around", Myka has a birthday party at the polo fields and Mark-Francis and Margo continue to…
2034 - Pop and Bravo with Ace Fanning [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:27:38
Mary Payne talks with Ace Fanning about the latest in our Bravo and TLC worlds. We discuss the new seasons of RHOA, RHRI and our love for RHOBH, no matter how bad it is. We also chat about the cancellation of RHOM - a tr…
2033 - Welcome to Plathville (s8e3) "Fish or Cut Bait" with Kimberly [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 57:33
Mary Payne has returned from her travels and ready to chat with Kimberly about Welcome to Plathville (s8e3) "Fish or Cut Bait". On this episode we are forced to watch Barry chat about dating with his kids, his ex-wife, h…
2030 - INTERVIEW with Elise Benson of Before the 90 Days [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 37:32
Mary Payne chats with Elise Benson of Before the 90 Days (and Hunt for Love). Elise tells MP all about her travels to Australia to hang out with Joshua. We talk about Joshua's confusing finances and living situation and…