Unsolved Case Files - The Mysteries of Natalie Wood, Mary Rogers, and the Tylenol Murders

Unsolved Case Files - The Mysteries of Natalie Wood, Mary Rogers, and the Tylenol Murders

Author: Hosted by Shannon and Cathy | Horror Both Real and Fictional October 22, 2025 Duration: 49:43

In this Unsolved Crimes episode of Terror Talk – Killer Minds and Creepy Stuff, Shannon and Cathy dig into three of America’s most haunting unsolved mysteries.
From Hollywood’s glittering shores to 19th-century New York and the shadowed aisles of 1980s Chicago, these cases reveal how beauty, mystery, and tragedy intertwine.

We begin with the death of Natalie Wood, whose drowning off the coast of Los Angeles still raises questions decades later. Was it an accident, or something darker beneath the Hollywood glamour?
Next, we travel back in time to the murder of Mary Rogers, the beautiful cigar girl whose unsolved death inspired Edgar Allan Poe’s chilling story The Mystery of Marie Roget.
Finally, we discuss The Chicago Tylenol Murders, a case that sparked national panic and changed the way America viewed consumer safety forever.

This episode blends psychological insight with historical intrigue, exploring the archetypes of the “femme fatale,” the cultural fear of random violence, and the enduring fascination with unsolved crime.

  • The psychological and cultural archetype of the “beautiful victim”

  • How Natalie Wood’s case blurred lines between tragedy and scandal

  • Edgar Allan Poe’s real-life inspiration for The Mystery of Marie Roget

  • The panic and policy changes caused by the Tylenol murders

  • Why these cases continue to captivate decades later

Don’t miss weekly episodes diving into true crime, psychology, and horror culture.
👉 Instagram: @terrortalkpodcast
👉 YouTube: Terror Talk Podcast
👉 Facebook: Halloween All Year Long

Music by Mannequin Uprising — Original score for Terror Talk Podcast.


Ever find yourself wondering what really makes a terrifying film tick, or what twisted logic might run through a real predator's mind? That's the unique space where Terror Talk-Horror Movies, Psychopaths and Humor lives. Hosted by therapists Shannon and Cathy, this podcast brings an unexpected and insightful lens to the things that go bump in the night, both in reality and on the silver screen. Their professional background allows them to dissect the psychology of infamous serial killers with a clarity that's as fascinating as it is chilling, then seamlessly pivot to analyzing the latest horror blockbuster or a cult classic. What you'll hear is a blend of expert insight into criminal motives and the artistic mechanics of fear, all delivered with a relatable and often darkly humorous tone that makes the macabre surprisingly approachable. Each episode feels like a conversation with two friends who are deeply knowledgeable about the darkest corners of human nature and pop culture, breaking down the myths and media portrayals that shape our understanding of horror. This isn't just a rundown of scary stories; it's a thoughtful exploration of why we're drawn to them, packed with surprising takes and a genuine sense of community for anyone obsessed with the genre. Tune in for a smart, engaging, and occasionally funny journey into horror, both real and fictional.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Terror Talk - Horror Movies, Psychopaths and Humor
Podcast Episodes
Shrink Chat - Wolfman, Gladiator II, Companion, Grafted [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 34:20
It’s time for another Shrink Chat episode, where we dive into the latest horror (and a little action) to hit the screen! This time, we’re sharing our thoughts on Wolfman, Gladiator II, Companion, Monster Summer, Grafted,…
NOS4A2 - Book vs. Series – What Worked & What Didn’t - Spoilers [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 29:22
In this episode of Terror Talk Podcast, we dive deep into Joe Hill’s horror novel NOS4A2 and its TV adaptation. We break down the biggest differences, the best (and worst) aspects of each, and whether the show did justic…
Gloria Trevi: Scandal, Crime, and the Psychology Behind the Case [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 35:49
Gloria Trevi was once hailed as the "Mexican Madonna," but her career took a dark turn when she became embroiled in one of Latin America's most shocking criminal cases. In this episode of Terror Talk, we unravel the dist…
The Best PG-13 Horror Movies You Need to Watch [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 22:09
Looking for horror without the extreme gore? In this episode ofTerror Talk Podcast, we break down some of the bestPG-13 horror movies that prove you don’t need an R-rating to get seriously creeped out. From ghostly perio…
The Alphabet Murders: Victims, Suspects & the Unsolved Mystery [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 22:39
In this episode ofTerror Talk Podcast, we dive deep into the chilling case of theAlphabet Murders, a series of unsolved crimes that took place inRochester, NY, during the 1970s. These brutal murders of young girls—all wi…
PATREON BONUS - Sundance Trip Report [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 7:31
This is a preview of our all-new Patreon exclusive episode where Shannon and Cathy discuss Shannon's recent trip to Sundance.Want more? Head on over to Patreon and become a patron for exclusive bonus content, to join our…