Amateurs Aren't Bad Putters. They're Bad From 150.

Amateurs Aren't Bad Putters. They're Bad From 150.

Author: Isaak Ramsey & Hayden Zimmerer | Smarter Golf Practice in Less Time May 22, 2026 Duration: 49:49

Try the Play Ready Golf app free for 7 days. Use code PRGPOD at checkout for $20 off your annual plan for life: https://onelink.to/93ggkv

Grab the free stat tracker and proximity benchmarks PDF mentioned in the episode: https://onelink.to/stats

Most amateurs spend 30 minutes on the practice green before every round. They hit 5 greens out of 18 and lose 40 yards of proximity from 150. You're not a bad putter. You're bad from 150.

Mark Broadie analyzed the top 40 PGA Tour pros from 2004 to 2012 and found putting is 15% of the gap between elite and average pros. Approach play is 40%. A scratch golfer beats a Tour pro on the greens in more than 30% of rounds. The data has been public for 12 years. In this episode Isaak and Hayden break down where your strokes actually leak, why Bobby Locke, Harvey Penick, and Dave Pelz built the putting myth, and what to practice instead.

📊 Data sources cited in this episode:

Mark Broadie, Every Shot Counts (Columbia University, top 40 PGA Tour pros 2004-2012)

Shot Scope (350M+ shots)

Arccos via Lou Stagner (1B+ shots)

Dave Pelz, Short Game Bible (2000)

Harvey Penick, Little Red Book (1992)

Chapters:

00:00 Why you're not actually a bad putter

00:53 The Broadie data nobody talks about

02:20 The Play Ready Golf app

02:42 Putts per round vs greens hit

04:57 The 150 yard truth (54 feet vs 122 feet)

09:00 How to practice when nothing feels like progress

15:00 The myth: Bobby Locke and "drive for show putt for dough"

20:56 The myth: Harvey Penick's Little Red Book

27:57 The myth: Dave Pelz and the 80% lie

29:26 Where putting actually matters (the steel-man)

32:33 How to raise your floor with approach play

40:00 Random practice and why blocked practice fails

44:42 "But I 3 putt all the time" (the data on lag putts)

48:19 What to take from this conversation


There's a common frustration that settles in when you love golf but feel stuck, watching your scores plateau despite your effort. Play Ready Golf is built on a simple, powerful idea: real improvement doesn't require endless hours or expensive gear you might not have. Instead, this podcast digs into practical, actionable strategies that fit into a regular life. You'll hear straightforward conversations about smarter practice, mental approaches that actually work on the course, and how to make the most of your existing game. The focus is always on tangible takeaways-the kind you can try during your next range session or round. It’s for anyone tired of generic advice and ready for a clearer path to lower scores. Each episode feels like a focused chat with a knowledgeable friend who cuts through the noise, all dedicated to helping you play better with what you've already got. Tune in and start transforming the time and resources you already invest into noticeable, satisfying progress on the fairway.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 24

Play Ready Golf | Strokes Gained for the 9 to 5 Golfer
Podcast Episodes
5 Free Fixes That Drop More Strokes Than a New Swing [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 39:17
Most golfers leave the course convinced their swing cost them strokes. But the 5 biggest mistakes amateur golfers make have nothing to do with their swing. They're decision-based. And they're free to fix. In this episode…
The Real Reason You Can't Break 90 (Ep. 10) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 30:28
A 20 handicap makes 6.6 doubles per round. A scratch golfer? 0.25. That's 12 shots of difference in big numbers alone. In this episode, we break down what actually separates each handicap level using real scoring data. N…
He Won the State Am by 21 Shots ft Christian Brand [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 35:28
He won the West Virginia Amateur by 21 shots at 22-under par. He's also a State Farm insurance agent, a husband, and a dad who practices 30 minutes a day in his garage simulator. Christian Brand is proof that you don't n…
The Golf Stats Everyone Tracks That Don't Actually Work [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 47:36
Most golf stats are lying to you. We break down every major stat category in golf, which ones actually help you score better, which ones are just noise, and the 4 simple stats you can track on your scorecard starting thi…
A PGA Pro Says Your Swing Isn't the Problem...Your Brain Is [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 47:11
Most golfers think their biggest problem is their swing. Brad Smith, PGA, has spent 38 years proving them wrong. In this episode, we unpack why the mental game matters even if you're a 20 handicap — and what you can actu…
The Range Series Part 4: Why Putting is Simple [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 36:53
I had 11 three-putts and a four-putt across 4 rounds at the Ohio Am. I hit the ball great. My putting destroyed me. This is the finale of the Range Series. Hayden and I break down the 3 skills that actually matter on the…
The Range Series Part 3: Make Chipping Easy [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 29:25
Phil Mickelson. Jordan Spieth. Seve Ballesteros. These are the guys we watch pulling off miraculous up and downs from impossible spots. So we try to replicate them. The problem? We blade the ball into someone's backyard…
The 20 Handicapper Building Your Next Golf App [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 24:01
Luke is a 15-20 handicapper who works a 9 to 5. He's not a pro. He's not a coach. He's the guy building the Play Ready Golf app. In this episode, Luke explains why being the worst golfer on the team makes him the perfect…