The State of Pastors 2021

The State of Pastors 2021

Author: Garry Brackett: Executive Coach, Non-Profit Leadership Equipping , and Blogger December 13, 2021 Duration: 21:29

A Crisis on The Horizon

YES we have moved from 3-n-10 to 2-n-5 pastors are giving serious consideration of leaving the ministry completely. This is a vocational exodus! When you consider there are approximately 350,000 protestant churches in America  with 38% considering leaving, this will become a crisis of spiritual leadership within our nation. This is 133,000 Pastors considering their departure today. To give a perspective on this number consider there are approximately 35,000 McDonalds in America. The possibility of spiritual leadership loss in American is greater than the iconic McDonalds fast food chain. 

Let’s examine some of the underlying points of data and discussion.

•We must reach back to 9/11 to see demographics at this level where people are considering leaving their current career.

•Understand, this is not a FAITH EXIT. It is however a career exit•Bi-vocational ministry has real potential for the future. There are huge pressures being exerted on pastor’s families and futures. This could be a beginning of significant changes in shaping what church looks like and how it will be conducted in the future.

•Currently, Pastoral Ministry is VERY HARD work with only ½ or less return for such incredible effort being exerted. Hard work with ½ return creates frustration.

•Pastors that are under the age of 45 have a 46% likelihood of quitting. Pastors over the age of 45 are 36% more likely to quit the ministry.

•When it comes to “Well-Being” there are six categories: Relational, Spiritual, Physical, Emotional, Vocational, and Financial well-being. One-third of all ministers stated they were below average to poor in these six essentials of Well-Being.

•Only one-n-three pastors say they are healthy in terms of Well-Being matrix.

•Healthy Pastors are defined as those who selected “Excellent” or “Good” as their response to the Well-Being matrix.

•Overall, the Pastors that are contemplating quitting are less healthy in all the well-being categories compared to Pastors who not contemplating quitting.

•We need to be careful about allowing correlation to be a means to causation. 

•The warning bells started sounding in the 2017 State of the Pastors study.

•After 18 months of the pandemic, along with congregational divisions, financial strain an alarming number of pastors are seriously leaving the vocational ministry for other pursuits in life.

David Kinnaman, President of Barna Research states that now more than ever, the church needs resilient leaders who are humble, agile, rooted in prayer and those who are committed to being healthy as an essential aspect of effective leadership.

LINKS

Shepherds Advantage Leadership Podcast is now on iTunes – SUBSCRIBE

Shepherds Advantage Leadership Podcast is now on Stitcher – SUBSCRIBE

FREE GIFT – “Servant Leadership Questions” – Click on the icon at the bottom of the page

Executive Coaching Service– Private message me for details on this customizable service

Birkman Assessment

Leadershift by John Maxwell

Q&A – Contact me at ShepherdsAdvantage@gmail.com

Music: “Gratitude Mood” by David Arivett. You can learn more about his music by clicking on his name. THANKS DAVID!


Garry Brackett brings his experience as an executive coach and non-profit leadership specialist to every conversation on the Shepherds Advantage Leadership Podcast. This isn't about abstract theory; it's a practical exploration of how leadership principles intersect with faith, culture, and the daily challenges of making a meaningful impact. Garry engages with a diverse range of guests-people who are actively shaping their communities and organizations-to uncover the real-world strategies and personal convictions that drive effective, compassionate leadership. You'll hear discussions that feel like a thoughtful mentorship session, covering topics from organizational health and personal resilience to the spiritual foundations that guide service-oriented work. This podcast serves as a resource for anyone, whether in ministry, non-profit, or broader community roles, who seeks to lead with purpose and integrity. Tune in for authentic stories and grounded advice that equips you to navigate the complex landscape of modern leadership with confidence and clarity.
Author: Language: en-us Episodes: 60

Shepherds Advantage Leadership Podcast
Podcast Episodes
Discovering Hope [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 19:54
Hope is like oxygen it is a requirement for living! You cannot live without HOPE! Author Dr. Shane Lopez writes; I have convincing evidence that hopeful thoughts and behavior propel us toward well-being and success; hope…
4 Needs of Followers [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 21:29
There has been much written about post-pandemic leadership models, effective post-pandemic leadership strategies, and post-pandemic efforts to return to pre-pandemic days. Little to nothing is being said about those who…
Inspirational Leaders [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 21:29
Napoleon Bonaparte once stated that “Leaders are dealers in HOPE!” If you are a leader, how do you inspire hope in a chaotic world? Better yet, If you are a person that Trains the Trainer, how do you inspire those who ne…
Your Most Dangerous Thought [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 20:29
The old adage is true; “What got you here, will not get you there!” You must maintain a sense of Hunger for personal growth; Live out true humility in front of your team; demonstrate what servant leadership looks – that…
Is Your Leadership Worth Following? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 21:24
Not all leadership is great leadership! There are certain qualities that true leaders cannot afford to go without. Here are some of those qualities. HUMMILITY – C S Lewis accurately describes humility when he said that h…
Cadence of Biblical Leadership [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 21:29
Jesus’ words in John 5:19 is our beginning point to understand a biblical cadence. Note his words; “…..the Son can do nothing of his own accord, but only what He sees the Father doing. For whatever the Father does…the So…
Ungrieved Losses [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 19:29
Let’s pause for just a minute. If 4-in-5 Spiritual Leaders are stating it is difficult to invest in spiritual development and if running on fumes is the new normal; what is the person seated in the auditorium receiving f…
Mental Health Awareness Pt 2 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 23:29
Currently 44% of Americans state that Churches should be the center of counseling within the community. 74% of nonpracticing Christians 3 out of 4 people stated they would reengage the church if they offered sermon teach…
Mental Health Awareness [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 21:29
I suppose it goes without saying, but 2020 has proven to be very difficult in non-profit enterprises. The isolation, social distancing, and learning to speak into a camera, Questioning if anyone would return to church, h…
Positional Vs Moral Authority [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 18:29
The key question that demands an answer is how do we captivate people’s heart? There are three things that I would offer to answer this question. Be Authentic – Pay The Price – It will be significant – Give Value to othe…