Hold or Sell?  What To Do With A North Carolina Nonperforming Note

Hold or Sell? What To Do With A North Carolina Nonperforming Note

Author: Scott Carson February 22, 2026 Duration: 17:27

Whether you are a seasoned real estate pro or a newcomer looking for a high-yield entry point, nonperforming notes (NPNs) offer a unique "backdoor" to property ownership. In a recent episode of the Note Closers Show, Hold or Sell Edition, note expert Scott Carson broke down a prime opportunity in New Bern, North Carolina, involving a single-family home with massive upside. With a foreclosure date already set, this deal is a masterclass in how savvy investors can leverage distressed debt to see returns that far outpace traditional fix-and-flips.


Key Takeaways from the New Bern Note Opportunity

  • The Asset Details & Location: The property is a 925-square-foot, three-bedroom, one-bath single-family home located at 571 Rocky Run Road in New Bern, NC. Situated on nearly 0.7 acres, the home is in a solid market near Raleigh and Greenville with a population of over 31,000. While the previous owner is deceased, the property has been well-maintained and recently cleaned out, sitting just off Highway 17.
  • The Financial Breakdown: The note has an unpaid balance of $51,000 and a total legal payoff of approximately $60,000. The seller is looking for bids around 80% of that legal balance—roughly $48,000—plus a $1,000 broker fee. Recent BPO (Broker Price Opinion) values the home at $189,000, with a quick-sale price of $179,000, providing a massive equity cushion for the note holder.
  • Strategy 1: The Foreclosure Exit: For investors seeking a quicker turnaround, finishing the existing foreclosure process is the primary play. North Carolina is a nonjudicial state but features a unique "upset bid" period that can last from 30 days to several months. If the property sells at auction for the full legal balance of $60,000, an investor at the $49,000 entry point could net an $11,000 profit, representing an annualized ROI of 44.8%.
  • Strategy 2: The "As-Is" Resale: If the property does not sell at auction and the investor takes it back (REO), they can choose to sell it as-is. By listing the property at a conservative $149,000 to ensure a fast sale—allowing the next buyer to handle the upgrades—the investor could net approximately $134,000 after closing costs. After the initial investment and a small cleanup budget, this path offers a projected gross profit of $83,000.
  • Strategy 3: The Fix-and-Flip Model: For those willing to manage a renovation, a $30,000 rehab could bring the property to modern standards. Even when listing at a discounted "moved-in" price of $169,000, the projected net profit stands at roughly $73,000. This strategy yields a 92% annualized ROI, though it requires more active management and local vendor oversight.


The New Bern deal highlights why note investing is often called "the cleanest way to play dirty real estate." Whether you prefer the hands-off approach of a foreclosure payoff or the higher-margin potential of a full renovation, the numbers in North Carolina are incredibly compelling. As Scott Carson notes, the key is taking action before the foreclosure clock runs out.


Watch the Original VIDEO HERE!


Book a Call With Scott HERE!


Sign up for the next FREE One-Day Note Class HERE!


Sign up for the WCN Membership HERE!


Sign up for the next Note Buying For Dummies Workshop HERE!


Love the show? Subscribe, rate, review, and share!


Join the Note Closers Show community today:


Get Signed Up For the Next Note Buying Workshop HERE!


Scott Carson brings his deep experience as a seasoned investor directly to you in The Note Closers Show-The #1 Podcast for Note Investing. This isn't about general real estate chatter; it's a focused dive into the specific, often overlooked niche of note investing. Each episode is built on the practical premise of acquiring control of real estate assets at significant discounts, not through traditional property management, but by understanding and investing in the debt behind them. You'll hear Scott break down complex strategies into actionable steps, sharing the nuances of evaluating, purchasing, and profiting from mortgage notes. The discussions are geared toward investors and entrepreneurs who are serious about expanding their portfolio options beyond conventional methods. Tune in for candid conversations about market trends, due diligence, risk assessment, and the real-world stories of deals that worked and those that didn't. This podcast serves as a direct line to advanced tactics and foundational knowledge, all aimed at building your confidence in this unique segment of the investment world. If you're looking to move past theory and into the practical mechanics of building wealth through notes, Scott Carson provides the roadmap in every episode.
Author: Language: en-us Episodes: 100

The Note Closers Show - The #1 Podcast for Note Investing
Podcast Episodes
Texas Foreclosures: Where Do You Find The List? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 22:12
In this episode, we explore the Texas foreclosure market and provide actionable strategies for real estate investors. With foreclosure activity on the rise, Texas offers significant opportunities, but navigating this mar…
How to Find Private SDIRA Investors In Your County [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 52:06
Tired of begging banks for capital? Ready to tap into a hidden goldmine of private funding? This week, we're diving deep into the world of Self-Directed IRA (SDIRA) investors and revealing how you can easily connect with…
What Every New Note Investor Needs To Do Before 2026 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 22:29
Howdy, investors! 🤠 Scott Carson here, ready to wrangle in some serious real estate success for 2026. Tired of New Year's resolutions that bite the dust by February? I'm spilling the beans on how to turn the last quarter…
What the Debt Markets Are Telling Us Real Estate Investors [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 23:11
Alright, Note Closers, brace yourselves! 🚀Scott Carson is here to give you a sneak peek into the future – and it ain't all sunshine and rainbows. According to the debt market tea leaves, a foreclosure wave is brewing, se…
88 Reverse Mortgage Notes: Death, Taxes, and Foreclosure Headaches [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 45:08
This week Scott reviews another tape of assets from a new provider. Buckle up your boot straps and hold on tight for this thrill ride of reverse mortgage notes. Scott dives into the map and spreadsheet, outlining the pos…
Deal or Dud:  When is a 13% ROI Performing Note a Dud? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 17:30
Alright, Note Closers! Scott Carson's back with a cautionary tale of epic proportions. And for this episode, it's all about the duds.In this cautionary (and terrifying) case study, Scott dissects a Kentucky note "perform…
Business Notes:  The Riskiest Investment Class with David Barnett [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 45:32
Thinking of diversifying into business note investing? This ain't your grandma's real estate note. David Barnett joins us to expose the real risks of buying paper backed by businesses. Forget passive income dreams; this…