Why is Weaning So Often So Traumatic?

Why is Weaning So Often So Traumatic?

Author: Balchem Animal Nutrition & Health August 29, 2023 Duration: 54:16

Guests: Dr. Jim Drackley, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign; Dr. Mike Van Amburgh, Cornell University & Dr. Jim Quigley, Cargill

Our Real Science Exchange pubcast always has leading scientists and industry professionals discussing the latest ideas and trends, and tonight we have three distinguished guests. Dr. Jim Drackley, Dr. Mike Van Amburgh, and Dr. Jim Quigley join us to discuss the weaning period and why it can be so traumatic for dairy calves.

Dr. Drackley leads off by describing that this topic is popular because it's still a problem. The advantages of feeding more milk during the milk feeding period are clear, but there can be system failure around the weaning transition from large amounts of milk to starter. There's often some slump in growth or even calf loss in some cases. (04:40)

Dr. Drackley emphasizes the importance of a properly texturized feed, starch content in calf starter, weaning age, and feeding too much hay which leads into a discussion about the importance of butyrate over propionate in rumen development. (05:31) 

Dr. Quigley tackles the idea of weaning age and rumen development, stating that research has found NDF digestibility isn’t mature until the calf has reached a threshold of about 15 kilograms of cumulative NFC intake. The latest NAHMS study suggested a typical weaning age in the industry of about nine weeks and this usually coincides with the NFC threshold (10:39)

Dr. Van Amburgh suggests that patience may be lacking when it comes to the weaning transition. Research shows taking more time to transition from milk to solid feed in a stepwise manner can lessen or remove the post-weaning performance lag. (19:41)

Dr. Van Amburgh goes on to reiterate the importance of butyrate production in rumen development and that the inclusion of simple sugars into calf starters rather than high levels of starch are beneficial. (21:26)

Dr. Drackley then reaffirms the importance of a gradual transition from milk given the cow’s natural lactation curve. A calf would be receiving less and less milk each day, not an abrupt shift to a different diet which often is not mimicked in weaning transition programs. (25:18)

Dr. Morrow gives the veterinarian perspective and agrees with the panel that a proper weaning transition program could take away a lot of the respiratory disease impacts on post-weaning performance. (27:14)

The panel shifts to speak to the long term impacts of a poor weaning transition program. Dr. Drackley emphasizes calves who experience disease have both lower longevity and lower milk production in the herd. (29:26)

Dr. Van Amburgh cites European research that showed if nutrition from weaning on didn’t achieve target body weights at certain stages of physiological development, reproductive efficiency was decreased as a heifer and as a lactating cow. (30:13)  

Each panelist gives an overview of the “perfect” calf weaning program. Dr. Quigley emphasizes a slow transition with high diet quality before and after weaning (32:46)

Dr. Van Amburgh further underlines the importance of calf starter diet quality, focusing on simple sugars and amino acids, rather than starch and crude protein (37:29)

Dr. Drackley focuses on the fact that digestive tract development is allometric during this time in the calf’s life, where the digestive tract develops at a faster rate than the rest of the body. Ensuring the calf has adequate nutrition to support this growth is imperative, and is an important focus for future research. (41:37)

Dr. Van Amburgh suggests that changing the way starter is presented to calves so they know it’s feed is critical because they may not be in an environment where they can learn from others. (48:18)

The panel wraps up with one piece of advice for calf weaning programs: be patient! (50:33)

Please subscribe and share with your industry friends to bring more people to join us around the Real Science Exchange virtual pub table.  

If you want one of our new Real Science Exchange t-shirts, screenshot your rating, review, or subscription, and email a picture to anh.marketing@balchem.com. Include your size and mailing address, and we’ll get a shirt in the mail to you.


Ever wonder what animal scientists talk about after the formal presentations are over and the notebooks are put away? Real Science Exchange-Dairy captures that exact spirit, moving beyond the lecture hall to explore the ideas shaping dairy and animal nutrition. Presented by Balchem Animal Nutrition & Health, this series feels more like a lively, insightful table conversation among colleagues than a staged interview. You’ll hear leading researchers and experts discuss pressing topics in the field, but in a relaxed, unfiltered way that reveals the person behind the data. The dialogue is driven by genuine curiosity and a shared passion for natural sciences, covering everything from emerging research to practical applications. Each episode is an exchange of perspectives, offering a range of new ideas that challenge conventional thinking. It’s a podcast for anyone interested in the real-world science that impacts animal health and productivity, delivered with the authenticity of a discussion among friends. Tune in for thoughtful, accessible conversations that connect complex concepts to the bigger picture of life and scientific discovery.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 205

Real Science Exchange-Dairy
Podcast Episodes
Real Science Exchange - Year in Review [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 33:47
Guests: Drs. Clay Zimmerman, Glen Aines, Eric Altom, Jeff ElliottAs we close out 2021 we want to take a few minutes to look back. The Real Science Exchange was started to have a more in-depth and intimate conversation wi…
Biosecurity Imperatives and the Feed Supply [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:03:57
Guests: Dr. Jordan Gebhardt, Kansas State University and Dr. Chad Paulk, Kansas State University Co-host: Dr. Zack Lowman, BalchemTonight we are talking feed supply biosecurity and the many challenges we face as we try t…
NRC Series: Vitamins & Minerals [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:15:54
Guests: Dr. Bill Weiss, The Ohio State University and Dr. Rich Erdman, University of MarylandTonight we finish the conversation on the new NRC with two legends in the industry. We’ll first focus on macro minerals, trace…
NRC Series: Feed Intake & Carbohydrates [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:06:00
Guests: Dr. Mary Beth Hall with the USDADr. Paul Kononoff from the University of Nebraska-LincolnCo-host: Dr. Clay Zimmerman, BalchemWe continue our discussions on the new 2021 dairy NRC, now known as NASEM. This is a fo…
NRC Series: Dry Cows, Calves and Heifers [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:02:20
Guests: Dr. Jim Drackley, University of Illinois Dr. Bill Weiss, The Ohio State UniversityDr. Mike VandeHaar, Michigan State UniversityTonight, we continue our discussions with the authors of each chapter of the new NASE…
NRC Series: Protein and Amino Acids [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:09:00
Guests: Dr. Mark Hanigan, Virginia TechDr. Jeff Firkins, The Ohio StateDr. Hélène Lapierre, Agriculture and Agri-Food CanadaOur Dairy NRC series of Real Science webinars was very well received and tonight we are talking…
NRC Overview Fats & Energy [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:07:51
Guests: Dr. Lou Armentano, University of Wisconsin-Madison and Dr. Mike Vandehaar, Michigan State University. Co-host: Dr. Glen Aines, BalchemWe are just coming off a very successful Real Science Lecture Series set of fi…
Dairy Producer Panel [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 52:05
Guests: Jim Ostrom, MilkSource, with locations in Wisconsin, Michigan and MissouriPat Maddox, RuAnn Genetics and Maddox Dairy in CaliforniaJonathan Lamb, Oakfield Corners Dairy and Lamb Farms in New York & OhioCo-host: B…