734. Finding Fire Island with Jess Rothschild

734. Finding Fire Island with Jess Rothschild

Author: Sarah Wendell September 4, 2026 Duration: 1:00:25

Jess Rothschild is a podcaster and journalist, one of the founding writers at Autostraddle, and her latest project is a documentary podcast called Finding Fire Island, about the history of Fire Island, Cherry Grove, and the Pines. Her prior work includes The Cult of Soul Cycle, and I love BOTH of these productions. Jess has been writing online longer than I have, and we talk about internet history, the process of making a podcast documentary, and what it’s like to have all your neighbors tell their most juicy, gossipy stories to you. For work. 


Finding Fire Island is a unique historical record, and I hope you’ll listen or watch. 


Please be advised that you can’t talk about gay history in the US without talking about the AIDS epidemic and the loss of so many people, so this episode is a little poignant at times. 


You can find Jess Rothschild on Instagram @JessXNYC.


Links ahoy!



Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


If you’ve ever felt a little defensive about loving romance novels, or just want to dive deeper into the books you can’t put down, Smart Podcast, Trashy Books: A Romance Novel Podcast is your perfect companion. Host Sarah Wendell approaches the genre with a critic’s sharp mind and a fan’s enthusiastic heart, creating conversations that are as thoughtful as they are joyful. This isn’t just author interviews, though you’ll hear brilliant voices like Ilona Andrews, Sarah J. Maas, and the wonderfully unique Chuck Tingle. The scope of the podcast is deliberately wide, bringing in reviewers, librarians, editors, and publishing professionals to examine every facet of the romance world. You’ll get honest talk about tropes and trends, the business behind the books, and why these stories resonate so powerfully with millions of readers. Regular appearances from Amanda Diehl add another layer of camaraderie and insight. Listening feels like being part of a smart, welcoming book club where no opinion is dismissed and passion is a given. It’s a celebration of a genre that dominates fiction, explored with humor, intelligence, and genuine curiosity. Whether you’re a longtime devotee or a curious newcomer, this podcast offers a rich, engaging, and deeply human look at the stories we love.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

Smart Podcast, Trashy Books: A Romance Novel Podcast
Podcast Episodes
705. RT Rewind: June 1997 Reviews [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 58:00
Amanda and I are back, deep diving into romance and pop culture history with issue 1997 of Romantic Times Magazine. The cover reads Love, Lust, Laugh, and we’ve got some vintage books to talk about. Then we talk about wh…
704. JQ Editions with Julia Quinn [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:00:47
My guest this week is Julia Quinn and we are talking about, of course, JQ Editions, a new subscription service creating special limited editions of historical romances. I’ve been writing about this since it was announced…
703. Oscars and Gossip with Kayleigh Donaldson [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 59:37
Kayleigh Donaldson is back! She is the guest on some of the most popular episodes, and I know what that is: she’s brilliant. We recorded this just before the Oscar nominations were announced, so Kayleigh is making (some…
702. Heated Rivalry with Candy Tan [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:24:02
Candy recapped Heated Rivalry, and is that enough? No, of course not. We had MANY things we wanted to exclaim at each other about, so why not podcast about it?We’re going to talk about the show, the acting, the adaptatio…
701. Holiday Wishes with Amanda and Sarah [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 56:05
It’s never too late for Holiday Wishes, right? We had such a record number of interviews for the Holiday Wishes episodes this year, and I truly love doing them. Thank you.But many of you asked about Amanda’s recs and wis…
700. An Art History Analysis of Romance Covers with Amanda Matta [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:00:50
Happy 700th Episode!! Amanda Matta is a debut author (her book is coming in 2027!), media commentator, royal analyst, and an art historian. I’ve mentioned Amanda, and her podcast Art of History, which I love. In that sho…
699. Holiday Wishes VII with Katie, Kate and Adam [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 43:55
Happy New Year!This week we are talking with Katie, Kate, and Adam – we’ve got book recs, wishes, spreadsheet discussions, dungeons, and some wishes that don’t violate the Hatch Act.There’s also rather appalling poo adve…
697. Holiday Wishes V with Shana, Sue, and Rhonda [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:00:07
This week we are talking with Shana, Sue, and Rhonda about book recs and wishes, plus fantasy and magical bureaucracy, grief in romance, schtupping by volume, and inventions for readers to find even MORE books.We also me…
696. Holiday Wishes IV with Rae A, Josephine, and Sneezy [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 58:20
We’re back with more Holiday Wishes! This week we’re talking with Rae A., Josephine, and Sneezy!This week we are talking romance bookstores and road trips, luxurious bidets, webtoons, and, of course, books. And some rant…