How we make custom monsters (Episode 272)

How we make custom monsters (Episode 272)

Author: Tabletop Journeys April 17, 2026 Duration: 15:58

Ever stare at a blank stat block and wonder where to even start? In this episode of Dr. Homebrew, we pull back the curtain on the monster-building framework we use here at Tabletop Journeys. It's a rules-first, narrative-driven system we've refined across dozens of NPCs, published adventures, and card decks.


Whether you're crafting a terrifying custom beast or a compelling villain NPC, this episode breaks down our full process step by step. We cover everything from how Challenge Rating (CR) anchors the entire stat block, to feature points as a spendable currency, to how we handle spellcasting differently from the official Monster Manual and why we made those calls.


We even walk through a brand new NPC, Arwir Echagüe (CR4, undead, and very hard to read 👀), to show you exactly how it all comes together in practice.


🔑 Topics covered in this episode:

Why CR is the foundation of every stat block we build

Feature points, the hidden currency that balances your monsters

Why we put spells directly into the action economy (and why it matters at the table)

A full live walkthrough of a CR4 NPC stat block


Shoutouts to the incredible work of Teos Abadía, Mike Shea, and Tom Dunn that helped shape our process


💬 We want to hear from YOU! Drop a comment and let us know: Are we getting it right? Would you want access to the full ruleset? Interested in a Foundry module? Tell us below!


And remember:

✅ Like

✅ Subscribe

✅ Ring the Bell to never miss an Episode


🔗 Links & Resources mentioned in the episode:


Tao Sabadia & Mike Shea: https://slyflourish.com/lazy_5e_monster_building_resource_document.html

Tom Dunn: https://tomedunn.github.io/the-finished-book/monsters/monster-manual-2024/


🧭 Tabletop Journeys Links:

Patreon: patreon.com/ttjourneys

Bluesky: @ttjourneys.bsky.social

Facebook: www.facebook.com/ttjourneys

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ttjourneys

Website: https://ttjourneys.com/

Email: podcast@ttjourneys.com


#DnD #DungeonsAndDragons #DrHomebrew #TabletopJourneys #TTRPG #HomebrewMonsters #DungeonMaster #DMTips #StatBlock #DnD5e #HomebrewDnD #TableTopRPG #MonsterDesign #ChallengeRating #DMsGuild #FoundryVTT #NPC #RPG #TabletopGaming #DnDCommunity


Three longtime friends, with a combined century of experience around the gaming table, invite you into their ongoing conversation. Tabletop Journeys is a podcast born from decades of shared history, not just as gamers but as people who have spent a lifetime thinking deeply about the worlds we create together. You’ll hear the easy, often hilarious dynamic of a group that has played in and run every kind of tabletop and live-action roleplaying game imaginable. Their discussions are the kind that usually happen late at night, after the dice are put away, where ideas get pulled apart, rebuilt, and passionately debated. Each episode feels like pulling up a chair in one of those living rooms, listening in as they dissect everything from game mechanics and storytelling techniques to the unexpected life lessons found in collaborative imagination. It’s less a formal review show and more a chronicle of a lifelong journey through games, packed with the kind of insight and friendly argument that only comes from truly knowing your fellow travelers. Tune into this podcast for a natural, deep, and often very funny exploration of why we play.
Author: Language: en-us Episodes: 100

Tabletop Journeys
Podcast Episodes
OtRP (s2 Ep20) -Grimly we Tread Into the Dark [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 25:10
Grim, gritty, and unapologetically dark… today we crack open one of the most atmospheric 5E-compatible settings on the market.In this episode of Tabletop Journeys Presents: On the Right Path, we dive into Grim Hollow: Tr…
STA: Where Everything's Better the Second Time Around [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 8:15
OtRP (S2 Ep 19) – "Everything's Better the Second Time Around."===========================What comes after first contact… is where the real story begins.In this episode of On the Right Path, we take a second look at the…
Talking Star Trek Preservations with Lt. Neelan - (S3 Bonus Ep) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 29:38
Talking Star Trek Preservations with Lt. Neelan (S3 Bonus Ep)Go behind the scenes of Star Trek: Preservations as we sit down with Lt. Neelan for a deep dive into Season 3. This bonus episode explores the character’s evol…
Don’t Rebuy Your Books: The STA Conversion Guide System Explained [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 7:30
🎬 OtRP (S2 Ep 18) – Don’t Rebuy Your BooksWhat if upgrading your game didn’t cost you your collection?What if a new edition didn’t replace your library… but respected it?In this episode of On the Right Path, Lewanika bre…
OtRP (S2 Ep16) - Stop Making Perfect Characters [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 12:06
What if the problem with your character… is that nothing is wrong with them?Perfect characters look great on paper, but fall flat at the table.In this episode of On the Right Path, we break down why tension, contradictio…
What Happens When 5E Goes Modern? | Everyday Heroes RPG [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 10:02
What happens when 5E goes modern?No magic. No fantasy.Just operators, investigators, medics… and missions where every decision matters.In this episode of On the Right Path, Lewanika dives into Everyday Heroes RPG, a mode…
OtRP (S2 Ep16) - Stop Making Perfect Characters [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 0:24
What if the problem with your character… is that nothing is wrong with them?Perfect characters look great on paper, but fall flat at the table.In this episode of On the Right Path, we break down why tension, contradictio…
“Technobabble is a Tool, Not a Crutch” [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 8:06
“Technobabble is a Tool, Not a Crutch”How to blend Science & Drama in your STA MissionsYou need a natural phenomenon powerful enough to shatter a research outpost, scramble transporters, and change a character forever. W…