AI or Community: Where Should Creators Focus?

AI or Community: Where Should Creators Focus?

Author: Jeff Sieh September 3, 2025 Duration: 54:51

Everywhere you turn, creators are talking about AI. Should you be leaning into tools that save you time, churn out content, and help with workflows? Or should your energy go into building real relationships and community that lasts? That’s the big question Conor and I tackled this week with our friend Paul Gowder of PowWows.com.

Paul has been building thriving online communities since before AI was even on the radar, and he’s quick to point out that the smartest path forward is learning how to use both together. In this conversation, we wrestle with the balance: how to let AI assist without losing your personal voice, how email can be more than a broadcast channel, and why community is the thing that keeps creators relevant no matter what tech comes next. If you’ve been wondering whether to spend more time testing AI tools or strengthening the connections you already have, this episode will help you see where to put your focus.

Key Takeaways

  • Community isn’t about size: Ten engaged people in your living room beats ten thousand ghost subscribers.
  • Email builds deeper connections: Write like you’re talking to one person, not shouting at a crowd.
  • Treat your newsletter as real content: Don’t just blast links. Make it valuable on its own.
  • Invite replies and interaction: Polls, trivia, and questions make people feel part of something. Then respond when they do.
  • AI is a helper, not a replacement: Use it to organize your thoughts or clean up drafts, but always add your own tone and stories.
  • Don’t force community: Start by treating your audience like they’re already part of something. The structure (Facebook group, Circle, etc.) can come later.

Resources


----------------------

Ecamm - Your go-to solution for crafting outstanding live shows and podcasts. - Get 15% off your first payment with promo code JEFF15

SocialMediaNewsLive.com - Dive into our website for comprehensive episode breakdowns.

Youtube.com - Tune in live, chat with us directly, and be part of the conversation. Or, revisit our archive of past broadcasts to stay updated.

Facebook - Stream our show live and chat with us in real time. Connect, engage, and be a part of our community.

Email - Subscribe and never miss a live show reminder.

----------------------

JeffSieh.com - Unlock the power of authentic storytelling with me! With over 20 years of marketing experience, I'm here to elevate your brand's narrative in an ever-competitive market. My expertise spans consulting, visual marketing, and producing podcasts and live videos.

Additionally, as a seasoned speaker, I'm not just about sharing knowledge--I believe in entertaining audiences and injecting humor into every presentation. I'm available to enlighten and engage audiences at your events, conferences, or institutions. My talks cover a diverse range of subjects, from purposeful repurposing and captivating storytelling to podcast promotion, social media strategies, visual marketing insights, the art of live video, and much more.


Staying current in the fast-moving world of social platforms can feel like a full-time job. That’s where Social Media News Live comes in. Hosted by Jeff Sieh, this isn't just a recorded lecture; it's a live, interactive conversation designed to cut through the noise. Each episode connects you directly with the people shaping the landscape-from seasoned marketing experts and platform innovators to successful creators who know how to tell a compelling story. You'll hear practical discussions about new features, algorithm shifts, and under-the-radar tools that can actually make a difference for your brand or business. The live format is key, allowing for real-time questions and answers that address the specific challenges you're facing right now. Tuning into this podcast feels like having a direct line to a room full of savvy professionals, all focused on translating the latest trends into actionable tactics you can use immediately. Whether you're building a company, growing an audience, or simply trying to understand the next big shift, these conversations provide clarity and a competitive edge.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

Creator News Live: Discussing the latest tools, tips, and tactics with industry experts, innovators, creators, and storytellers
Podcast Episodes
Stop Trying to Out-Market AI, Do This Instead [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:00:24
What happens when the marketing strategies that worked for years suddenly stop delivering?--------------Angie Callen, founder of The Modern Coach, believes we're in a messy transition where AI is creating more content an…
Everyone's Faking It Online. Here's What Actually Works. [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 51:47
What does it actually mean to “be authentic” when being authentic has become its own kind of performance? --------------Michael King Jr., founder of Teams.Coach, believes your strongest advantage comes from figuring out…
He Took the Deals Everyone Else Laughed At (And Won) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 57:41
What if the opportunity everyone else is laughing at is exactly the one you should be paying attention to?--------------Billy Thorpe built his business by taking the small video deals other creators dismissed, then figur…
How to Write and Actually Ship Your First Book (No Publisher) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 58:02
What actually turns “I should write a book someday” into a finished book you can hold in your hands? ---------------Lisa DiNoto Glassner, founder of The Castle Run and author of The runDisney Companion, shares how she to…
How to Build a Community That Lasts 10 Years (Not Just an Audience) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:00:12
Building an audience is one thing. Building a community that keeps showing up year after year is something else entirely. Mike Potter has spent two decades growing the For Mac Eyes Only podcast and the last ten years tur…
AI Is a Dial, Not a Switch (How Creators Win in the AI Era) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:01:40
What if the real question isn't whether to use AI, but where to use it? ------------Mike Schmitz believes the best creators aren't choosing between AI and human creativity. They're learning where AI adds value, where it…
The AI Back Office That Does the Work Creators Hate [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 52:56
What if the biggest opportunity with AI isn't creating more content, it's getting your time back? ----------------------Jennifer Bennett believes most creators are using AI in the wrong place. Instead of replacing your c…
Why The Best Conversations Need You to Shut Up [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 57:09
What separates a memorable interview from one people forget the moment it ends? -------------Matt Stagliano believes it isn't about asking better questions; it's about learning when to stop talking. Drawing from more tha…
Creator Skills AI Can't Steal [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 53:07
What happens when AI can write posts, create images, and sound increasingly human? What's left that truly belongs to you?In this AMA-style episode, Paul Gowder and I take the hot seat to explore two creator advantages th…
YouTube Just Changed Everything: What Creators Need to Do Now [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 54:29
What happens when YouTube starts answering questions instead of just serving up videos?----------------------In this episode, Jerry Potter joins us to break down one of the biggest waves of YouTube updates creators have…