Top 20 Modern Era Bills Non-First Round Picks

Top 20 Modern Era Bills Non-First Round Picks

Author: Blue Wire April 21, 2025 Duration: 1:07:58

On this episode of Talking Buffalo, Patrick Moran is joined by Joe From Queens to conversate on several Buffalo Bills topics, including counting down Patrick's list of the top 20 Buffalo Bills non first round draft picks of the modern era.

Through interest and plenty of boredom, Patrick spent several hours going through every year of the Bills draft history and coming up with his power rankings of the best players that weren't taken in the first round. It's important to note that by modern era that means anytime past 1970 after the NFL and AFL merged. That disqualified a handful of 1960's draft picks that would've easily been on and likely near the top of the list, such as Butch Byrd, Mike Stratton, Tom Sestak and Billy Shaw.

Patrick counts down his list with explanations for each and spoiler alert---there's three current Buffalo Bills players on the list. As you'd expect Joe has plenty to say about several of the players and especially the order Patrick has them ranked in. Fun little spoiler alert----Joe is not very keen on Patrick's placement of Phil Hansen and also thinks current Bills cornerback Taron Johnson is ranked way too low.

Also, Joe has his Buffalo Bills/NFL Draft bingo board with plenty of hilarious nuggets. That plus their "True and False" segment, trying to avoid wrestling talk during Wrestlemania weekend and more.

Major props to Talking Buffalo sponsor, Sonny Red’s at 1841 Abbott Road in Lackawanna, just minutes from Highmark Stadium. We consider them THE most underrated spot for wings, pizza and other great food in Western New York plus it’s a great place to drink and have a great time.

♦♦♦♦♦

Follow Patrick Moran/Talking Buffalo Podcast 

Substack: Patrick Moran’s Substack

Twitter: @PatrickMoranTB

Blue Sky: @PatrickMoranTB.bsky.social

Instagram: @PatrickMoranTB

Facebook: Talking Buffalo Podcast 


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.


There's a particular kind of passion that comes from following Buffalo sports, a mix of unwavering hope and hardened realism that Talking Buffalo captures perfectly. Hosted by Buffalo-born Patrick Moran, this Blue Wire podcast dives deep into the heart of the city's teams, with a primary focus on the emotional rollercoasters provided by the Bills and Sabres. Patrick doesn't just report on games; he lives them, offering a perspective that can swing from critical skepticism to full-blown optimism in a single conversation. That authentic, sometimes self-deprecating fan voice is exactly what drives each episode. The show regularly features interviews with guests from across the sports world, media, and even pop culture, providing unique angles and insider insights you won't find elsewhere. It’s this blend of local passion, candid analysis, and diverse conversations that gives the podcast its character. You'll hear the highs, the lows, and all the gritty commentary in between, all filtered through the experience of someone who truly understands what it means to invest in these teams. For anyone who bleeds blue and red or simply appreciates the complex narrative of a sports city, Talking Buffalo feels like a conversation with a knowledgeable, and admittedly opinionated, friend.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 1000

Talking Buffalo
Podcast Episodes
Casual Friday: Bills, Sabres & Best MCU Movies [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:25:17
It’s Casual Friday on Talking Buffalo Podcast, which means Patrick Moran is joined by Noted Hockey author and Maintenance Day podcaster Joe Yerdon to discuss round of the NFL draft, including their takes after having som…
Placing All AFC Teams Into Six Tiers [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 58:17
On the episode of Talking Buffalo Podcast, Patrick Moran takes all 16 teams in the AFC and breaks then down into six different tiers now that offseason movement, for the most part is done and teams ready themselves for t…
Thoughts on Bills Drafting Elam Plus Sabres Stink Up Boston [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:06:36
It’s Casual Friday on Talking Buffalo Podcast, which means Patrick Moran is joined by Noted Hockey author and Maintenance Day podcaster Joe Yerdon to discuss round of the NFL draft, including the Buffalo Bills trading up…
Final Bills Mock Draft With Scenarios [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 48:44
On this episode of Talking Buffalo Podcast, the NFL draft is finally here and host Patrick Moran goes through one final Buffalo Bills seven-round mock draft before the real thing starts tonight.After concluding a five-we…
Bills Talk Plus Reviving The Shane Wright/Sabres Dream [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:13:07
It’s Casual Friday on Talking Buffalo Podcast, which means Patrick Moran is joined by Noted Hockey author and Maintenance Day podcaster Joe Yerdon to discuss the NFL Draft, Von Miller's candid words, the Buffalo Sabres s…
Buffalo Bills Mock Draft, Version 5.0 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:12:57
On this episode of Talking Buffalo Podcast, Patrick Moran is joined by friend and recurring guest Aaron Quinn from Cover 1 for the last in a five-week series consisting of full seven-round Buffalo Bills mock drafts. As a…
Owen Power, Sports Talk & Best 80's Sitcoms [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:27:22
It’s Casual Friday on Talking Buffalo Podcast, which means Patrick Moran is joined by Noted Hockey author and Maintenance Day podcaster Joe Yerdon to discuss a Owen Power making his Buffalo Sabres home debut, their poten…
Buffalo Bills Mock Draft, Version 4.0 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 57:56
On this episode of Talking Buffalo Podcast, Patrick Moran is joined by friend and recurring guest Aaron Quinn from Cover 1 for the four in a five-week series consisting of full seven-round Buffalo Bills mock drafts. As a…
What Happens With Jordan Poyer? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 38:26
On this solo episode of Talking Buffalo Podcast, Patrick Moran discusses the potential dilemma Buffalo Bills general manager Brandon Beane has when it comes to All-Pro safety Jordan Poyer, who reportedly is seeking a bra…
Casual Friday With Joe Yerdon Returns! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:30:05
It’s Casual Friday on Talking Buffalo Podcast for the first time in over a month, which means Patrick Moran is joined by Noted Hockey author and Maintenance Day podcaster Joe Yerdon to discuss a variety of topics, includ…