Overturning Poletown: County of Wayne v. Hathcock  | Taking Poletown

Overturning Poletown: County of Wayne v. Hathcock | Taking Poletown

Author: The Federalist Society April 5, 2022 Duration: 46:27
For over 20 years, the Michigan Supreme Court ruling in Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit, often referred to simply as Poletown, set the precedent for how and why eminent domain can be used. This was a controversial decision that was preceded by protests & holdouts, but eventually the Court’s decision allowed for the City of Detroit to use eminent domain to acquire land for General Motors to expand a car plant—land where a neighborhood existed. Part of what was at issue was what does “public use” mean? The Michigan Court found that the economic benefits that the plant promised to create sufficed as “public use,” regardless that the land was to be transferred to a private party, GM. But the story didn’t end there. In 2004, another eminent domain case, County of Wayne v. Hathcock, made its way to a new Michigan Supreme Court, and that court ended up overturning the precedent set in Poletown.

Today’s episode of the FedSoc Films Podcast features Robert P. Young, one of the Justice’s on the Michigan Court in 2004, to give key insights into why he was in favor of overturning Poletown.

This episode is inspired by our film Taking Poletown: A Community’s Fight Over Economic Justice & Eminent Domain, a short documentary that explores the battle that took place over 30 years ago between homeowners, government officials, and General Motors.

Watch the full film Taking Poletown: A Community’s Fight Over Economic Justice & Eminent Domain on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OaoessbpIIc


As always, the Federalist Society takes no position on particular legal or public policy issues; all expressions of opinion are those of the speaker.

Visit https://fedsoc.org/ to learn more!
Follow us on Instagram, YouTube, and Twitter:
https://www.instagram.com/fedsoc/

Produced by The Federalist Society, The FedSoc Films Podcast extends the conversation started by their documentary films. This isn't a simple recap but a dedicated space for the nuanced discussions that the visual medium can only introduce. Each episode pulls back the curtain on the ideas and legal principles shaping the stories you've seen, featuring the scholars, judges, and policy experts who understand them best. You'll hear candid debates and detailed commentary that explore the intersection of law, culture, and governance. The analysis is rigorous but accessible, designed for anyone curious about the foundational debates in contemporary society. It's a natural companion to the film series, offering depth and context that turns a compelling narrative into a fuller understanding of the issues at play. This podcast operates on the principle that the most important conversations continue long after the credits roll, providing a forum for that continued examination. The focus remains on substantive dialogue and expert perspective, reflecting the organization's commitment to fostering thoughtful discourse on matters of legal and public policy.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 45

The FedSoc Films Podcast
Podcast Episodes
BONUS: Why Law School Students Should Read Locke & Montesquieu [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 12:10
How did our founding fathers encounter the ideas of John Locke and Baron de Montesquieu? Today we have two professors from the film, Paul Carrese and Michael Zuckert, who are here to answer that question and give some ad…
George Washington: Not Just Another Founder | American Cincinnatus [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 56:40
In this episode of the FedSoc Films Podcast Dr. Matthew Spalding (Hillsdale College), Dr. Jeffry Morrison (Christopher Newport University), and Dr. W.B. Allen (Michigan State University) discuss how much George Washingto…
Washington Bids Farewell | American Cincinnatus [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 29:20
What was the significance of the first presidential farewell address in American history? In this episode of the FedSoc Films Podcast, Allison Wickens, Vice President of Education at George Washington's Mount Vernon, joi…
Montesquieu’s Constitution | The Philosophers Behind the Founders [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 43:19
Who was Baron de Montesquieu and which of his ideas made it into America’s founding documents? In this episode of the FedSoc Films Podcast, Prof. Paul Carrese and Prof. Michael Zuckert answer that question and more…