5 Underrated Time Travel Romance Books That Deserve More Hype

5 Underrated Time Travel Romance Books That Deserve More Hype

Author: Under the Covers Book Blog June 3, 2025 Duration: 10:02

Ready to fall for a grumpy Highlander... across timelines? šŸ‘€

In this episode of Reading Under the Covers, I’m sharing 5 time travel romance books that absolutely deserve more hype. These are the hidden gems you may not have heard of—but they bring everything from fake marriage plots and haunted manor houses to hockey players lost in Regency England and Austen-themed chaos. If you love stories with a little magic, a little mayhem, and a lot of swoon... this list is for you.

Whether you’re in the mood for gothic ghost vibes or a romance that starts with falling into a loch (literally), this episode is packed with recs that aren’t overhyped—but should be.

This episode was originally recorded as a YouTube video, but I added a podcast-only intro and outro just for you. If you’d rather watch it with visuals or grab all the links, head over here:

Watch on YouTube

Read the blog post with more time travel secs

Books Mentioned in This Episode:

Puck & Prejudice by Lia Riley

Hockey goalie meets Regency England + fake marriage

Buy on Amazon

Sinful Scot by Julie Johnstone & Cecelia Mecca

Billionaire falls into medieval Scotland, full of clan politics & steam

Buy on Amazon

A Stitch in Time by Kelley Armstrong

Gothic ghost romance with slow burn and second chances

Buy on Amazon

The Austen Affair by Madeline Bell

Enemies-to-lovers actors fall into a Jane Austen-inspired timeline

Buy on Amazon

Falling for the Highlander by Emma Prince

Sister falls into a loch... and into the arms of a brooding Laird

Buy on Amazon

Want more?

More Time Travel Romance Books on the Blog

My Highlander Hero Tier Ranking Video

More Highlander Romance Recs


If you've ever stayed up far too late, utterly lost in the world of a romance novel, you're in the right place. Reading Under the Covers: A Romance Novel Podcast is that feeling, turned into a conversation. Hosted by the two friends behind the Under the Covers Book Blog, this podcast feels like pulling up a chair in your favorite bookstore cafƩ. Each episode is a deep, often hilarious, and always heartfelt dive into the books they can't stop thinking about. You'll hear genuine, spoiler-filled discussions that dissect everything from beloved tropes and character chemistry to the sheer craft of storytelling. It's a celebration of the genre in all its forms-historical, contemporary, fantasy, and everything in between. More than just reviews, it's about the shared experience of reading: the anticipation of a new release, the comfort of a re-read, and the joy of finding a perfect book boyfriend. This is a space for fellow enthusiasts who understand that a great romance novel isn't just a story; it's an escape, a comfort, and a source of genuine delight. Tune in for passionate recommendations, thoughtful analysis, and the kind of enthusiastic fangirling that only true friends and book lovers can share.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Reading Under the Covers: A Romance Novel Podcast
Podcast Episodes
2026 Romance Book Club and Readalongs [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 18:04
Kicking Off 2026 with Exciting Romance Book Clubs and Read Alongs!In this first episode of Reading Under the Covers, a romance novel podcast, in 2026, Francesca introduces an exciting lineup of romance book clubs and rea…
Ranking the 12 Best Historical Romance Books I Read in 2025 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 11:04
Finding good historical romances is weirdly hard right now, so in this video I’m RANKING the best historical romance books I read in 2025… from ā€œthis was funā€ all the way up to ā€œnew all‑time favorite unlocked.ā€This is a…
Christmas Traditions We Grew Up With (and What We Do Now) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 55:44
Pull up a chair, pour the coquito, and get ready for the ultimate cozy chat about how we really do the holidays. In this special archive episode from 2024, we're talking about our personal Christmas (and beyond) traditio…
The 20 Best Fantasy Romance Books I Read in 2025 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 11:25
Tired of seeing the same 5 fantasy romance books recommended over and over? In this video I’m sharing 20 underrated fantasy romance books I read in 2025 and bringing you the hidden gems and romantasy favorites you need o…
I Created a Modern TBR for Jane Austen - Would She Be on BookTok? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 8:00
What would Jane Austen read if she were alive today? We are celebrating her 250th birthday by building her perfect modern TBR and asking the big question: would she DNF YOUR favorite book?In this episode of Reading Under…
Goodreads Choice Awards 2025 Winners Reaction + Books That Got ROBBED [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 45:36
Goodreads just dropped the 2025 Choice Awards winners, and we had… feelings. In this episode of Reading Under the Covers, we go category-by-category reacting to the wins, the vote blowouts, and the surprises (and yes, we…
Spicy and Unhinged Christmas Romance Books Feat. Krampus [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 9:39
I skipped the cozy, feel‑good Christmas romance books this year and went straight for the unhinged, unholy, and totally unhinged ones instead šŸŽ„šŸ’€ From murderous Santas to deeply questionable MMCs to… a certain horned holi…
This Romance Reading Challenge Changes Everything - Romanceopoly 2026 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 11:54
Welcome to Romanceopoly University: the 2026 romance reading challenge where YOU choose your major, minor, and build your perfect reading year. Choose from 5 departments, customize everything, or follow the Simple Path!T…