The Rural vs. Urban Divide

The Rural vs. Urban Divide

Author: The One Country Project April 29, 2026 Duration: 42:46

Buckle in, folks, because Suzanne Mettler brings deep insights on the rural-urban political divide — and it’s more about history, economics, and institutions than you might think. If you’ve ever wondered why rural voters often vote Republican, despite Democratic policies benefiting them, or how to start healing this fractured relationship, this episode is for you. 


In this episode:

  • Suzanne explains how the rural-urban political split is a recent phenomenon that gained momentum in the 1990s.
  • She breaks down the historical importance of the New Deal in shaping rural loyalty to Democrats, and why that loyalty has eroded.
  • We explore how economic shifts, job losses, and feelings of abandonment have driven rural voters into the arms of the GOP.
  • Heidi, Joel, and Suzanne discuss the role of shared culture, common values, and the lack of trusted institutions in reconciling the divide.
  • Insights on how Democrats can rebuild trust, emphasizing listening, local organizing, and respectful dialogue.

Whether you're a curious rural voter, a political junkie,, or just here for the engaging conversation, this episode unravels the complexities of the rural-urban divide with the precision of Suzanne's insightful analysis. Dive into the historical shifts, economic challenges, and the evolving political landscape that have shaped today's divide and the current realities of American politics.


Resources & Links:

The Hot Dish is brought to you by the One Country Project. To learn more, visit OneCountryProject.org, or find us on Substack (Onecountryproject.substack.com), and on YouTube, Bluesky, and Facebook (@onecountryproject).

  • (00:00) - Introduction to the Urban-Rural Divide
  • (01:04) - Suzanne Mettler's Background and Interest
  • (03:04) - The Evolution of Political Polarization
  • (06:18) - Historical Context: The New Deal and Rural Politics
  • (10:04) - Economic Policies and Rural Discontent
  • (12:57) - Cultural Identity and Political Choices
  • (16:47) - The Role of Organizations in Political Engagement
  • (20:00) - Trust and Communication in Rural America
  • (24:00) - Rebuilding Trust and Engagement
  • (30:10) - Opportunities for Democrats in Rural Areas
  • (35:00) - The Confiscation of Appropriated Funds
  • (38:02) - Congress and the Lawless Presidency
  • (40:45) - Shifting Political Dynamics in Rural America
  • (42:28) - OCP-YouTube-EndScreen.mp4

Heidi Heitkamp, a former U.S. Senator, and her brother Joel, a longtime Midwest radio host, bring a unique perspective to the table in their podcast The Hot Dish. Their dynamic is the engine here-a blend of deep policy knowledge from the halls of Congress and grounded, everyday insight from community radio, all filtered through the familiar and often humorous lens of sibling debate. They sit down with a range of guests, from national newsmakers and elected officials to local policymakers, focusing squarely on the ideas and actions that impact rural communities across America. These aren't dry lectures; they're animated discussions that dig into practical solutions for real challenges, from economic opportunities to infrastructure. Produced by The One Country Project, the conversation on this podcast is as informative as it is engaging, often punctuated by the kind of lively back-and-forth that only a brother and sister can provide. You'll come for the insightful analysis on politics and news, but you'll stay for the authentic and enlightening dialogue that makes complex issues relatable. Each episode serves up a hearty mix of substance and personality, offering listeners a fresh take on the stories that shape the heart of the country.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

The Hot Dish
Podcast Episodes
Remembering Democracy's Worst Day [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 43:13
In this episode, Heidi and Joel recall the January 6, 2021, insurrection at the U.S. Capitol with former Senator Joe Donnelly. They reflect on the events of that day, the role of law enforcement, and the political accoun…
An Internment Camp in Nebraska [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 46:06
In this episode of The Hot Dish, hosts Heidi Heitkamp and Joel Heitkamp are joined by Nebraska State Senator Machaela Cavanaugh to discuss her efforts to gain access to a state-run federal immigration detention center. S…
'Tis the Season for Community [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 30:17
In this episode of The Hot Dish, hosts Heidi and Joel Heitkamp announce the 2025 Rural Champion Awards before highlighting the Christmas Spirit of Kellie Smith, a small-town entrepreneur from Perham, Minnesota. Kellie sh…
What's Happening with Healthcare? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 46:00
Hosts Heidi and Joel Heitkamp welcome Cynthia Cox from the Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) to discuss the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and its impact on healthcare costs. Cynthia shares insights into how the ACA supports ind…
The Rebirth of Rural Democrats [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 40:20
The Liberal Redneck, Trae Crowder, joins Heidi and Joel Heitkamp to discuss his journey from rural Tennessee to internet fame. You will learn about Trae's unique perspective on blending humor with serious topics, discuss…
Don't Tell Jess Piper It's Raining [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 44:59
Jess Piper joins hosts Heidi and Joel Heitkamp to discuss the political climate in rural America, focusing on Democratic engagement and the challenges faced by local communities. The conversation covers economic issues,…
The Country is Great when the Country does Good [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 35:30
Hosts Heidi and Joel Heitkamp are joined by political commentator Chris Matthews to discuss the future of the Democratic Party, lessons from Bobby Kennedy, and the importance of connecting with everyday Americans. They e…
Justin Wolfers Tells The Truth About the US Economy [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 39:32
Economist Justin Wolfers joins hosts Heidi and Joel Heitkamp to break down the current state of the American economy under recent administrations. They discuss inflation, rural financial challenges, the impact of tariffs…
Tom Nichols on Trump's "Populist Popcorn" Military [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 42:15
In this Veteran's Day episode, Journalist and professor Tom Nichols joins hosts Heidi and Joel Heitkamp to discuss current leadership at the Pentagon and Justice Department, the state of American democracy, and Republica…
Gov. Tim Walz asks, "What happened to 'Don't Tread On Me'?" [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 50:52
Governor Tim Walz joins co-hosts Heidi and Joel Heitkamp to discuss the mounting economic and social challenges facing rural America. The conversation covers the farm economy, rural health care, trade policy, and how pol…