The Biggest Mistakes Dividend Investors Make

The Biggest Mistakes Dividend Investors Make

Author: Brad Johnson March 19, 2026 Duration: 10:36

In this episode, Brad Johnson breaks down the biggest mistakes dividend investors make and why chasing high yield can quietly hurt long-term results. He explains what dividend investors should actually focus on, how to identify stronger businesses with staying power, and why dividend growth matters far more than the highest starting yield. Brad also shares how Evergreen Capital thinks about pairing dividend growth stocks with alternative income-producing assets for high-net-worth investors.


Book a Call

https://zpr.io/W6JaycaP8EeT

Evergreen Capital

info@evergreencap.com

Connect with Brad Johnson

https://www.linkedin.com/in/bradleyjohnson/


Key topics:

• Why the goal of dividend investing is lasting income, not just a high starting yield

• How yield traps can pull investors into weak businesses with unsustainable payouts

• What to look for in quality dividend growth stocks

• Why Texas Pacific Land Trust is a useful case study in dividend growth investing

• How yield on cost compounds over time

• The behavioral benefits of owning cash-flowing investments

• Why over-concentrating in REITs can create portfolio risk

• How payout ratios help reveal whether a dividend is sustainable

• The tradeoff between total return investing and dividend-focused investing

• Why high-net-worth investors often prefer income-producing portfolios


Timestamps:

00:00 - Introduction to Dividend Investing

00:21 - The Goal of Dividend Investing

00:39 - Avoiding Yield Traps

01:40 - Finding Quality Dividend Growth Stocks

02:34 - Case Study: Texas Pacific Land Trust (TPL)

03:51 - The Power of Yield on Cost

04:31 - Behavioral Benefits of Dividends

05:20 - Risks of Over-Concentrating in REITs

06:08 - Understanding Payout Ratios

07:13 - Total Return vs Dividend Strategy

08:04 - Achieving Market Returns with Quality Growers

09:03 - Strategy for High-Net-Worth Investors


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


For those looking beyond the ticker symbols, The Alternative Investor explores the tangible and often complex world of assets that don't trade on a public exchange. Host Brad Johnson, drawing from his experience at Evergreen Capital, believes a well-rounded portfolio often exists outside the daily noise of the stock market. This podcast digs into the practicalities of private equity, real estate, venture capital, and other non-traditional avenues. While these opportunities can offer different paths to growth, they come with their own unique set of questions and due diligence. Each conversation is geared towards demystifying that process. You'll hear detailed discussions on how these investments actually work, the structures involved, and the long-term mindset they require. The aim isn't to offer quick tips, but to provide a clearer framework for evaluation. Johnson breaks down real-world cases and strategies, focusing on the critical factors that can influence an outcome. It’s a resource for anyone considering how to allocate capital towards assets that aren’t as easily quoted or sold, with the understanding that higher potential returns often walk hand-in-hand with increased complexity. Tune in for a straightforward take on building resilience and potential through alternative holdings.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

The Alternative Investor
Podcast Episodes
We Talk to a Guy Who Bought a Business with an SBA Loan - EP.38 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 43:50
Just as this title says, we talk to guy who bought a business with an SBA loan! Nick Haschka is an entrepreneur and investor who lives in the San Francisco Bay Area, with his wife and two kids. He owns a small business c…
Should You Get an MBA? - EP.37 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 29:12
We often get emailed by 25-35 year olds interested in getting into private equity, venture capital, or real estate private equity, wondering if it’s worth it or not to go get an MBA. Both Brad and I have our MBAs (which…
How to Buy a $2 Million Business for $200K - EP.35 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 21:52
Today’s going to be a fun episode because we’re really excited to talk about today’s topic: SBA loans.If you think you need $1 million to get started in buying a company then this episode is for you. You don’t always nee…
To Hold or to Sell? That is the Question - EP.34 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 17:05
In this episode, we’ll take you below the surface for a much deeper analysis on all the variables you need to take a look at before closing the deal.Key Takeaways:[:13] You’ve been running a great piece of real estate fo…
What is a Covered Land Play? - EP.33 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 17:27
oday’s episode is about Covered Land Plays! A Covered Land Play is when you buy a property based on the existing use of that asset… but, what you’re really buying for is the land (in the hopes that someday it’s going to…
Don't Be Fooled By EBITDA - EP. 32 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 13:41
Today we’re talking about an incredibly important topic: the dangers of mistaking EBITDA with Cash Flow.It’s so tempting when you’re looking at a lot of these small businesses to buy and you see this metric called EBITDA…
What is a Search Fund? - EP.31 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 30:05
In this week’s episode, Brad and I discuss search funds! We explain what a search fund is (and who’s funding them), the four main steps, how they originally got started, who they’re great for, and why you should use one.…
How to Raise 10 Million Dollars - EP.30 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 35:44
In today’s episode we answer one of the questions that we probably get most frequently from people looking to break into the industry, and that is: ‘Once I’ve found the deal, how do I make it happen?’ Using the example o…