How to Handle Listener Feedback (Even the Awkward Bits)

Welcome to the show! In this episode, I’m pulling back the curtain and sharing the feedback you’ve given me over the past year. From the things you love—like honest opinions and those behind-the-scenes bloopers—to areas where you think I could improve, I’m breaking it all down.

I’ll share how I process both praise and criticism, respond to some thought-provoking and even challenging listener comments, and talk openly about staying authentic on the microphone, no matter what.

If you’ve ever wondered how to handle feedback for your own podcast—or you’re just curious about what really goes on behind the scenes—this episode is for you. Let’s jump in and talk about what it really means to grow through feedback!

Main Points Covered

1. Shared survey results about my audience (how you found the show, preferences on episode length, etc.)
2. The value of opinions and why I’m not afraid to voice mine—people appreciate authenticity!
3. Blooper reel gets love for keeping the show relatable and real.
4. Several listeners said the show’s focus has improved—thanks for noticing!
5. Some prefer solo episodes to interviews, and I talk about why I sometimes do interviews anyway.
6. The “same old” show approach: people tune in for consistency, just like reruns of Hallmark movies.
7. Trust is crucial; I work hard to give value and answers you can’t find elsewhere.
8. You can tell when I’m tired or distracted! I agree—your energy transfers to listeners.
9. Being award-winning isn’t about ego—my goal is always helping people.
10. Repetition helps beginners, but seasoned podcasters would like more advanced content.
11. Technical details: I use a Rode Podmic USB microphone into a Rodecaster Duo, recording in Hindenburg.
12. Notes on ideas and feedback: people want more “behind-the-scenes” and technical information.
13. Reading vs. riffing: I admit sometimes I slip into “reading mode” and work to stay spontaneous.
14. Length controversy: some want shorter shows, some longer, but the majority like the current format.
15. Hobbyists vs. business podcasters: I explain why my content has sometimes shifted toward podcasters wanting to grow.
16. Ads feedback: some want fewer ads, especially repeating the School of Podcasting ad too often.
17. Religion and “blue” humor: I discuss my Christian identity, my sense of humor, and respect differing tastes—even when jokes cross lines.
18. You can’t please everyone—sometimes what “crosses the line” for one person is just casual for another.
19. Suggestions for more advanced content and deeper listener Q&A segments.
20. Advanced podcasting wisdom: find out what your audience wants, deliver with value, and keep improving.
21. On making money: it’s possible, but requires loving the journey and standing out from the crowd.
22. I’m always open to detailed questions—consider sending in your own for future deep dives!

Websites Mentioned

1. School of Podcasting
2. Podcasting Observations (my email list)
3. Podpage
4. AppSumo
5. Voicemail: schoolofpodcasting.com/voicemail
6. Biz Chicks Podcast
7. AI Goes to College
8. Live Well and Flourish
9. Rode Podmic USB
10. Rodecaster Duo Mixer Recorder
11. Feeding My Faith Show

Mentioned in this episode:

Get Your Podcast Up and Going in Six Weeks

Dreaming of starting your own podcast but not sure where to begin? Podcasting in Six Weeks gives you a clear, step-by-step path to go from idea to launch with confidence. This practical course is designed to help you create, record, edit, publish, and promote your podcast in just six weeks. Whether you're starting from scratch or feeling overwhelmed by the technical side, you'll get the guidance, structure, and tools you need to launch a podcast that sounds professional and reaches the right audience. Ready to stop overthinking and start podcasting? Join Podcasting in Six Weeks today and turn your voice, ideas, and expertise into a show people want to hear. The best part? It's only $1 Classes Start June 3rd

Podcasting in Six Weeks

Question of the Month

This might be harder question to answer because when I ask people, the sometimes freeze. The question? How do you measure success for your podcast beyond download numbers? I need your answer by June 26th, 2026. Don't forget to tell us a little bit about your show and your website address so I can link to it in the show notes.

Question of the Month

Check Out Dave's Newsletter With Behind the Scenes Content

In each issue of Podcasting Observations, I share my thoughts on what is happening in the podcasting space, my latest content, and things that have caught my eye. I also may ask for your opinion. Join the free community

Podcasting Observations

See Your Show On Podpage

If you host a podcast, your website should work as hard as your episodes do. At Podpage, we automatically create a beautiful, professional site for your show — complete with episode pages, transcripts, audio players, SEO optimization, and built-in tools to grow your audience. No design work. No plugins. No ongoing maintenance. In less than a minute, you can see exactly what your podcast would look like on Podpage. Go to podpage.com/preview and generate your free preview site now. (No Credit Card Required) See your show the way it should look.

Podpage