Ch. 28 - What Ghosts Remain

Ch. 28 - What Ghosts Remain

Author: Radio Vérté | Cory Zimmerman June 15, 2023 Duration: 30:46

Step inside the charred remains--

Inside the old Victorian at 356 South First Avenue, we witness the fire's aftermath through the vivid descriptions of investigators who discover a crucial piece of evidence in Donna's living room: the pull-out sofa bed where Donna and Justine’s remains were found. As suspicion arises as they detect the presence of a flammable liquid at the scene, all collected evidence is meticulously examined at the Alcohol Tobacco & Firearms Forensic Science Laboratory in Rockville, Maryland. The analysis reveals alarming findings, verifying the traces of gasoline on clothing, wood, and hair samples taken from Donna Tompkins. Additionally, ethyl alcohol is detected, adding another layer of complexity to the case.

During the investigation, an interview with Sarah Haynes, David Haynes' wife, offers insight into their relationship and interactions with Donna. Sarah describes meeting Dave at the National Bank of Canton and emphasizes that they were married for four years. She acknowledges Donna as an acquaintance and reveals that Dave considered her one of his closest friends. While Sarah claims that she and Dave never babysat for Justine, they were always willing to offer help since they knew Donna faced financial struggles. Sarah provides an alibi for Dave, stating that he was home on the night of the incident, celebrating their child's birthday. However, Sarah's occasional memory lapses and eagerness to conclude the interview leave room for further exploration.

The interviews conducted at Donna's workplace—the bank—uncover intriguing details surrounding the case. And David Haynes, for the most part, maintains a consistent story among his colleagues, describing the chaotic gas meter, an orange-reddish glow from the front room, and his heroic act of breaking down the front door. Moreover, insights into Jon Tompkins' family dynamics emerge, suggesting that Jon's family was weary of his temper and speculating that he could have hired someone to harm Donna and Justine. These revelations hint at deeper tensions and motivations within the Tompkins family, leaving us to ponder the true extent of their involvement in this tragedy.

As we navigate the captivating narrative of this episode, we witness the emotional significance of the Victorian home and its impact on the community. The forensic discoveries from the crime scene and the insightful interviews provide valuable clues and raise thought-provoking questions about the parties involved. The evolving dynamics between the Haynes and Tompkins families and the intriguing inconsistencies and potential motives fuel our curiosity and leave us eagerly anticipating the subsequent revelations in this haunting case.

The tragic tale of Donna and Justine Tompkins continues to unravel, urging us to delve deeper into the enigma and seek justice for the victims.

Contact SRG: cz@studios.works.

Visit SRG: www.spoonrivergothic.com.

Instagram: @srg.podcast

Facebook: /Spoon.River.Gothic.Podcast

YouTube: @Spoon.River.Gothic.Podcast


In the shadows of small towns and along forgotten backroads, stories linger. The Spoon River Gothic Podcast, from Radio Vérté and Cory Zimmerman, unearths these true crime narratives, giving voice to tales that are often whispered but seldom fully told. Each episode is a carefully crafted journey, written and narrated by Zimmerman himself, whose delivery sets a distinctive, atmospheric tone. The work is rooted in detailed research provided by Rachel Laubis, Moira King, and Allison Hester, ensuring every narrative is built on a foundation of factual depth. This isn't just a recitation of events; it's an immersive audio experience designed to pull you into the heart of each mystery. For those who want to delve even deeper, Samantha Thomas provides extended written analysis on the blog, and supporters can access The Spoon River Gothic case file for exclusive bonus episodes and additional investigative material. This podcast lives in the space where the ordinary meets the ominous, exploring the unsettling truths that define the genre. Listen for stories that stick with you, long after the episode ends.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

The Spoon River Gothic Podcast
Podcast Episodes
Chapter 8 | 138 Minutes [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 30:41
DescriptionRadio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives.Think, feel, understand the sideways world around you. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyWr…
Cross-Examination | To Bear Witness [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:06:54
Radio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives.Think, feel, understand the sideways world around you. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyWritten and h…
Chapter 7 | Right-Hand Girl [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 56:08
Radio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives.Think, feel, understand the sideways world around you. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyWritten and h…
Chapter 6 | Ark-La-Tex [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 38:59
Radio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives.Think, feel, understand the sideways world around you. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyWritten and h…
Cross-Examination | 48th of an Inch [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 18:36
Radio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives.Think, feel, understand. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyWritten and hosted by Cory Zimmerman, our f…
Chapter 5 | Bubble Yum [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:02:35
Radio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives.Think, feel, understand. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyWritten and hosted by Cory Zimmerman, our f…
Chapter 4 | .69 Item [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:07:14
In this episode, we journey into the enigmatic heart of 1985 Florida, a state pulsating with life and exponential population growth. New residents flock to its shores daily, drawn by promises of economic prosperity and b…
Cross-Examination | An Affluent Man [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 39:30
Eric Stull, the nephew of Merle “Chet” Reeder, offers a poignant narrative surrounding the life of his mysterious uncle, whose life was tragically cut short during the 1985 multi-state killing spree masterminded by Danie…
Chapter 3 | The Land of Misfit Toys - Part II [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 31:37
A February 8th, 1985, armed robbery at an Ocala gas station that leaves attendant Merle “Chet” Reeder brutally murdered is meticulously dissected with the testimonies of witnesses and law enforcement officers, who piece…
Chapter 3 | The Land of Misfit Toys - Part I [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 58:40
Beginning with a poignant biblical quote, we explore the intricacies of the courtroom trial against the backdrop of moral dilemmas, community challenges, and themes of justice, personal belief, and societal norms.As the…