Baker Mayfield's Fumble Problem, By the Numbers — Plus Bucs-Browns Preview

Baker Mayfield's Fumble Problem, By the Numbers — Plus Bucs-Browns Preview

Author: Tampa Bay Times September 15, 2026 Duration: 39:31

The stat that should worry Bucs fans: Baker Mayfield has fumbled the ball 35 times since 2023 — more than any quarterback in football.


A day after Tampa Bay's turnover-plagued loss to Cincinnati, Rick Stroud and Steve Versnick dig deeper into what went wrong and why it's not just a one-week problem. Todd Bowles blitzed on more than 40% of snaps — the third-highest rate in the league — and still generated almost no pressure on Joe Burrow outside of rookie Josiah Trotter's historic sack-and-pick-six. Rick breaks down a bizarre blown defensive alignment late in the first half that left the entire middle of the field open and let Burrow scramble 12 yards untouched, and explains why Alex Anzalone's rough debut — slow, out of position, exploited over the middle by Cincinnati's tight end — has him wondering if Detroit knew something by letting him walk. They also weigh whether Baker's competitiveness and refusal to "play boring" is now a real liability worth $165 million, and look at how much of Sunday's 33-27 result actually came down to two backbreaking fumbles worth a 14-point swing.


Then it's on to a wide-open NFC South and NFL Week 1 chaos around the league, before previewing Sunday's home opener against Cleveland — where Deshaun Watson, not Shedeur Sanders, looks likely to start against a Bucs team Todd Monken knows well. Plus a Rays mailbag: their magic number is down to 10 with six home games left, and Rick and Steve debate why national experts still see the Yankees, not Tampa Bay, as the AL's team to beat.


In this episode:



  • Baker Mayfield's fumble problem, by the numbers: 35 since 2023
  • The blown coverage that let Joe Burrow scramble 12 yards untouched
  • Why Alex Anzalone's rough debut has Rick asking hard questions
  • Todd Bowles' blitz rate vs. the Bucs' near-zero pass rush
  • Bucs-Browns preview: why Deshaun Watson is expected to start for Cleveland
  • Rays mailbag: magic number at 10, and the case for Tampa Bay over the Yankees


Send your mailbag questions to @SportsDayTB on X or email rstroud@tampabay.com. And get on down to Breitling Boutique at International Plaza — mention Sports Day Tampa Bay when you go.


#TampaBayBucs #BakerMayfield #TampaBayRays #NFL #MLB


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


For a daily dose of Tampa Bay sports talk that feels like a conversation with the most plugged-in friends you have, there's Sports Day Tampa Bay. This weekday podcast from the Tampa Bay Times is anchored by award-winning journalist Rick Stroud and co-host Steve Versnick, who bring a newsroom's rigor and a fan's passion to each episode. Instead of just rehashing scores, they dig into the nuances behind them-the strategy shaping the Buccaneers' defense, the roster decisions facing the Rays front office, or the playoff mentality driving the Lightning. The discussion naturally spans the full spectrum of local teams, including USF athletics, providing context that often gets lost in quick headlines. What you'll hear is analysis grounded in decades of institutional knowledge and reporting access, offering a perspective that turns the day's news into a deeper understanding of the games and the people who play them. Tune in each morning for this essential, insider-focused update that has become a routine for fans who want more than the highlight reel.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

Sports Day Tampa Bay
Podcast Episodes