The Fundraising Reset: Retention, Reactivation, Results

The Fundraising Reset: Retention, Reactivation, Results

Author: The Association for Animal Welfare Advancement December 11, 2025 Duration: 45:07

What does it take to stabilize your donor pipeline, re-engage lapsed supporters, and grow fundraising revenue—without burning out your team?


In this episode of The Intake, host Katherine Shenar is joined by Kendall Paul, CEO of the Vanderburgh Humane Society, and Kristin Serrano, Vice President and Managing Director at TrueSense Marketing, for a candid, data-driven conversation about building a smarter, more resilient fundraising program. Since 2022, Vanderburgh Humane Society and TrueSense have partnered to design and execute an integrated fundraising strategy rooted in strategic segmentation, donor retention, reactivation science, and disciplined acquisition modeling.


The results are striking: the highest active donor count in five years, the successful reactivation of long-lapsed donors, and record-breaking fundraising revenue. Together, Kendall and Kristin walk through how the partnership worked, the decisions that mattered most, and what animal welfare organizations of any size can apply to strengthen their own fundraising efforts.


If you’re a fundraiser navigating donor fatigue, retention challenges, or pressure to “do more with less,” this episode offers real-world insight—and a roadmap forward.


Ever wonder what really happens behind the doors of an animal shelter or rescue? the Intake pulls up a chair to those conversations, offering a genuine look at the world of animal welfare. Created by The Association for Animal Welfare Advancement, this podcast moves beyond simple stories to explore the real challenges, heartwarming successes, and complex decisions faced by professionals and volunteers every day. You'll hear from the people on the front lines-from shelter directors and veterinarians to foster families and humane educators-as they discuss practical strategies, compassionate care, and the evolving philosophy of protecting animals. While the subject matter is rooted in animal welfare, the discussions naturally resonate with anyone who shares their home with a pet or is thinking of adding a furry member to their family. It’s a resource that feels like a thoughtful conversation with experts who understand that caring for animals involves the whole community, including kids and adults alike. Tune in for an honest and insightful audio experience that deepens your understanding of the dedicated work that ensures animals find safety, health, and love. Each episode of this podcast connects the dots between daily care and the broader mission of creating a more humane world for all creatures.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

the Intake
Podcast Episodes
DEI Journey with The Association and MSM Global [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:16:08
In 2019, The Association made an intentional commitment to examine DEI within our organization and across the animal welfare profession. That commitment ultimately led to the creation of our DEI Council and to a partners…
Disaster Fundraising and Communications with Pasadena Humane [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 56:19
In January 2025, the Eaton Fire burned for 24 daysin Pasadena Humane's service area. Evacuations and warnings affected more than 100,000 residents and 20,000 structures, over 9,400 structures were destroyed and Pasadena…
All About AAWA with Jim Tedford [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 38:17
What is The Association for Animal Welfare Advancement? Where did it originate? Why should I become a member? Jim Tedford sits down with Katherine Shenar to talk all things AAWA!
The Annual Conference...Registration is LIVE! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 36:22
Join us in Chattanooga, TN, October 26 - 29 for The Association's Annual Conference! AAWA's own Kelly Cunningham and Kristy Gonyer join Katherine to share the details of all the things you don't want to miss.Register tod…
Did You Miss The Network Live? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 49:25
Recently, animal welfare leaders from across the countrygathered for The Network Live, an event designed to bring together big ideas, honest conversations, and practical solutions for some of our profession's most pressi…
Community Cats with Stacy LeBaron [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 36:40
Stacy LeBaron has spent more than three decades helping cats and the people who care for them. Previously, she led the Merrimack River Feline Rescue Society, where innovative programs helped more than 100,000 cats and ki…